Cultural factors
Shared beliefs and norms that restrict roles, breed fatalism, and protect group identity from evidence.
Barriers within this factor
Each barrier has its own page with the evidence and sources behind it.
- 1Rigid norms and roles
Rigid norms about gender, occupation, or life path restrict the roles people are expected to take.
Evidence and sources (3 evidence points, 5 actions, 6 experimental methods)
- 2Fatalism
Fatalism is the belief that outcomes are fixed by fate or social position.
Evidence and sources (3 evidence points, 2 actions, 4 experimental methods)
- 3Identity-protective thinking
Kahan et al. (2012) found that people with higher science literacy were more polarized on climate risk, not less. According to the study, this was because those people used their skills to defend their group's position.
Evidence and sources (2 evidence points, 2 actions, 5 experimental methods)
- 4Distrust of expertise
Distrust of experts slows adoption of useful knowledge. Most people trust scientists. But where trust is lower, people are less likely to follow expert advice.
Evidence and sources (3 evidence points, 4 actions, 5 experimental methods)
- 5Materialism and status competition
Self-Determination Theory research finds that putting wealth, image, and status first is associated with lower wellbeing than putting growth and relationships first.
Evidence and sources (3 evidence points, 2 actions, 4 experimental methods)
- 6Cultural value differences
Hofstede (2001) describes how cultures differ in individualism and in tolerance for uncertainty. No single profile is better overall. Critics argue that treating each nation as one uniform culture oversimplifies (rated C).
Evidence and sources (3 evidence points, 3 actions, 3 experimental methods)
Evidence strength
These are the main findings behind this page, grouped by the strength ratings, from strongest to weakest. Each tier lists the findings that received that rating.
| Strength | Findings |
|---|---|
| Moderate | Survey measures of gender norms. Trust in scientists. The aspirations trial (a single trial). Materialism and children's learning. |
| Limited | Identity-protective thinking. Cultural value differences. Individualism and innovation. The idea of tight and loose cultures. |
| Contested or debated | Materialism as a cause of lower wellbeing. Country rankings of cultural tightness. |
Actions that can reduce these barriers
This section lists changes that governments, health systems, organizations, schools, employers, and families can make to reduce these barriers. Each action has an evidence rating on the scale used in the strength ratings (A strong and replicated, B solid but limited, C weak or debated, D contested or failed). The rating applies to the specific claim made. All sources were checked against their abstracts or full texts.
Each barrier page lists the actions that apply to it, with ratings and sources.
Who can act
| Actor | Highest-value cultural actions |
|---|---|
| Governments | Secondary school scholarships and stipends for girls, a minimum marriage age of 18 with enforcement, well-paid parental leave reserved for fathers, school vaccination requirements without nonmedical exemptions, modest guaranteed payments for vaccination instead of lotteries |
| Health systems | Training clinicians to recommend vaccines as a routine announcement, culturally adapted therapy that uses the client's own explanation of the illness, bringing proven parenting programs to new countries |
| Nonprofits and organizations | Scholarships for rural girls, information on real returns to schooling, transported parenting programs, independent testing before scaling norms campaigns or prejudice trainings |
| Schools and employers | Role-model visits by successful women, random or mixed assignment of roommates and study groups, financial education timed to real decisions, dropping one-off implicit bias exercises as the main diversity measure |
| Communities | Supporting girls to stay in school rather than relying on norms campaigns alone, enforcing marriage age laws locally |
| Families and individuals | Fathers taking reserved leave, keeping girls in secondary school, gratitude practices with adolescents (weak evidence) |
Lessons across the actions
- Changing real incentives and opportunities shifted roles more reliably than messages about norms. Scholarships, stipends, reserved paternity leave, and vaccine requirements changed behavior. Social norms marketing, brief prejudice exercises, and exposure to opposing views online did not.
- Laws work only with enforcement and good design. Marriage age laws helped mainly in cities. Fathers' quotas raised leave-taking, but they changed household work in Quebec and not in Sweden.
- Many actions work around distrust, identity, and fatalism rather than removing them. Vaccine uptake rose through requirements, payments, and routine recommendations. This happened even though few trials changed beliefs about vaccines.
Limits: Evidence that any action reduces fatalism, materialism, or identity-protective thinking itself is thin. Several actions rest on single trials in one country or one university. Many outcomes in the gratitude, financial education, and accuracy studies are self-reported or measured in surveys. Studies of vaccine lotteries reached conflicting conclusions.
Proposed and experimental methods
Each barrier also has a list of proposed and experimental methods. The list covers methods that are proposed, under trial, approved in some places but not widely used, or tried and then failed or reversed, so readers can see what is being tested. Each method has a stage label and an evidence rating in parentheses. The stage labels are Theoretical (proposed but not yet tested as an intervention), Early trial (small or first studies), Large trial (large randomized or field trials), Approved but not scaled (legally approved or running in some places but not widely adopted), In wide use (widely adopted but newly tested or questioned), Sold commercially without trials (used for polygenic embryo screening), and Failed or reversed (tested and shown not to work, or adopted and then withdrawn). The word contested is added where the evidence is disputed. Failed, reversed, and unhelpful methods are listed last and begin with "Failed," "Reversed," or "Not shown to help." A stage label shows how far a method has progressed, not whether it works. The rating shows the strength of the evidence.
Ideal conditions that counter this factor
Cultural conditions
What the evidence shows
Bell et al. found that women and disadvantaged youth are as underrepresented among high-impact inventors as among inventors overall. This suggests lost opportunity rather than lower ability. Wheatley's authorship was doubted because she was an enslaved Black woman. Wollstonecraft had no access to higher education as a woman. Julian was refused positions because of his race.
Ideal:
- A culture that values curiosity and questioning
- Tolerance for nonconformity
- Respect for evidence
- Inclusion of historically excluded groups
- Fair credit for contributions
Evidence strength: Moderate. The exclusion data are strong.
