Custodes Futurifor the advancement of humanity

Albert Einstein 1879-1955

Contribution. He developed special relativity (the 1905 paper) and wrote the light quanta paper. He also completed general relativity, which took about eight years, from 1907 to November 1915.

Einstein's exceptional ability mattered. But his path depended heavily on friends, institutions and timing. It also depended on the absence of barriers such as disease, extreme poverty and persecution during his most productive decade.

At a glance

ItemDetail
Dates1879-1955
FieldPhysics, chemistry, and mathematics
Case typeIn-depth case
Discrimination or exclusionYes

Cautions

  • This is one case. Historians can identify conditions that made his work possible. But they cannot prove which were necessary. Studying only famous successes creates survivorship bias.

Factor coverage

Favorable entries (helped or barrier absent) and adverse entries (barrier or not overcome) by factor. Factor tags are this site's classification.

Barriers faced

FactorsStatement
EducationalEntrance exam. At 16, two years below the usual age, he took the Swiss Federal Polytechnic entrance exam. He got the best results in math and science. But he failed languages and history. Contrary to a popular myth, he did not fail math.
EconomicReal hardship. In 1902 his father's business went bankrupt. Einstein tutored to get by. The hardship was temporary, not extreme.

Barriers that were absent

FactorsStatement
BiologicalHealth and nutrition. He grew up in a middle-class home in Germany. That meant no malnutrition, parasites or serious childhood disease.
SocietalStability. His key years (1905 to 1915) came before persecution. He completed general relativity in Berlin during World War I. But he was not drawn into the war.

What helped

FactorsStatement
PsychologicalEarly curiosity. In his Autobiographical Notes (1949), he described how a compass fascinated him as a child. He also described a Euclidean geometry book from when he was 12, which he called his "holy geometry booklet."
PsychologicalThought experiments. He used thought experiments. At about 16, for example, he imagined riding alongside a beam of light.
Psychological EducationalIndependence from authority. He disliked the rote learning at his Munich gymnasium and left it as a teenager. This skepticism later let him question absolute time.
PsychologicalPersistence. General relativity took about eight years, from 1907 to November 1915. Along the way he produced a flawed intermediate theory.
PsychologicalResilience. From 1900 to 1902 he could not get an academic position. He kept working on physics anyway.
EducationalSwiss Matura. He finished school at Aarau. In 1896 he passed the Swiss Matura with a top grade of 6 in physics and mathematics.
Economic TechnologicalTechnical exposure. His father and uncle ran an electrical engineering business.
EconomicA stable job with bandwidth. The Bern patent office paid a steady income. The workweek was 48 hours. The science library usually closed before he got off work. But the routine work left his mind free.
Social EducationalMax Talmey. He lent Einstein Aaron Bernstein's popular science books and a geometry textbook.
SocialMarcel Grossmann. He shared lecture notes. His father recommended Einstein for the patent office job. In 1912 he pointed Einstein to Riemannian geometry for general relativity. Einstein later downplayed Grossmann's role. But historians generally see it as significant.
Social EducationalThe Olympia Academy. Einstein, Maurice Solovine, and Conrad Habicht met to talk about philosophy. They spent weeks on Hume's critique of substance and causality.
SocialMichele Besso. He was the only person thanked in the 1905 relativity paper.
SocialMax Planck. He was co-editor of Annalen der Physik. He accepted Einstein's light quanta paper even though he disliked the idea. He was also the first scientist to report favorably on relativity.
CulturalFamily. His secular Jewish family valued learning.
CulturalPlace and time. Around 1900, German-speaking Europe was the center of theoretical physics.
CulturalA tradition of questioning. A philosophical tradition (Hume, Mach) encouraged people to question foundations.
Cultural EducationalThe Aarau school. The Pestalozzi-inspired Aarau school encouraged independent and visual thinking.
Societal EducationalAccessible institutions. The Polytechnic admitted foreign students and told him how to qualify. Switzerland granted him citizenship in 1901.
SocietalOpen publication. Annalen der Physik checked first papers closely. It then published later ones with little refereeing. He already had five earlier papers, so his relativity paper was probably accepted on receipt.
EnvironmentalA field ready for a breakthrough. Physics was in crisis around 1900. There was the Michelson-Morley null result (1887), Lorentz's and Poincaré's electrodynamics, and Planck's 1900 quantum hypothesis. Einstein felt someone else would have found special relativity. But he saw general relativity as harder and more original.

