Contribution. As head of agriculture at Tuskegee Institute from 1896, he taught poor Southern farmers to restore soil worn out by cotton. Many of them were Black sharecroppers. He taught crop rotation with peanuts and other legumes, composting, and growing a mix of food crops. He spread this work through 44 farm bulletins (the American Chemical Society's count) and a mobile school, the Jesup wagon.
At a glance
Item
Detail
Dates
c. 1864-1943
Field
Agriculture and food
Case type
Pioneer
Discrimination or exclusion
Yes
Factor coverage
Favorable entries (helped or barrier absent) and adverse entries (barrier or not overcome) by factor. Factor tags are this site's classification.
Born enslaved and orphaned. He was born on the farm of Moses and Susan Carver near Diamond Grove, Missouri. In 1865 slave raiders kidnapped him and his mother, Mary. He was found in Arkansas, but his mother never was (National Park Service). The Iowa State University archivist's account says Moses Carver offered a bushwhacker, John Bentley, 40 acres and a racehorse to bring back Mary and her child. It says Bentley came back with only the infant and kept the horse as payment (Fishbein, 1976). Mackintosh notes that the story of a horse given for his recovery comes from later accounts. He also notes that a 1932 American Magazine article was titled "A Boy Who Was Traded for a Horse" (Mackintosh, 1977). The same account says he was a frail child. It says he had whooping cough when he was returned and was too weak for field work (Fishbein, 1976).
Segregated schooling and racial violence. He could not attend Diamond Grove's whites-only public school. His teacher in Neosho knew little more than he did. In Fort Scott, Kansas, he saw a lynching in 1879. Some 60 years later, he noted that it still haunted him (Encyclopedia of Alabama). He then moved through schools in several Kansas towns and supported himself (Fishbein, 1976).
Rejection because of race. A college in Highland, Kansas, accepted him by mail. Then it turned him away once his race was known. He tried to homestead in Ness County, Kansas, and failed (Encyclopedia of Alabama).
Working his way through college. He ran a laundry to support himself at Simpson College in 1890 and 1891. At Iowa State he worked as a waiter and as a masseur for the athletic teams (Fishbein, 1976). Accounts of his first days at Iowa State differ. One is an education page of the National Park Service's George Washington Carver National Monument. It says he was not allowed to eat in the dining hall and ate in the basement with the kitchen staff. It says Sophia Liston, a former Simpson College student who had befriended him, came to Ames. She ate with him there and walked the campus with him. After that, he said, things went more smoothly (National Park Service, n.d.). Tom Morain writes on CampSilos, an educational site of the Silos & Smokestacks National Heritage Area. He says Carver ate in the kitchen until Etta Budd brought him into the dining hall and ate with him (Morain, n.d.).
An underfunded station. Tuskegee's experiment station got far less money than the one at the all-white college in Auburn. Most methods he had learned at Iowa State cost too much for sharecroppers. Most of them borrowed against future harvests. Contract and debtor laws forced those in debt to keep working for landowners. At first his larger salary and unusual demands, including a room for painting, put off many Tuskegee faculty (Encyclopedia of Alabama).
His former enslavers. Moses and Susan Carver had owned his mother. They raised him after the kidnapping and Emancipation. He learned to read and write in their home (Fishbein, 1976).
People who took him in. In Neosho he lived with Mariah and Andrew Watkins. In Winterset, Iowa, a white couple encouraged him to apply to Simpson College (Science History Institute, Encyclopedia of Alabama).
A teacher who redirected him. Simpson College admitted him in September 1890 as an art major. He was its only African American student. His art teacher, Etta Budd, worried that he would struggle to find work as an artist. She saw plants he had hybridized. Then she suggested he transfer to Iowa State, where her father, J. L. Budd, taught horticulture (Encyclopedia of Alabama, Fishbein, 1976).
Iowa State. In 1891 he became the first African American to enroll there. He built skills in plant pathology and mycology, the study of fungi (Iowa State University Library). He earned a bachelor's degree in agriculture in 1894 and a master's degree in 1896. He served as assistant botanist at the experiment station. He was the first Black faculty member (Fishbein, 1976).