In the pioneer cases
Statements from the pioneer records that this site classifies under the cultural factor. The classification is this site's.
| Pioneer | Effect | Statement |
|---|---|---|
| Albert Einstein | Helped | Family. His secular Jewish family valued learning. |
| Albert Einstein | Helped | Place and time. Around 1900, German-speaking Europe was the center of theoretical physics. |
| Albert Einstein | Helped | A tradition of questioning. A philosophical tradition (Hume, Mach) encouraged people to question foundations. |
| Albert Einstein | Helped | The Aarau school. The Pestalozzi-inspired Aarau school encouraged independent and visual thinking. |
| Michael Faraday | Barrier | Class. Davy toured Europe from 1813 to 1815. Days before they left, Davy's valet withdrew. Faraday agreed to do the valet's tasks until a replacement was found. No replacement was ever hired, and Lady Davy treated him as a servant. In 1815 he wrote from Rome to his friend Benjamin Abbott. He said "'tis the name more than the thing which hurts" (Bence Jones, 1870). |
| Michael Faraday | Note | Beliefs, honors, and the Christmas Lectures. Faraday was a member of the Sandemanians, a small Christian sect, all his life. The only break was a brief exclusion in 1844. He served as an elder. In 1832 members of the emerging Tractarian movement criticized Oxford for giving him and other religious dissenters honorary degrees. He often said he would never accept a knighthood. But the Oxford DNB finds no evidence that one was offered. He declined the presidency of the Royal Society (offered in 1848 and 1858 according to the Oxford DNB, in 1857 according to MacTutor). He also declined the presidency of the Royal Institution in 1864. He is often credited with founding the Royal Institution's Christmas Lectures. The Oxford DNB says he set them up in 1826. The Royal Institution's own history tells it differently. It says its managers decided in 1825 to offer lectures for young people, and other lecturers gave the first series. It says Faraday gave 19 series between 1827 and 1860 (Royal Institution). |
| Marie Curie | Barrier | Russian rule and family losses. Warsaw was part of the Russian Empire. Its authorities tried to suppress Polish culture and language. They also removed laboratory teaching from Polish schools. Her father taught mathematics and physics. He was pushed out of his post for pro-Polish views, and the family took in student boarders. Her eldest sister died of typhus when Maria was 8. Her mother died of tuberculosis when she was 10 (AIP). |
| Marie Curie | Barrier | Women barred from university. The University of Warsaw did not admit women. Laboratory training was banned for Poles. So she learned chemistry in secret at a so-called museum. It was actually an illegal laboratory for training Polish scientists. |
| Marie Curie | Barrier | Hostility in 1911. On January 23, 1911, she lost an election to the French Academy of Sciences. She lost by one vote in the first round and two in the second, out of 58 votes cast. The vote followed a press campaign. NobelPrize.org describes it as drawing on antisemitism, prejudice against women, and xenophobia (right-wing papers falsely called her Jewish, according to the American Institute of Physics). In November 1911, newspapers published letters about her relationship with the physicist Paul Langevin. A crowd gathered outside her home. Svante Arrhenius of the Swedish Academy of Sciences asked her not to come to Stockholm to receive her second Nobel Prize (NobelPrize.org). |
| Srinivasa Ramanujan | Barrier | Religious rules. He was an orthodox Brahmin and a strict vegetarian. At first he turned down Hardy's invitation to Cambridge. He had religious objections to overseas travel, and his mother refused. In England, suitable food was hard to get, especially under wartime shortages. |
| Jonas Salk | Barrier | Admission quotas. A 2018 essay draws on Charlotte DeCroes Jacobs's biography. It states that unofficial quotas limited Jewish admission to most medical schools. It says Salk was rejected nearly everywhere he applied, and that only New York University offered him a place (The New Atlantis). This is a single secondary account. |
| Jonas Salk | Barrier | Rejected for research posts. He did his internship at Mount Sinai Hospital. After that, several prestigious university hospitals and research institutes turned him down. The same essay says this was because of a preference for "Ivy League gentiles." |
| Jonas Salk | Barrier | Skepticism of peers. Most virologists, including Albert Sabin, believed that only a live, weakened virus could give lasting immunity. In 1950 the polio typing committee rejected the method changes he proposed. Before the 1954 trial, Sabin argued to the American Medical Association and to Congress that a killed-virus vaccine was neither effective nor safe. |
| Norman Borlaug | Note | Critics of the Green Revolution. The broader Green Revolution has critics. They point to fertilizer pollution, water use, and reliance on a few varieties. Borlaug replied that higher yields left more land for forests and natural habitat. He called many Western environmental lobbyists "elitists" who had never felt hunger. He said Stakman or Harrar should have received or shared his Nobel Prize. NobelPrize.org notes that he always called himself only part of a team. In 1986 he founded the World Food Prize, first awarded in 1987. |
| Katalin Karikó | Barrier | Rejection and demotion at Penn. She worked at the University of Pennsylvania from 1989. There her grant applications were rejected one after another. This was because few scientists thought unstable mRNA could become a medicine (University of Szeged). In 1995 she was demoted off the path to a full professorship. That same year she had a cancer scare, and a visa problem held her husband in Hungary. She described being demoted four times. |
| Katalin Karikó | Barrier | Little interest in the 2005 finding. She and Weissman expected their 2005 finding to draw wide interest. But, in her words, "Nobody cared." A 2023 perspective in Frontiers in Immunology, citing the New York Times, reports that Nature and Science rejected the manuscript before Immunity published it. |
| Tu Youyou | Helped | Training in two traditions. Western-trained professors taught her pharmacy at Beijing Medical College. She then completed a government program in traditional Chinese medicine for scientists with modern medical training. |
| Tu Youyou | Helped | A close reading of an ancient text. More than 100 herbal extracts produced few promising results. She then reread Ge Hong's A Handbook of Prescriptions for Emergencies. The book describes soaking qinghao (sweet wormwood) in cold water rather than boiling it. She reasoned that heat was destroying the active ingredient. So she switched to low-temperature extraction with ether. In October 1971, sample number 191 fully suppressed malaria parasites in rodents. |
| Percy Julian | Barrier | No path to graduate study. He graduated in 1920 as valedictorian and a member of Phi Beta Kappa. Even so, his teachers told him "there were no opportunities for those of his color, and they could not help." He taught chemistry at Fisk University from 1920 to 1922 instead. |
| Percy Julian | Barrier | Harvard's refusal. He earned a master's degree at Harvard in 1923 on an Austin Fellowship. Harvard then withdrew the teaching assistantship he needed to go on to a doctorate. The reported reason was a worry that white students would resent a Black instructor (Kenar, AOCS). His NAS biographer wrote that Harvard "was unable, or unwilling, to offer a Negro a faculty position." |
