Custodes Futurifor the advancement of humanity

Ludwig van Beethoven 1770-1827

Contribution. He became one of the most influential composers in Western music. He kept writing major works after losing his hearing. He was baptized in Bonn on December 17, 1770. He lived in Vienna from 1792 until his death on March 26, 1827.

At a glance

ItemDetail
Dates1770-1827
FieldPhilosophy and the arts
Case typePioneer
Discrimination or exclusionNo

Factor coverage

Favorable entries (helped or barrier absent) and adverse entries (barrier or not overcome) by factor. Factor tags are this site's classification.

Barriers faced

FactorsStatement
Economic Social BiologicalA struggling father. His father, Johann, was a tenor in the Bonn court chapel. He drank heavily, and Thayer judged that this helped bring the family into poverty. His mother died of tuberculosis on July 17, 1787. At 18 Beethoven petitioned the Elector. A decree of November 20, 1789 retired his father. It paid half of the father's salary to Beethoven to support his two younger brothers (Thayer, 1921, Vol. I).
BiologicalProgressive deafness. On June 29, 1801, at age 30, he wrote a letter to his childhood friend Franz Wegeler. He said his hearing had grown worse over the last three years. He said his ears buzzed day and night. He also said that for nearly two years he had avoided society because he could not tell people "I am deaf." He blamed long-standing digestive illness. He asked Wegeler to keep it secret (Wallace, 1866, Vol. 1).
Psychological Biological SocialIsolation and despair. The Heiligenstadt Testament is an unsent letter to his brothers of October 6, 1802. In it he wrote that he had been in a hopeless condition for six years. He wrote that he had to live "like an exile." He also wrote that he was humiliated when someone beside him heard a distant flute or a shepherd singing and he heard nothing. Only his art, he wrote, held him back from ending his life (Heiligenstadt Testament, Wikisource).
Economic SocietalLoss of court income. Thayer suggests that in January 1794 it was decided he should stay in Vienna "without salary until recalled." In October 1794 the French army occupied Bonn, and the Elector fled.
Environmental BiologicalLead exposure. A 2024 letter in Clinical Chemistry reported tests on two authenticated locks of his hair. It estimated his blood lead at 69 to 71 µg/dL. The locks date from about 1820 to 1827. They cannot show whether lead exposure came before his hearing loss. The authors conclude that the levels do not support lead as the cause of his death. They say lead may have contributed to his lifelong ailments. Lead exposure is well supported. Lead as the cause of his deafness is rated C.

What helped

FactorsStatement
Economic SocietalA court post in Bonn. By 1787 he signed himself "Court Organist to the Elector of Cologne." The 1789 decree added half of his father's salary to his own.
SocialA patron in Bonn. Count Ferdinand von Waldstein befriended him. On October 29, 1792, as Beethoven was leaving, Waldstein wrote in his album. He wrote that with hard work Beethoven would "receive Mozart's spirit from Haydn's hands."
Educational SocialStudy in Vienna. He reached Vienna by November 10, 1792. He studied with Joseph Haydn and then with Johann Georg Albrechtsberger.
Economic SocialA first annuity. In about 1800, Prince Karl Lichnowsky granted him 600 florins a year. It was to be paid until he found a suitable post.
Economic SocialThe 1809 annuity. Jérôme Bonaparte, Napoleon's brother and King of Westphalia, offered him a post as music director in Kassel for 600 gold ducats a year. After that, on March 1, 1809, Archduke Rudolph and Princes Kinsky and Lobkowitz agreed to pay him 4,000 florins a year. The only condition was that he turn down the Kassel offer and stay in Vienna. Ignaz von Gleichenstein led the talks. The contract split the sum as 1,500 florins from Rudolph, 1,800 from Kinsky, and 700 from Lobkowitz. It promised payment for life if accident or old age stopped his work (Thayer, 1921, Vol. II).
Technological SocialWritten conversation. From 1818 visitors wrote their questions in notebooks. He usually answered aloud.
Social EconomicAllies in the annuity disputes. Archduke Rudolph and friends pressed his claims. Settlements in 1815 restored payments from the Kinsky estate at 1,200 florins instead of 1,800. They also restored payments from the Lobkowitz estate at the full 700 florins in the new paper currency.

