Custodes Futurifor the advancement of humanity

Ignaz Semmelweis 1818-1865

Contribution. In 1847, at the Vienna General Hospital, he showed that childbed fever (puerperal fever) was spread on the hands of doctors and students coming from autopsies. He also showed that washing with chlorinated lime prevented it. He later found that the agent, which he called "decaying animal organic matter," could also come from living patients with purulent (pus-producing) infections. This was decades before germ theory was accepted. Kadar (2019) dates that acceptance to about fifteen years after his death (Kadar, 2019).

Semmelweis is included as a counterexample because his correct discovery was rejected in his lifetime. His case shows what happens when the conditions that helped the other pioneers are missing.

At a glance

ItemDetail
Dates1818-1865
FieldMedicine and public health
Case typeCounterexample
Discrimination or exclusionNo

Factor coverage

Favorable entries (helped or barrier absent) and adverse entries (barrier or not overcome) by factor. Factor tags are this site's classification.

Barriers faced

FactorsStatement
Social SocietalNo support from the top. His chief, Johann Klein, rejected his explanation. His appointment was not extended. The Science History Institute says Klein dismissed him on March 20, 1849, partly because Semmelweis supported the 1848 Hungarian revolution (Science History Institute). Kadar (2019) adds that his work was drawn into a dispute over academic freedom at the Vienna medical school. This turned Klein against him (Kadar, 2019). The private attending post he then held would not have let him continue his research (Kadar et al., 2018).
Cultural PsychologicalIt conflicted with prevailing beliefs. Many physicians blamed bad air (miasma). His explanation implied that doctors themselves carried the disease. Most held that childbed fever had many causes, up to 30 by one count. He argued that every case had one necessary cause. Opponents included Friedrich Scanzoni and Rudolf Virchow, who mainly blamed the uterus not contracting enough. The medical faculty at Würzburg gave a prize to an 1859 monograph that rejected his teachings (Ravel et al., 2025).
Cultural SocietalThe proof was judged weak. Kadar and Croft (2020) show that an editorial in the Gazette médicale de Paris dismissed his figures. Its reason was that a fall in mortality after handwashing began did not prove that handwashing caused it. They argue this was also Klein's objection. Animal experiments were done in 1849 and 1850, the second set with the physiologist Ernst von Brücke. They gave only ambiguous results.
Social PsychologicalDelayed publication. Ferdinand von Hebra reported the discovery in December 1847 and April 1848. But Semmelweis's own first papers appeared only in 1858, and his book in 1861. Kadar (2020) argues that Škoda's and Brücke's responses to the animal experiments led him to wait. He waited until he had enough clinical evidence (Kadar, 2020).
Psychological SocialA disputed role for his own conduct. After 1861 he wrote open letters to leading obstetricians abroad, with little effect (Britannica). In them he called continued opposition a "massacre." Historians still debate exactly why his evidence was dismissed. Kadar (2019, 2021) argues that the primary documents do not support accounts that blame the rejection on his character, education, or writing (Kadar, 2021).

What helped

FactorsStatement
SocialSupportive colleagues. Josef Škoda and Ferdinand von Hebra supported him, and so did the deputy director Karl Haller. When Semmelweis turned down an 1849 invitation to address the Vienna Medical Society, Škoda spoke for him (Ravel et al., 2025). Škoda also asked the Academy of Sciences to fund more experiments. Semmelweis himself lectured to the Vienna Medical Society on May 15, 1850. The discussion continued on June 18 and ended on July 15, 1850 (Semmelweis, 1861, p. 397, Neue Deutsche Biographie).
Social EducationalPathology and a colleague's death. He worked with the pathologist Carl von Rokitansky (Science History Institute). Each day before his ward rounds, he autopsied the mothers who had died. In March 1847 he returned from Venice. He learned that his friend Jakob Kolletschka, a forensic pathologist, had died after a student cut his finger during an autopsy. The autopsy findings matched those of mothers who died of childbed fever. From this he inferred a common cause.
Societal EconomicSuccess in Budapest. He returned to Pest in October 1850. He took an unpaid post as head of obstetrics at St. Rochus Hospital. There, maternal mortality from childbed fever averaged 0.85% in 1851 to 1857. Prague and Vienna still had 10% to 15% (Britannica).
Societal EducationalA professorship. On July 18, 1855, he became professor of midwifery at the University of Pest. Mortality in his clinic was 0.39% in his first year (Kadar et al., 2018). In 1857 he turned down a chair at the University of Zürich (Britannica).
Social PsychologicalAn editor's encouragement. Lajos Markusovszky founded the Hungarian medical journal Orvosi Hetilap (1857). He encouraged Semmelweis to publish there. The preface to Semmelweis's book is dated Pest, August 30, 1860. In it he wrote that he was acting against his own inclinations in appearing before the public again, because silence had served so badly (Semmelweis, 1861). In the same preface he wrote that, besides his dislike of all polemics, he had "an innate aversion to everything called writing" ("eine mir angeborne Abneigung gegen alles, was Schreiben heißt"). His biographer Schürer von Waldheim reprinted this (Schürer von Waldheim, 1905, p. 155).