| Percy Julian | Barrier | Closed academic and research posts. After his physostigmine breakthrough, DePauw refused him a permanent faculty position. Sources give three reasons: his race, local critics of his hiring, and the university's finances. In 1936 the Institute of Paper Chemistry in Appleton, Wisconsin, was about to hire him. The hiring stopped when an old town statute was raised that barred Black people from staying overnight (NOVA, 2007). |
| Percy Julian | Barrier | Violence at home. In 1950 the family moved to Oak Park, Illinois, a white suburb. On Thanksgiving Day 1950, arsonists set their house on fire. On June 12, 1951, the house was hit by a dynamite bomb. The family stayed. |
| Percy Julian | Not overcome | He was denied the academic career his research qualified him for. He never held a permanent post at a research university. His family faced arson and a bombing in Oak Park. Glidden turned his research back toward paint and declined to pursue more biomedical work, so he left to start his own company. |
| Ignaz Semmelweis | Barrier | It conflicted with prevailing beliefs. Many physicians blamed bad air (miasma). His explanation implied that doctors themselves carried the disease. Most held that childbed fever had many causes, up to 30 by one count. He argued that every case had one necessary cause. Opponents included Friedrich Scanzoni and Rudolf Virchow, who mainly blamed the uterus not contracting enough. The medical faculty at Würzburg gave a prize to an 1859 monograph that rejected his teachings (Ravel et al., 2025). |
| Ignaz Semmelweis | Barrier | The proof was judged weak. Kadar and Croft (2020) show that an editorial in the Gazette médicale de Paris dismissed his figures. Its reason was that a fall in mortality after handwashing began did not prove that handwashing caused it. They argue this was also Klein's objection. Animal experiments were done in 1849 and 1850, the second set with the physiologist Ernst von Brücke. They gave only ambiguous results. |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Barrier | Unequal inheritance. Her eldest brother, Edward, inherited directly from their grandfather. He was the only child to get a formal education, and he became a lawyer (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). Godwin says her schooling was the day schools at Beverley. The family lived there until she was fifteen. |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Barrier | Few paid jobs. Few kinds of paid work were open to her. In 1778 she became a lady's companion to a Mrs Dawson in Bath. She returned home in late 1781 to nurse her mother, who died in the spring of 1782 (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Barrier | Low status as a governess. As a governess she had low status. She worked for about a year as governess to the daughters of Lord Kingsborough in Ireland. There, Godwin writes, earlier governesses had been "a species of upper servants." |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Not overcome | She died on September 10, 1797, eleven days after giving birth, of septicemia or puerperal fever (Orlando Project). Godwin records that the placenta was not delivered. He also records that a physician removed it in pieces, but part of it remained (Godwin, 1798, chapter 10). This is the disease that Semmelweis showed, fifty years later, was spread on unwashed hands (see his entry). Her husband's frank memoir (1798) then hurt her reputation for most of the next century. Claudia L. Johnson writes that serious attention to her works, rather than her life, began only in the late 1960s and 1970s (Johnson, 2002). |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Note | Reception and private life. Early reviews of Rights of Woman were fairly respectful. Johnson (2002) says critics more and more read it as a political text once Britain and France went to war. Horace Walpole wrote to Hannah More in a letter begun on January 24, 1795. In it he called her "a hyena in petticoats" (the first printing, in 1798, leaves her name blank) (Walpole, 1798). The clergyman Richard Polwhele attacked her as the leading example of "unsexed" women. The Anti-Jacobin Review of 1798 indexed her under "P" for "Prostitute," which Johnson links to her criticism of standards of female modesty. In France from December 1792, she met the American Gilbert Imlay. They had a daughter, Fanny, in May 1794. After he left her, she attempted suicide twice in 1795. Her daughter with William Godwin, born August 30, 1797, became the novelist Mary Shelley (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). |
| Baruch Spinoza | Barrier | Excommunication. On July 27, 1656, the ma'amad issued him a herem (ban), with the rabbis' consent. The ma'amad was the lay governing board of Amsterdam's Sephardic congregation. The ban condemned his "evil opinions and acts," "abominable heresies," and "monstrous deeds," and it barred members from communicating with him, "not even in writing," from reading anything he wrote, and from coming within four cubits of him. Steven Nadler calls it the harshest writ the community ever issued. The historian Yosef Kaplan counts forty bans there between 1622 and 1683. Others could end in reinstatement after an apology and a fine. Spinoza's was never lifted, and no surviving document states its exact reasons (Nadler, 2013). |
| Baruch Spinoza | Barrier | Censorship. He published the Theological-Political Treatise anonymously in 1670, and it caused great alarm. One critic called it "a book forged in hell by the devil himself." It was banned in the Netherlands in 1674. |
| Baruch Spinoza | Note | Reasons for the ban. The reasons for the herem are not documented. Nadler infers them from Spinoza's later philosophy, including his denial of the soul's immortality and of the divine origin of the Law. He also draws on reports by Spanish travelers to the Inquisition, which he calls hearsay. Nadler does not think the orphan petition was the real cause. He suggests the community may also have wanted to reassure Dutch authorities that it did not tolerate such views. Spinoza reportedly responded to the ban with "All the better." A story says that a man attacked him with a knife. It rests on two early accounts that differ, Pierre Bayle's (1697) and Colerus's (1705). Nadler treats it as unconfirmed. He dates it, if it happened, before the ban. He suggests the motive was revenge by men in a business dispute, rather than religious hostility (Nadler, 2018). |
| Phillis Wheatley | Barrier | No market in Boston. In February 1772, Boston newspapers ran advertisements seeking subscribers for a book of her poems. They drew too little support. The Poetry Foundation says this was because colonists were unwilling to support literature by an African. She and the Wheatleys then turned to London for a publisher. |
| Phillis Wheatley | Barrier | Doubted authorship. The first attempt to place the manuscript with the London bookseller Archibald Bell failed. The Boston merchant John Andrews reported that Bell "could not sell it by reason of their not crediting ye performance to be by a Negro" (Brooks, 2010). The book was printed with an attestation signed by 18 men, including Governor Thomas Hutchinson, John Hancock, seven ministers, and her master. It stated that the poems "were (as we verily believe) written by Phillis, a young Negro Girl" and that "She has been examined by some of the best Judges" (Wheatley, 1773). Brooks dates the signing to October 28, 1772. |
| Phillis Wheatley | Barrier | No market for a second book. From October 30, 1779 she advertised for subscribers for a second volume of about 300 pages. It found too little support and was never published. |