Not overcome

FactorsStatement
Biological Economic SocietalHis deafness, whose cause remains unknown. According to the Beethoven-Haus Bonn, he was functionally deaf by 1818. A 2023 genome study found no genetic explanation for it (Begg et al., 2023). His annuity was also cut and interrupted. The Austrian Finanzpatent (currency decree) of 1811 briefly cut Kinsky's payments to one fifth. This lasted until a court decree of September 13, 1811 set a scale based on March 1809 values. Lobkowitz stopped payments for nearly four years after his estates were sequestered. Kinsky died in a fall from his horse in November 1812. After that, his estate paid nothing until 1815. From 1815 he received 3,400 florins a year in the new paper currency. From 1817 this equaled 1,360 florins in silver. That compares with about 1,613 when the contract was signed.

Notes

FactorsStatement
Biological EnvironmentalDisputed sources and causes. Popular accounts of his father's treatment of him rest on later recollections. They are left out here. His secretary Anton Schindler took many of the conversation books after Beethoven's death. The Beethoven-Haus Bonn states that he falsified or removed entries to inflate his own role. The forgeries were identified in the 1970s. The British critic Peter Stadlen found them first. Then the Berlin editors of the conversation books found them and labeled them in the edition's volumes from 1978. Counts of the false entries range from about 120 to 150 (Lockwood, 2020). The 2023 genome study found that the "Hiller lock," long attributed to Beethoven, came from a woman. So earlier lead analyses of it do not apply to him. Researchers disagree on the deafness. Rzymski and colleagues (2023) propose chronic hepatitis B infection as the cause. The genome study detected this infection at least in his last months. Sakai (2024) blames lead poisoning. Rifai and colleagues (2024) say only that lead may have contributed to his ailments.

Pattern summary

ElementIn this case
Door-openerWaldstein, Lichnowsky, then Archduke Rudolph, Kinsky, Lobkowitz
Institutional supportBonn court post, Lichnowsky's annuity, the 1809 annuity contract
Setback overcomeFather's alcoholism and family responsibility at 18, progressive deafness
Barrier not overcomeDeafness, reduced and interrupted annuity payments after 1811
Related barriersLead exposure (not shown to cause his deafness)

Sources

  1. Beethoven-Haus Bonn: Annuity contract, 1 March 1809
  2. Rifai, N., Meredith, W., Brown, K., Erdahl, S. A., & Jannetto, P. J. (2024). High lead levels in 2 independent and authenticated locks of Beethoven's hair. Clinical Chemistry, 70(6), 878-879
  3. ADLM press release: Beethoven had lead poisoning but it did not kill him (2024)
  4. NPR via MPR News: Beethoven's hair and lead exposure (2024)
  5. Classic FM: Beethoven hair analysis and the cause of his deafness (2024)
  6. Thayer, A. W. (1921). The Life of Ludwig van Beethoven, Vol. I (H. E. Krehbiel, Ed.). Beethoven Association, via Project Gutenberg
  7. Thayer, A. W. (1921). The Life of Ludwig van Beethoven, Vol. II (H. E. Krehbiel, Ed.). Beethoven Association, via Project Gutenberg
  8. Beethoven, L. van. Letter to Franz Gerhard Wegeler, Vienna, 29 June 1801. Beethoven-Haus Bonn, Sammlung Wegeler, W 17
  9. Beethoven, L. van (1802). Heiligenstädter Testament, 6 and 10 October 1802, transcription after Brandenburg (Ed.), Briefwechsel Gesamtausgabe, Vol. 1, No. 106 (1996). Wikisource
  10. Beethoven's Letters 1790-1826, Vol. 1 (Lady Wallace, Trans., 1866), via Project Gutenberg
  11. Begg, T. J. A., Schmidt, A., Kocher, A., et al. (2023). Genomic analyses of hair from Ludwig van Beethoven. Current Biology, 33(8), 1431-1447.e22
  12. Beethoven-Haus Bonn (2023, March 22). Beethoven's genome offers clues to composer's health and family history (press release)
  13. Beethoven-Haus Bonn. Glossary: Konversationsheft (conversation book)
  14. Rzymski, P., Zarębska-Michaluk, D., & Flisiak, R. (2023). Could chronic HBV infection explain Beethoven's hearing loss? Implications for patients currently living with hepatitis B. Journal of Infection, 87(3), 171-176
  15. Sakai, K. L. (2024). The pathography and art of Beethoven, revisited (in Japanese). Brain and Nerve, 76(12), 1301-1306
  16. Britannica. Ludwig van Beethoven summary
  17. Lockwood, L. (2020, March 26). Beethoven's empire of the mind. The New York Review of Books

Also relevant: Bell, A., Chetty, R., Jaravel, X., Petkova, N., & Van Reenen, J. (2019). Who becomes an inventor in America? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(2), 647-713. All references