Not overcome

FactorsStatement
SocietalAntisemitism drove him to emigrate in 1933, after his major work.

Notes

FactorsStatement
BiologicalHis brain. Witelson, Kigar, and Harvey (1999) reported unusual parietal lobe features. Falk, Lepore, and Noe (2013) described an unusual prefrontal cortex and parietal lobes. They called their interpretations tentative. Hines (2014) concluded these studies do not show his brain structure explains his abilities. One brain and small comparison groups cannot establish cause.
Social EconomicA close call. He nearly left physics to teach high school. One recommendation from Grossmann's father changed his path.
SocialMileva Marić. A 1901 letter mentions "our work on relative motion." But most historians reject the claim that she was an unacknowledged coauthor. She was an intellectual companion during his formative years.
TechnologicalGalison's hypothesis. Galison (2003) argued that reviewing clock-synchronization patents may have shaped his thinking on simultaneity. This is a plausible hypothesis, not an established fact.

Discrimination and exclusion

ElementIn this case
Form of exclusionAntisemitism drove him to emigrate in 1933, after his major work.
Modern evidence it parallelsU.S. patenting rose 31% in the fields of Jewish chemists who fled Nazi Germany (Moser et al., 2014). So one country's exclusion became another's gain.
What got them past itEmigration to the United States.

Pattern summary

ElementIn this case
Door-openerGrossmann, Planck
Knowledge sourceTalmey's books, ETH
Institutional supportPatent office, Annalen
Built on recent workLorentz, Planck
Setback overcomeUnemployment
Barrier not overcomeLater persecution
Not independently verified. Some points were not independently verified. These are the family business, the Aarau school's Pestalozzi approach, the light-beam thought experiment, Besso's acknowledgment, the pre-1905 physics context, and Galison's hypothesis. They appear in standard biographies such as Isaacson (2007) and Pais (1982).

Sources

  1. Einstein, A. (1949). Autobiographical Notes. In P. A. Schilpp (Ed.), Albert Einstein: Philosopher-Scientist. Evanston, IL: Library of Living Philosophers.
  2. Witelson, S. F., Kigar, D. L., & Harvey, T. (1999). The exceptional brain of Albert Einstein. Lancet, 353(9170), 2149-2153. DOI10327-6)
  3. Falk, D., Lepore, F. E., & Noe, A. (2013). The cerebral cortex of Albert Einstein. Brain, 136(4), 1304-1327. DOI
  4. Hines, T. (2014). Neuromythology of Einstein's brain. Brain and Cognition, 88, 21-25. DOI
  5. Isaacson, W. (2007). Einstein: His Life and Universe. New York: Simon and Schuster.
  6. Pais, A. (1982). Subtle Is the Lord. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  7. Galison, P. (2003). Einstein's Clocks, Poincaré's Maps. New York: Norton.
  8. Britannica: Einstein, from graduation to the miracle year
  9. Einstein-website.de: Matura certificate
  10. Einstein-website.de: Patent Office
  11. Einsteinhaus Bern: Einstein and Bern
  12. Swiss Federal Institute of Intellectual Property: Einstein at the patent office
  13. MacTutor: Einstein biography
  14. arXiv: Sauer, Marcel Grossmann and general relativity
  15. arXiv: Weinstein, Einstein's friends at the Patent Office
  16. arXiv: Weinstein, The 1905 relativity paper and the light quantum
  17. MIT Technology Review: Did Einstein's first wife coauthor his 1905 paper?
  18. Redalyc: Esterson, The story of Mileva Marić

Also relevant: Bell, A., Chetty, R., Jaravel, X., Petkova, N., & Van Reenen, J. (2019). Who becomes an inventor in America? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(2), 647-713. All references