| Phillis Wheatley | Note | The disputed examination. The "examination" of Wheatley is disputed. In The Trials of Phillis Wheatley, Henry Louis Gates Jr. imagined an oral examination before the signers. He wrote, "She is on trial and so is her race." Brooks points out that "Nowhere does the attestation state that the signatories had conducted their own examination of Wheatley." Vincent Carretta suspects the signers belonged to the same wealthy Boston circle as her enslavers. He suspects they had come to believe in her authorship through knowing her over time. Some historians argue that no explicit examination took place (National Constitution Center). Hollis Robbins argues that some form of examination did occur. Thomas Jefferson later wrote that religion had "produced a Phyllis Whately" but "could not produce a poet." Sources differ on the date of her freedom (her own letter shows she was free by October 18, 1773, while the Museum of the American Revolution gives 1774). They also differ on her arrival (the Society of Early Americanists gives July 11, 1761, the Poetry Foundation August 1761). |
| Benjamin Franklin | Barrier | A harsh apprenticeship. At 12 he signed indentures that bound him to his brother James, a printer, until age 21. In his words, James "was passionate, and had often beaten me." His "indiscreet disputations about religion" also made him "pointed at with horror by good people as an infidel or atheist." He ran away to Philadelphia. |
| Benjamin Franklin | Helped | Giving away his inventions. A governor offered him a patent on his stove, but he declined. He wrote that "as we enjoy great advantages from the inventions of others, we should be glad of an opportunity to serve others by any invention of ours." |
| Benjamin Franklin | Note | Slavery and the kite. Franklin enslaved people for much of his adult life. The Benjamin Franklin House museum dates his first known purchase of an enslaved person to 1735. It says he returned to Philadelphia in 1775 and shortly after gave his enslaved man Bob to his daughter Sally and her husband Richard Bache (Benjamin Franklin House). The National Park Service names Peter, Jemima, King, and Othello among the enslaved people in his household. It says he no longer owned any enslaved people when he died (National Park Service). His newspaper carried advertisements for slave sales. Late in life he became an outspoken opponent of slavery. In 1787 he became president of the Pennsylvania Society for Promoting the Abolition of Slavery. His last public act was a 1790 petition to Congress asking for an end to slavery and the slave trade (National Archives). Whether and when he flew his kite is debated. His account appeared on October 19, 1752. The editors of his papers say the timing "cannot be established with absolute certainty." But they see "no good reason to doubt" Joseph Priestley's date of June 1752. Tom Tucker argued in 2003 that it was a hoax. Michael Schiffer and Walter Isaacson disagree (National Constitution Center, 2016). |
| George Washington Carver | Barrier | Segregated schooling and racial violence. He could not attend Diamond Grove's whites-only public school. His teacher in Neosho knew little more than he did. In Fort Scott, Kansas, he saw a lynching in 1879. Some 60 years later, he noted that it still haunted him (Encyclopedia of Alabama). He then moved through schools in several Kansas towns and supported himself (Fishbein, 1976). |
| George Washington Carver | Barrier | Rejection because of race. A college in Highland, Kansas, accepted him by mail. Then it turned him away once his race was known. He tried to homestead in Ness County, Kansas, and failed (Encyclopedia of Alabama). |
| George Washington Carver | Barrier | Working his way through college. He ran a laundry to support himself at Simpson College in 1890 and 1891. At Iowa State he worked as a waiter and as a masseur for the athletic teams (Fishbein, 1976). Accounts of his first days at Iowa State differ. One is an education page of the National Park Service's George Washington Carver National Monument. It says he was not allowed to eat in the dining hall and ate in the basement with the kitchen staff. It says Sophia Liston, a former Simpson College student who had befriended him, came to Ames. She ate with him there and walked the campus with him. After that, he said, things went more smoothly (National Park Service, n.d.). Tom Morain writes on CampSilos, an educational site of the Silos & Smokestacks National Heritage Area. He says Carver ate in the kitchen until Etta Budd brought him into the dining hall and ate with him (Morain, n.d.). |
| George Washington Carver | Note | Myths about his work. Carver did not invent peanut butter. John Harvey Kellogg filed a patent on November 4, 1895, almost a year before Carver reached Tuskegee. It was for a process that made a peanut "nut-butter" (Kellogg, 1897). Carver himself made the claim of 300 peanut products in 1937. That claim is disputed. The Carver Museum at Tuskegee credited him with 287. Historian Barry Mackintosh found that many "were clearly not original with Carver" and that peanut butter was not on the list (Mackintosh, 1977). In January 1921 he spoke to the House Ways and Means Committee on a peanut tariff. That testimony made him widely known (Mackintosh, 1977). His peanut bulletin, How to Grow the Peanut and 105 Ways of Preparing It for Human Consumption (Tuskegee Experiment Station Bulletin No. 31), came out in 1916. That was the year national peanut output passed 40 million bushels. The bulletin credited recipe books and other sources (Mackintosh, 1977, AGRIS record). The copy in the USDA National Agricultural Library exhibit is dated 1917. In an earlier journal article, Mackintosh concluded that the uses for soils and plants he developed or advocated "were not of pioneering importance in science, nor were they widely adopted" (Mackintosh, 1976). Historian Mark Hersey places him in the early conservation movement of the Progressive Era (Hersey, 2006, Hersey, 2011). Hersey argues that his lasting contribution was his conservation and environmental thinking, not his peanut products (Kaufman, 2019). Linda McMurry Edwards writes that "Much of his fame was based upon myth, but his real contributions were significant" (Encyclopedia of Alabama). |
| Yuan Longping | Barrier | Soviet-style training. His training followed the Soviet theories of heredity of Michurin and Lysenko. By his own account, his grafting experiments based on them failed to breed true, and he turned to the genetics of Mendel and Morgan (People's Daily, 2009). He studied it on his own (CUHK citation, 2001). Genetics was politically risky. His college teacher Guan Xianghuan followed Mendel and Morgan. In 1957 Guan was labeled an enemy of the Communist Party and later took his own life. His later mentor, the geneticist Bao Wenkui, was imprisoned for long periods (Nature). |
| Mary Engle Pennington | Barrier | Limited science education. At about 12 she became interested in chemistry after reading a medical chemistry textbook. But the headmistress of her girls' school refused to offer chemistry (National Inventors Hall of Fame, Women in World History). |
| Mary Engle Pennington | Barrier | Limited careers for women. Before 1900, women chemists were mostly limited to assistant jobs under men, teaching, or nutrition work. She was one of 12 women to earn a doctorate in chemistry in the United States before 1900 (Science History Institute). |
| Mary Engle Pennington | Barrier | A hidden identity. Her federal civil service papers were sent in under the name "M. E. Pennington," which hid that she was a woman. She scored highest of those examined. According to the Science History Institute, Civil Service officials tried to take back the offer when they found out her sex, and Wiley stepped in. The FDA's history office says Wiley argued that the civil service law did not allow her to be refused because of her sex (FDA). |