Not overcome

FactorsStatement
Biological SocietalAfter signs of mental illness in July 1865 (Dictionary of Scientific Biography), he was committed to an asylum in Oberdöbling, outside Vienna. He died there on August 13, aged 47, about two weeks after admission. Autopsy documents indicate he was probably beaten by attendants and died of sepsis from his infected injuries (Kadar et al., 2018). The cause of his mental illness is still debated. Britannica mentions dementia or advanced syphilis.

Notes

FactorsStatement
BiologicalThe evidence. Mothers were admitted to the two clinics on alternate days. The hospital had kept monthly counts of births and deaths since 1784. In 1846, the clinic staffed by doctors and medical students lost 459 of 4,010 mothers (11.4%). The clinic staffed by midwives lost 105 of 3,754 (2.7%) (Semmelweis, 1861). Chlorine hand disinfection began in May 1847. In 1848 it was fully in place, and mortality in the doctors' clinic fell to 1.27%. That was slightly below the midwives' 1.33% (Kadar et al., 2018).
SocialLater recognition. Virchow acknowledged his merit in 1864. Scanzoni credited him in 1867. Joseph Lister also praised him.

Pattern summary

ElementIn this case
Door-openerŠkoda and Hebra, but not his chief
Knowledge sourceTraining alongside pathologist Carl von Rokitansky
Institutional supportVienna clinic until 1849, then St. Rochus Hospital and the University of Pest
Built on recent workHospital mortality records kept since 1784, Kolletschka's autopsy findings
Setback overcomePartly: renewed success in Budapest
Barrier not overcomeRejection, dismissal, death in an asylum

Sources

  1. Britannica: Ignaz Semmelweis
  2. Science History Institute: Ignaz Semmelweis
  3. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology (2018): Ignaz Semmelweis, the "Savior of Mothers"30943-8/fulltext)
  4. GMS Hygiene and Infection Control: Ignaz Philipp Semmelweis (1818-1865)
  5. Eurosurveillance (2018): Preventing sepsis in healthcare, 200 years after the birth of Ignaz Semmelweis
  6. The Lancet (2014): Searching for Semmelweis60062-3/fulltext)
  7. British Journal for the History of Science: Why Semmelweis's doctrine was rejected
  8. EBSCO Research Starters: Ignaz Philipp Semmelweis
  9. Semmelweis, I. P. (1861). Die Aetiologie, der Begriff und die Prophylaxis des Kindbettfiebers. Pest, Vienna and Leipzig: Hartleben (Wellcome Library copy, Internet Archive)
  10. Kadar, N. (2019). Rediscovering Ignaz Philipp Semmelweis (1818-1865). American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 220(1), 26-39
  11. Kadar, N. (2020). A note on Semmelweis's animal experiments and their historical significance. Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 75(4), 383-407
  12. Kadar, N. (2021). Vindicating a traduced genius: Ignaz Philipp Semmelweis (1818-1865). American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 225(3), 310-324
  13. Bauer, B. (2010). Semmelweis, Ignaz. Neue Deutsche Biographie, 24, 239-241
  14. Risse, G. B. Semmelweis, Ignaz Philipp. Complete Dictionary of Scientific Biography (Encyclopedia.com)
  15. Schürer von Waldheim, F. (1905). Ignaz Philipp Semmelweis: sein Leben und Wirken. Vienna and Leipzig: Hartleben (Internet Archive)

Also relevant: Bell, A., Chetty, R., Jaravel, X., Petkova, N., & Van Reenen, J. (2019). Who becomes an inventor in America? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(2), 647-713. All references