Booker T. Washington. Washington invited him to lead agriculture and a new experiment station at Tuskegee. He began there on October 8, 1896. The Science History Institute says Washington sought him out as the only African American with an advanced degree in scientific agriculture. The relationship later became strained. In 1910 the agriculture department graduated only two students. After that, Washington removed him from charge of it and made him head of a new Department of Research. In 1912 Washington warned him of criticism of his teaching (Mackintosh, 1977).
Philanthropy and federal support. Morris K. Jesup, a New York benefactor, paid $674.50 for the wagon, mules, and demonstration supplies. A committee led by Carver designed it. It first left campus on May 24, 1906, carrying farm tools, seeds, and demonstration materials. From November 1906 his former student Thomas Monroe Campbell ran it. Campbell was made a federal extension agent that month. The wagon reached about 2,000 people a month in its first summer (Zabawa, 2008).
Recognition after 1915. He became a fellow of Britain's Royal Society of Arts in 1916. He received the NAACP's Spingarn Medal in 1923 (Fishbein, 1976).
Sharecroppers' debt and poverty limited how widely his methods were used. He held three patents, for a cosmetic and for paints and stains. They were not commercially successful (National Archives). In the 1920s his Carver Products Company could not make a commercial success of goods meant to replace purchased goods for poor farmers (Encyclopedia of Alabama).
Myths about his work. Carver did not invent peanut butter. John Harvey Kellogg filed a patent on November 4, 1895, almost a year before Carver reached Tuskegee. It was for a process that made a peanut "nut-butter" (Kellogg, 1897). Carver himself made the claim of 300 peanut products in 1937. That claim is disputed. The Carver Museum at Tuskegee credited him with 287. Historian Barry Mackintosh found that many "were clearly not original with Carver" and that peanut butter was not on the list (Mackintosh, 1977). In January 1921 he spoke to the House Ways and Means Committee on a peanut tariff. That testimony made him widely known (Mackintosh, 1977). His peanut bulletin, How to Grow the Peanut and 105 Ways of Preparing It for Human Consumption (Tuskegee Experiment Station Bulletin No. 31), came out in 1916. That was the year national peanut output passed 40 million bushels. The bulletin credited recipe books and other sources (Mackintosh, 1977, AGRIS record). The copy in the USDA National Agricultural Library exhibit is dated 1917. In an earlier journal article, Mackintosh concluded that the uses for soils and plants he developed or advocated "were not of pioneering importance in science, nor were they widely adopted" (Mackintosh, 1976). Historian Mark Hersey places him in the early conservation movement of the Progressive Era (Hersey, 2006, Hersey, 2011). Hersey argues that his lasting contribution was his conservation and environmental thinking, not his peanut products (Kaufman, 2019). Linda McMurry Edwards writes that "Much of his fame was based upon myth, but his real contributions were significant" (Encyclopedia of Alabama).
Discrimination and exclusion
Element
In this case
Form of exclusion
Born enslaved and barred from his hometown's whites-only school. A college in Highland, Kansas, accepted him and then turned him away because of his race. Tuskegee's experiment station received far less funding than the white college at Auburn.
Modern evidence it parallels
Black and white boys from families with the same income have very different adult incomes (Chetty et al., 2020). Hiring field experiments show a callback gap against Black applicants unchanged since 1989.
What got them past it
Moses and Susan Carver, who raised him, Simpson College's admission, Iowa State, and Booker T. Washington's invitation to Tuskegee.
Pattern summary
Element
In this case
Door-opener
Etta Budd, Booker T. Washington
Knowledge source
Iowa State
Institutional support
Tuskegee Institute, USDA, Morris Jesup
Built on recent work
Land-grant agricultural science, the role of legumes in restoring nitrogen
Setback overcome
Rejection by a college in Highland, Kansas, segregated schooling
Barrier not overcome
His farmers' poverty and sharecroppers' debt
Related barriers
Discrimination and exclusion, poverty, unequal access to education
Not independently verified. Sources disagree on Carver's birth year. It ranges from 1859 to 1865. This site follows the stronger or majority source.
Also relevant: Bell, A., Chetty, R., Jaravel, X., Petkova, N., & Van Reenen, J. (2019). Who becomes an inventor in America? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(2), 647-713. All references