| Fritz Haber | Not overcome | He was born to a Jewish family and had converted to Protestantism in 1892. But in 1933 Nazi race laws forced most of his Jewish staff out. He resigned rather than agree to the dismissals. In his letter of April 30, 1933 he wrote that he had chosen his collaborators by their intelligence and character. His words have been rendered freely in English as "not on the basis of their grandmothers" (Dictionary of Scientific Biography). He delayed his departure a few months to help Jewish staff find posts abroad. He worked briefly at Cambridge at the invitation of William Pope. He died of heart disease in Basel on January 29, 1934 (Friedrich, 2016). |
| Nikolai Vavilov | Barrier | A rival with state backing. Trofim Lysenko rose to prominence with vernalization, a technique of chilling soaked seed. He claimed it produced heritable changes, which geneticists knew to be false. It was ordered into use in 1931, and by 1935 it proved unrealistically laborious or even harmful (Borinskaya et al., 2019). Lysenko had Stalin's support (Embryo Project). He rejected Mendelian genetics and publicly denounced Vavilov at plant-breeding congresses from 1934 to 1939 (Britannica). |
Key figures
| Measure | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Gender Social Norms Index, 2023 (80 countries, 85% of the world's population) | Nearly 9 in 10 men and women hold at least one fundamental bias against women | UNDP |
| Beliefs about political and business leadership | About half of people believe men make better political leaders. More than 40% believe men make better business executives. There has been no improvement over the previous decade | UNDP |
| Child marriage | An estimated 640 million girls and women alive today were married in childhood. About 1 in 5 young women aged 20 to 24 were married as children, down from nearly 1 in 4 a decade earlier. At the current rate, ending the practice would take about 300 years | UNICEF (2023) |
| Trust in scientists across 68 countries | 71,922 people were surveyed. In most countries, most people trust scientists and want them to engage more in society and policymaking. Trust varied within and between countries, partly by political orientation | Cologna et al. (2025) |
| Science literacy and climate polarization | Highest science literacy and numeracy were the most culturally polarized on climate risk, not the least | Kahan et al. (2012) |
| Aspirations trial in rural Ethiopia | Households were randomly shown a one-hour documentary about people from similar communities who escaped poverty. Six months later, these households had higher aspirations. They also had more saving, borrowing, and spending on children's schooling. Five years later, they had invested more in farming, children's education, and assets | Bernard et al. (2026) |
| Materialism and wellbeing | A meta-analysis of 259 samples found that materialist values were associated with lower wellbeing (r = -0.19 for the most widely used measures). The link was strongest for risky health and spending behaviors and negative self-views. It was weakest for life satisfaction. The studies are correlational. Three longitudinal studies and a small intervention trial found wellbeing improved as people became less materialistic (Kasser et al., 2014). But a three-year study of 6,551 people using a stricter method found no within-person link between changes in materialism and changes in life satisfaction (reported by PsyPost, 2023) | Dittmar et al. (2014) |
| Tight and loose cultures | A 33-nation study measured cultural "tightness," meaning strong norms and low tolerance of deviant behavior. Tighter nations (such as Pakistan, Singapore, and Japan) tended to have histories of threats such as dense populations, resource scarcity, conflict, and disease. Looser nations included New Zealand, the Netherlands, and the United States. Tightness can support coordination but leaves less room for nonconformity. The measure is disputed. A six-country replication found different country rankings and did not support averaging individual answers into country scores (Treviño et al., 2021). Another study argued the scoring method can distort results (Venaik et al., 2021). The country examples should be treated as uncertain | Gelfand et al. (2011) |
| Trust in scientists in 12 countries, 2020 | Panel surveys ran in 12 countries from March to December 2020. In them, trust in scientists was the key driver of support for and compliance with non-drug public health measures. It was also the key driver of favorable attitudes toward vaccination | Algan et al. (2021) |
| Trust in experts and vaccination intentions | In 25 national samples across 12 countries (25,334 people), trust in medical and scientific experts was among the strongest and most consistent factors linked to willingness to get a COVID-19 vaccine (odds ratio 1.28). These are surveys of stated intentions | Kerr et al. (2021) |
| Materialism and children's learning | In 9- to 11-year-olds in Britain and Hong Kong, materialism was linked to lower exam performance through weaker interest in mastering material. In Hong Kong, materialism predicted worse grades a year later. In an experiment, British children shown a materialism prime chose easier tasks focused on performance. These children also gave up on a learning task sooner. Samples were modest. An independent longitudinal study of 404 Hong Kong secondary students found that earlier materialism predicted lower engagement and lower later achievement. That study found this worked partly through reduced motivation (King and Datu, 2017) | Ku, Dittmar, and Banerjee (2014) |
| Individualism and innovation | A cross-country study used the frequency of certain genes and historic disease prevalence as instruments for culture. It found that individualism raised innovation, productivity, and income per worker. The link held after controlling for institutions. The instruments rest on strong assumptions that they affect growth only through culture, so this is rated C | Gorodnichenko and Roland (2017) |
| Age at marriage and schooling, Bangladesh | In rural Bangladesh, the study used the age at which girls reach puberty (menarche) as a natural source of variation in when they marry. Each additional year that marriage was delayed was associated with about 0.22 more years of schooling and higher literacy. Later marriage was also linked to more use of preventive health care. The study covers one country. A later working paper using surveys from 12 countries found broadly similar links between later marriage, schooling, and employment | Field and Ambrus (2008) |
| Missing female births from sex-selective abortion | Son preference, combined with prenatal sex determination and falling fertility, has led to sex-selective abortion. A Bayesian model used 10,835 observations from vital registration, censuses, and surveys in 202 countries. It found strong evidence of imbalanced sex ratios at birth in 12 countries during 1970 to 2017. This amounted to an estimated 23.1 million missing female births worldwide (uncertainty range 19.0 to 28.3 million). Of these, 11.9 million were in China and 10.6 million in India. These are modeled estimates | Chao et al. (2019) |
| Norm against wives out-earning husbands | Using U.S. data, Bertrand, Kamenica, and Pan reported that the share of household income earned by wives drops sharply just above one half. They also reported that wives likely to out-earn their husbands were less likely to work and earned less than predicted. In their data, couples where the wife out-earns the husband reported less marital satisfaction and more divorce. They read this as evidence of a norm against wives out-earning husbands. Two later studies disputed the central evidence. One found that ordinary assortative matching closely reproduces the same income pattern, so the pattern says little about whether such a norm exists. Another, with Finnish data, traced the drop to spouses who work for the same employer (rated D) | Bertrand, Kamenica, and Pan (2015) |
