Custodes Futurifor the advancement of humanity

Baruch Spinoza 1632-1677

Contribution. He became one of the most radical philosophers of the early modern period. His work laid foundations for democratic political thought and for the critical study of Scripture. In his Theological-Political Treatise he argued that freedom of thought is essential to public peace. He wrote that such freedom "is absolutely necessary for progress in science and the liberal arts," since no one follows such pursuits to advantage "unless his judgment be entirely free and unhampered" (Spinoza, 1670, chapter 20). His main work, the Ethics, came out only after his death.

At a glance

ItemDetail
Dates1632-1677
FieldPhilosophy and the arts
Case typePioneer
Discrimination or exclusionYes

Factor coverage

Favorable entries (helped or barrier absent) and adverse entries (barrier or not overcome) by factor. Factor tags are this site's classification.

Barriers faced

FactorsStatement
Economic EducationalInterrupted schooling. He was born in Amsterdam on November 24, 1632 into the city's Portuguese-Jewish community. He was a standout pupil at the congregation's Talmud Torah school, but he never reached its advanced levels. At seventeen he had to cut short his formal studies to help run the family's importing business (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy).
Economic SocietalInherited debts. His father died in 1654. After that, he and his brother Gabriel ran the family firm, which imported dried fruit. In 1656, at 23, he asked the Dutch authorities to declare him an orphan. He did this so that he would not be liable for his father's debts. Doing so broke the community's rule that disputes be settled internally.
Cultural SocialExcommunication. On July 27, 1656, the ma'amad issued him a herem (ban), with the rabbis' consent. The ma'amad was the lay governing board of Amsterdam's Sephardic congregation. The ban condemned his "evil opinions and acts," "abominable heresies," and "monstrous deeds," and it barred members from communicating with him, "not even in writing," from reading anything he wrote, and from coming within four cubits of him. Steven Nadler calls it the harshest writ the community ever issued. The historian Yosef Kaplan counts forty bans there between 1622 and 1683. Others could end in reinstatement after an apology and a fine. Spinoza's was never lifted, and no surviving document states its exact reasons (Nadler, 2013).
Societal CulturalCensorship. He published the Theological-Political Treatise anonymously in 1670, and it caused great alarm. One critic called it "a book forged in hell by the devil himself." It was banned in the Netherlands in 1674.
Psychological SocietalFear of controversy. He was working on the Ethics by 1663. He set it aside to finish the Treatise. The Ethics was not published in his lifetime because of worry about the controversy it would cause.

What helped

FactorsStatement
Educational SocialA Latin tutor. With his Latin teacher, Franciscus van den Enden, guiding him, he turned from Jewish tradition toward classical literature, republican political theory, and the philosophy of Descartes.
EnvironmentalA quiet base outside Amsterdam. By 1661 he lived in Rijnsburg, near Leiden. There he wrote the Treatise on the Emendation of the Intellect and the Short Treatise. He then moved to Voorburg, outside The Hague. There he finished his explanation of Descartes's Principles of Philosophy in 1663. Later he moved to The Hague itself.
EconomicIndependent income. He supported himself modestly by grinding optical lenses. He worked at it only as much as he needed to. He gained a high reputation for the quality of his instruments.
Economic SocialFriends with means. He also received grants and pensions from wealthy admirers. The early biographer Johannes Colerus writes about the annuity from the de Vries estate described below. He says it was offered at 500 florins a year and that Spinoza accepted only 300 (Colerus, 1706). Simon de Vries was an Amsterdam Mennonite merchant and one of his closest friends. He died in 1667, and Spinoza inherited an annual sum from his estate. It let him focus on philosophy (Cambridge Spinoza Lexicon).
SocietalAnonymous publication. Publishing the Treatise without his name gave him some protection. But word soon got out that he was the author.
Social EducationalA network of correspondents. He exchanged letters with leading thinkers, including Christiaan Huygens and Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz.
SocialFriends who published his work. After his death, friends published his unpublished writings as the Opera posthuma (1677). These included the Ethics and the unfinished Political Treatise. Jarig Jelles edited the volume, and Jan Rieuwertsz printed it in Amsterdam (Morgan Library).

Not overcome

FactorsStatement
Societal BiologicalThe only work he published under his own name in his lifetime was an explanation of Descartes. The ban from his community was never lifted. He died in The Hague on February 21, 1677, at 44. The cause was a lung illness reported as tuberculosis or "phthisis." Inhaling glass dust from lens grinding has been suggested as a cause, but it is unproven.

Notes

FactorsStatement
Cultural SocialReasons for the ban. The reasons for the herem are not documented. Nadler infers them from Spinoza's later philosophy, including his denial of the soul's immortality and of the divine origin of the Law. He also draws on reports by Spanish travelers to the Inquisition, which he calls hearsay. Nadler does not think the orphan petition was the real cause. He suggests the community may also have wanted to reassure Dutch authorities that it did not tolerate such views. Spinoza reportedly responded to the ban with "All the better." A story says that a man attacked him with a knife. It rests on two early accounts that differ, Pierre Bayle's (1697) and Colerus's (1705). Nadler treats it as unconfirmed. He dates it, if it happened, before the ban. He suggests the motive was revenge by men in a business dispute, rather than religious hostility (Nadler, 2018).

Discrimination and exclusion

ElementIn this case
Form of exclusionExcommunicated by his community, and his works banned.
Modern evidence it parallelsNot covered: this document has no modern evidence on religious discrimination.
What got them past itFriends who published his work. He turned down a professorship to keep his freedom of thought.

Pattern summary

ElementIn this case
Door-openerVan den Enden, Simon de Vries, friends who published his work
Institutional supportNone accepted (declined Heidelberg)
Setback overcomeExcommunication
Barrier not overcomeCensorship, early death
Related barriersCultural exclusion (religious discrimination not covered on the factor pages), possible workplace hazard

Sources

  1. Nadler, S. (2001, revised 2023). Baruch Spinoza. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
  2. UC Davis course notes: Spinoza (Mattey, 2004)
  3. Cartwright, M. (2024). Baruch Spinoza. World History Encyclopedia
  4. Nadler, S. (2013, September/October). Why Spinoza was excommunicated. Humanities, 34(5). National Endowment for the Humanities
  5. Spinoza, B. & Fabritius, J. L. (1673). Letters 53 and 54 (Fabritius to Spinoza, 16 February 1673, and Spinoza to Fabritius, 30 March 1673), trans. R. H. M. Elwes (1883). Sacred Texts
  6. van Bunge, W. (2024). De Vries, Simon (1633/34-1667). In K. Hübner and J. Steinberg (Eds.), The Cambridge Spinoza Lexicon, pp. 566-568. Cambridge University Press
  7. Morgan Library and Museum: Spinoza, Opera posthuma (Amsterdam: Jan Rieuwertsz, 1677), catalog record
  8. Spinoza, B. (1670). A Theologico-Political Treatise, Part IV, including chapter 20, trans. R. H. M. Elwes (1883). Project Gutenberg eBook 992
  9. Colerus, J. (1706). The Life of Benedict de Spinosa (English translation of the 1705 Dutch life), reprinted in F. Pollock (1880), Spinoza: His Life and Philosophy, Appendix A, pp. 409-443. London: C. Kegan Paul. Internet Archive
  10. Nadler, S. (2018, December 20). Who tried to kill Spinoza? Jewish Review of Books, Winter 2019

Also relevant: Bell, A., Chetty, R., Jaravel, X., Petkova, N., & Van Reenen, J. (2019). Who becomes an inventor in America? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(2), 647-713. All references