| Locus of control and job search, Germany | In a panel of newly unemployed people in Germany, those with an internal locus of control searched harder for jobs. Having an internal locus of control means believing your own actions shape your future. Those who believed outcomes are determined by outside factors set lower reservation wages (the lowest pay they would accept). The design is observational. Locus of control was measured during unemployment. A later study found that unemployment temporarily shifts how people describe their own sense of control | Caliendo, Cobb-Clark, and Uhlendorff (2015) |
| Self-efficacy program for women in Uttar Pradesh | In rural Uttar Pradesh, India, 1,022 women were randomly assigned to one of two groups. One group got a nine-session program to raise generalized self-efficacy, the belief that one can handle challenges and reach goals. The other group got control meetings. The program raised self-efficacy, and the gain lasted 13 months. Work off the family farm rose by 6.1 percentage points at six weeks and 8.7 points at five months. The control levels were 13.1% and 18.7%. But there was no effect on employment at 13 months. A six-minute job promotion video shown to family members raised employment by itself. But women who received both the program and the video worked no more than the control group. This is a single unpublished working paper | McKelway (2021) |
| Fatalism and lung cancer screening | A systematic review of 72 studies looked at why people take up, or plan to take up, lung cancer screening. It found that fear was the most often reported barrier. This was either fear of a cancer diagnosis rooted in fatalism, the belief that cancer cannot be prevented or survived (22 studies), or fear of the procedure (13 studies). Cost (28 studies) and inconvenience (24 studies) came next. Most included studies measured intention to screen rather than actual screening. The review counts how often a barrier was reported rather than measuring its size | Salman et al. (2025) |
| Partisan bias in evaluating information | A meta-analysis of 51 experiments with more than 18,000 participants found that people consistently rated otherwise identical information more favorably when it supported their political side (average correlation r = .245). It found the bias was about equal among liberals (r = .235) and conservatives (r = .255). Critics argue the included studies were not designed to detect differences between the sides. So the equal-bias conclusion is disputed, though the existence of the bias is not | Ditto et al. (2019) |
| Motivated numeracy, failed replications | The idea that more numerate people use their skill to defend their side has not held up in replication. A preregistered replication of the motivated numeracy experiment found no good evidence for it. Another test covered five contested issues in a large nationally representative probability sample of Americans. It found that people were more accurate when a result fit their politics. It also found that more numerate people were more accurate whether or not the result fit. Partisan bias remained, but skill did not generally amplify it | Persson et al. (2021), Stagnaro, Tappin, and Rand (2023) |
| Party registration and excess deaths after COVID-19 vaccines | Researchers linked 2017 voter registration to 538,159 deaths of adults aged 25 and over in Florida and Ohio. COVID-19 vaccines became available to all adults in May 2021. The researchers found that after that, excess deaths among registered Republicans were 43% higher than among registered Democrats. Before, there was no clear gap. The gap was larger in counties with lower vaccination rates. The study is cross-sectional and covers two states. It had no individual vaccination records or causes of death | Wallace, Goldsmith-Pinkham, and Schwartz (2023) |
| Colonial medical campaigns and vaccine trust | From 1921 to 1956, French colonial governments in central Africa ran campaigns against sleeping sickness. The campaigns forcibly examined villagers and injected them with drugs that had severe and sometimes fatal side effects. The authors used 30 years of digitized archival records covering five countries. Areas with greater past exposure to the campaigns have lower child vaccination rates today. People there are also less willing to consent to a free blood test today, and World Bank health projects there were less successful. Exposure was not randomly assigned, so the result rests on the authors' controls and comparisons | Lowes and Montero (2021b) |
| Fake CIA vaccination campaign in Pakistan | In July 2011 the Pakistani public learned that the CIA had used a vaccination campaign as cover in the search for Osama Bin Laden. The Taliban then ran anti-vaccine propaganda. The study compared birth cohorts and districts. It found that vaccination rates fell by 23% to 39% more in districts with high support for Islamist parties (90th percentile) than in districts with low support (10th percentile). The authors conclude that information that discredits vaccination campaigns can reduce trust in health services and demand for immunization | Martinez-Bravo and Stegmann (2022) |
| Tuskegee disclosure and Black men's health | Researchers compared older Black men with other groups before and after the 1972 disclosure of the Tuskegee syphilis study. They also compared men by distance from the study's victims. The disclosure was associated with more medical mistrust, fewer doctor visits, and higher mortality. The authors estimated that life expectancy at age 45 for Black men fell by up to 1.5 years. That is about 35% of the 1980 gap with white men. A 2024 reanalysis argued the data do not credibly show that the study raised mortality. So the size of the effect is contested | Kaestner (2024), Alsan and Wanamaker (2018) |
| Experiments exposing people to materialistic cues | A meta-analysis looked at 27 experiments (3,649 people) that exposed people to materialistic cues, such as images of luxury goods or framing people as consumers. It found lower individual wellbeing (δ = -0.39) and lower concern for others and the environment (δ = -0.41). The studies were small (50 to 487 people). The authors judged 37% of them to be underpowered. Publication bias was checked only with a funnel plot | Moldes and Ku (2020) |
| Consumer framing and trust, Many Labs 2 | An experiment found that people asked to think of themselves as "consumers" trusted others less to conserve water in a shortage (77 people, d = 0.87). Many Labs 2 repeated it with 6,608 people across many labs and countries. The effect was in the same direction but much smaller (d = 0.12). The same project replicated only 15 of 28 psychology findings. The median effect size was 0.15, compared with 0.60 in the originals | Klein et al. (2018) |
| Materialism and environmental attitudes | A meta-analysis of 13 independent samples (about 2,500 people) found that people who held more materialistic values reported less favorable environmental attitudes (r = -0.22). These people also reported fewer pro-environmental behaviors (r = -0.24). Tests found no sign of publication bias. But the studies were cross-sectional, behavior was self-reported, and most samples were US students | Hurst et al. (2013) |
| Unpaid parking tickets of UN diplomats | Before 2002, diplomatic immunity meant UN diplomats in New York faced no enforcement of parking tickets. Between November 1997 and the end of 2002, they built up more than 150,000 unpaid tickets. Diplomats from countries ranked as more corrupt in survey indices had significantly more unpaid violations. In 2002, authorities gained the power to confiscate diplomatic plates. After that, violations fell sharply, so enforcement mattered as well as norms | Fisman and Miguel (2007) |
| Ancestral culture, women's work, and fertility | The study looked at 6,774 married US-born women in the 1970 census whose fathers came from 25 countries. Women whose ancestral country had higher female labor force participation in 1950 worked more. Women whose ancestral country had higher fertility had more children (about 0.4 more children per standard deviation). The pattern held after controlling for education and husbands' characteristics. Later work argues this method can be biased by which families migrate | Beblo et al. (2020), Fernández and Fogli (2009) |
| Inherited trust and national income | A cross-country study used the trust of US descendants of immigrants from 24 countries as a measure of trust inherited from each origin country. It tracked how this trust changed between 1935 and 2000. The study estimated large effects of inherited trust on income per head. Under its full model, income in 2000 would have been 69% higher in Russia and 59% higher in Mexico with Sweden's level of inherited trust. A published comment found much weaker links between inherited trust in 1935 and trust in the origin countries when using more reliable World Values Survey waves. The comment also noted very small samples behind the 1935 trust estimates | Müller, Torgler, and Uslaner (2012), Algan and Cahuc (2010) |
References cited on this page
- Algan, Y., Cohen, D., Davoine, E., Foucault, M., & Stantcheva, S. (2021). Trust in scientists in times of pandemic: panel evidence from 12 countries. PNAS, 118(40), e2108576118. DOI
- Kerr, J. R., Schneider, C. R., Recchia, G., Dryhurst, S., Sahlin, U., Dufouil, C., Arwidson, P., Freeman, A. L. J., & van der Linden, S. (2021). Correlates of intended COVID-19 vaccine acceptance across time and countries: results from a series of cross-sectional surveys. BMJ Open, 11(8), e048025. DOI
- Ku, L., Dittmar, H., & Banerjee, R. (2014). To have or to learn? The effects of materialism on British and Chinese children's learning. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 106(5), 803-821. DOI
- Gorodnichenko, Y., & Roland, G. (2017). Culture, institutions, and the wealth of nations. Review of Economics and Statistics, 99(3), 402-416. DOI
- King, R. B., & Datu, J. A. D. (2017). Materialism does not pay: materialistic students have lower motivation, engagement, and achievement. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 49, 289-301. DOI
- UNDP: Gender Social Norms Index 2023
- UNICEF: Is an end to child marriage within reach? (2023)
- Cologna, V., Mede, N. G., Berger, S., et al. (2025). Trust in scientists and their role in society across 68 countries. Nature Human Behaviour, 9(4), 713-730. DOI
- Kahan, D. M., et al. (2012). The polarizing impact of science literacy and numeracy on perceived climate change risks. Nature Climate Change, 2, 732-735. Nature
- Ryan, R. M., & Deci, E. L. (2000). Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being. American Psychologist, 55(1), 68-78. DOI
- Hofstede, G. (2001). Culture's Consequences (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
- Bernard, T., Dercon, S., Orkin, K., Schinaia, G., & Taffesse, A. S. (2026). The future in mind: aspirations and long-term outcomes in rural Ethiopia. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 141, 1383-1447. DOI
- Dittmar, H., Bond, R., Hurst, M., & Kasser, T. (2014). The relationship between materialism and personal well-being: a meta-analysis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 107(5), 879-924. DOI
- Kasser, T., Rosenblum, K. L., Sameroff, A. J., Deci, E. L., Niemiec, C. P., Ryan, R. M., et al. (2014). Changes in materialism, changes in psychological well-being: evidence from three longitudinal studies and an intervention experiment. Motivation and Emotion, 38(1), 1-22. DOI
- PsyPost (2023). Does materialism really lead to lower life satisfaction? Surprising new study suggests otherwise
- Gelfand, M. J., et al. (2011). Differences between tight and loose cultures: a 33-nation study. Science, 332(6033), 1100-1104. DOI
- Treviño, L. J., Egri, C. P., Ralston, D. A., Naoumova, I., et al. (2021). A multi-country, multi-sector replication challenge to the validity of the cultural tightness-looseness measure. Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 38(2), 735-764. DOI
- Venaik, S., Midgley, D. F., & Christopoulos, D. (2021). Do within-subject standardized indices of societal culture distort reality? An illustration with the national Tightness culture scale. Journal of World Business, 56(5), 101242. DOI
- Algan, Y., & Cahuc, P. (2010). Inherited trust and growth. American Economic Review, 100(5), 2060-2092. DOI
- Alsan, M., & Wanamaker, M. (2018). Tuskegee and the health of Black men. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 133(1), 407-455. DOI
- Bertrand, M., Kamenica, E., & Pan, J. (2015). Gender identity and relative income within households. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 130(2), 571-614. DOI
- Caliendo, M., Cobb-Clark, D. A., & Uhlendorff, A. (2015). Locus of control and job search strategies. Review of Economics and Statistics, 97(1), 88-103. DOI
- Chao, F., Gerland, P., Cook, A. R., & Alkema, L. (2019). Systematic assessment of the sex ratio at birth for all countries and estimation of national imbalances and regional reference levels. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 116(19), 9303-9311. DOI
- Ditto, P. H., Liu, B. S., Clark, C. J., Wojcik, S. P., Chen, E. E., Grady, R. H., Celniker, J. B., & Zinger, J. F. (2019). At least bias is bipartisan: A meta-analytic comparison of partisan bias in liberals and conservatives. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 14(2), 273-291. DOI
- Fernández, R., & Fogli, A. (2009). Culture: An empirical investigation of beliefs, work, and fertility. American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 1(1), 146-177. DOI
- Field, E., & Ambrus, A. (2008). Early marriage, age of menarche, and female schooling attainment in Bangladesh. Journal of Political Economy, 116(5), 881-930. DOI
- Fisman, R., & Miguel, E. (2007). Corruption, norms, and legal enforcement: Evidence from diplomatic parking tickets. Journal of Political Economy, 115(6), 1020-1048. DOI
- Hurst, M., Dittmar, H., Bond, R., & Kasser, T. (2013). The relationship between materialistic values and environmental attitudes and behaviors: A meta-analysis. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 36, 257-269. DOI
- Klein, R. A., Vianello, M., Hasselman, F., Adams, B. G., Adams, R. B., Jr., et al. (2018). Many Labs 2: Investigating variation in replicability across samples and settings. Advances in Methods and Practices in Psychological Science, 1(4), 443-490. DOI
- Lowes, S., & Montero, E. (2021a). Concessions, violence, and indirect rule: Evidence from the Congo Free State. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 136(4), 2047-2091. DOI
- Lowes, S., & Montero, E. (2021b). The legacy of colonial medicine in Central Africa. American Economic Review, 111(4), 1284-1314. DOI
- Martinez-Bravo, M., & Stegmann, A. (2022). In vaccines we trust? The effects of the CIA's vaccine ruse on immunization in Pakistan. Journal of the European Economic Association, 20(1), 150-186. DOI
- Moldes, O., & Ku, L. (2020). Materialistic cues make us miserable: A meta-analysis of the experimental evidence for the effects of materialism on individual and societal well-being. Psychology and Marketing, 37(10), 1396-1419. DOI
- Persson, E., Andersson, D., Koppel, L., Västfjäll, D., & Tinghög, G. (2021). A preregistered replication of motivated numeracy. Cognition, 214, 104768. DOI
- Salman, M., Cotton, A., Humphrey, A., Domun, T., Cheng, C., & Judah, G. (2025). Patient barriers and facilitators to lung cancer screening uptake and intention to screen: A systematic review using the Theoretical Domains Framework. BMJ Open Respiratory Research, 12(1), e003127. DOI
- Stagnaro, M. N., Tappin, B. M., & Rand, D. G. (2023). No association between numerical ability and politically motivated reasoning in a large US probability sample. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 120(32), e2301491120. DOI
- Wallace, J., Goldsmith-Pinkham, P., & Schwartz, J. L. (2023). Excess death rates for Republican and Democratic registered voters in Florida and Ohio during the COVID-19 pandemic. JAMA Internal Medicine, 183(9), 916-923. DOI
- McKelway, M. (2021). Women's agency and women's employment: How women's sense of agency affects their labor supply (Working Paper No. 1083). Stanford King Center on Global Development
Sources for the actions
- Banerjee, A., La Ferrara, E., & Orozco, V. (2019b). Entertainment, education, and attitudes toward domestic violence. AEA Papers and Proceedings, 109, 133-137. link B Moderate
- Banerjee, A., La Ferrara, E., & Orozco-Olvera, V. H. (2019a). The entertaining way to behavioral change: Fighting HIV with MTV (NBER Working Paper No. 26096). National Bureau of Economic Research. link B Moderate
- Beaman, L., Duflo, E., Pande, R., & Topalova, P. (2012). Female leadership raises aspirations and educational attainment for girls: A policy experiment in India. Science, 335(6068), 582-586. link B Moderate
- Buchmann, N., Field, E., Glennerster, R., Nazneen, S., & Wang, X. Y. (2023). A signal to end child marriage: Theory and experimental evidence from Bangladesh. American Economic Review, 113(10), 2645-2688. link B Moderate
- Bursztyn, L., Cappelen, A. W., Tungodden, B., Voena, A., & Yanagizawa-Drott, D. H. (2023). How are gender norms perceived? (NBER Working Paper No. 31049). National Bureau of Economic Research. link B Moderate
- Bursztyn, L., González, A. L., & Yanagizawa-Drott, D. (2020). Misperceived social norms: Women working outside the home in Saudi Arabia. American Economic Review, 110(10), 2997-3029. link B Moderate
- Dhar, D., Jain, T., & Jayachandran, S. (2022). Reshaping adolescents' gender attitudes: Evidence from a school-based experiment in India. American Economic Review, 112(3), 899-927. link B Moderate
- Diop, N. J., & Askew, I. (2009). The effectiveness of a community-based education program on abandoning female genital mutilation/cutting in Senegal. Studies in Family Planning, 40(4), 307-318. link C Limited
- Efferson, C., Vogt, S., Elhadi, A., Ahmed, H. E. F., & Fehr, E. (2015). Female genital cutting is not a social coordination norm. Science, 349(6255), 1446-1447. link B Moderate
- La Ferrara, E., Chong, A., & Duryea, S. (2012). Soap operas and fertility: Evidence from Brazil. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 4(4), 1-31. link B Moderate
- Vogt, S., Mohmmed Zaid, N. A., El Fadil Ahmed, H., Fehr, E., & Efferson, C. (2016). Changing cultural attitudes towards female genital cutting. Nature, 538(7626), 506-509. link B Moderate
- Jensen, R. (2012). Do labor market opportunities affect young women's work and family decisions? Experimental evidence from India. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 127(2), 753-792. link B Moderate
- Leight, J., Gilligan, D. O., Mulford, M., Taffesse, A. S., & Tambet, H. (2024). Aspiring to more? New evidence on the effect of light-touch aspirations interventions in rural Ethiopia. Journal of Development Effectiveness, 16(4), 485-498. link B Moderate
- Riley, E. (2024). Role models in movies: The impact of Queen of Katwe on students' educational attainment. Review of Economics and Statistics, 106(2), 334-351. link B Moderate
- Berkebile-Weinberg, M., Goldwert, D., Doell, K. C., Van Bavel, J. J., & Vlasceanu, M. (2024). The differential impact of climate interventions along the political divide in 60 countries. Nature Communications, 15(1), 3885. link B Moderate
- Cohen, G. L., Sherman, D. K., Bastardi, A., Hsu, L., McGoey, M., & Ross, L. (2007). Bridging the partisan divide: Self-affirmation reduces ideological closed-mindedness and inflexibility in negotiation. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 93(3), 415-430. link D Contested
- Feinberg, M., & Willer, R. (2015). From gulf to bridge: When do moral arguments facilitate political influence? Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 41(12), 1665-1681. link C Limited
- Kalla, J. L., Levine, A. S., & Broockman, D. E. (2022). Personalizing moral reframing in interpersonal conversation: A field experiment. Journal of Politics, 84(2), 1239-1243. link C Limited
- Lyons, B. A., Farhart, C. E., Hall, M. P., Kotcher, J., Levendusky, M., Miller, J. M., et al. (2022). Self-affirmation and identity-driven political behavior. Journal of Experimental Political Science, 9(2), 225-240. link B Moderate
- Nyhan, B., Reifler, J., Richey, S., & Freed, G. L. (2014). Effective messages in vaccine promotion: A randomized trial. Pediatrics, 133(4), e835-e842. link B Moderate
- van Stekelenburg, A., Schaap, G., Veling, H., van 't Riet, J., & Buijzen, M. (2022). Scientific-consensus communication about contested science: A preregistered meta-analysis. Psychological Science, 33(12), 1989-2008. link B Moderate
- Vlasceanu, M., Doell, K. C., Bak-Coleman, J. B., Todorova, B., Berkebile-Weinberg, M. M., Grayson, S. J., et al. (2024). Addressing climate change with behavioral science: A global intervention tournament in 63 countries. Science Advances, 10(6), eadj5778. link B Moderate
- Wood, T., & Porter, E. (2019). The elusive backfire effect: Mass attitudes' steadfast factual adherence. Political Behavior, 41(1), 135-163. link A Strong
- Alsan, M., Garrick, O., & Graziani, G. (2019). Does diversity matter for health? Experimental evidence from Oakland. American Economic Review, 109(12), 4071-4111. link B Moderate
- Breza, E., Stanford, F. C., Alsan, M., Alsan, B., Banerjee, A., Chandrasekhar, A. G., et al. (2021). Effects of a large-scale social media advertising campaign on holiday travel and COVID-19 infections: A cluster randomized controlled trial. Nature Medicine, 27(9), 1622-1628. link B Moderate
- Kerr, J., van der Bles, A. M., Dryhurst, S., Schneider, C. R., Chopurian, V., Freeman, A. L. J., et al. (2023). The effects of communicating uncertainty around statistics, on public trust. Royal Society Open Science, 10(11), 230604. link B Moderate
- Methner, N., Dahme, B., & Menzel, C. (2023). The "replication crisis" and trust in psychological science: How reforms shape public trust in psychology. Social Psychological Bulletin, 18, e9665. link C Limited
- Rosman, T., Bosnjak, M., Silber, H., Koßmann, J., & Heycke, T. (2022). Open science and public trust in science: Results from two studies. Public Understanding of Science, 31(8), 1046-1062. link C Limited
- van der Bles, A. M., van der Linden, S., Freeman, A. L. J., & Spiegelhalter, D. J. (2020). The effects of communicating uncertainty on public trust in facts and numbers. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 117(14), 7672-7683. link B Moderate
- Viskupič, F., & Wiltse, D. L. (2022). The messenger matters: Religious leaders and overcoming COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy. PS: Political Science & Politics, 55(3), 504-509. link C Limited
- Zhang, F. J. (2023). Political endorsement by Nature and trust in scientific expertise during COVID-19. Nature Human Behaviour, 7(5), 696-706. link B Moderate
- Dhar, T., & Baylis, K. (2011). Fast-food consumption and the ban on advertising targeting children: The Quebec experience. Journal of Marketing Research, 48(5), 799-813. link C Limited
- GNH Centre Bhutan. (n.d.). GNH screening tool. link B Moderate
- Gu, X., Wu, M., Zeng, X., Wang, Y., Zhang, Y., Dong, X., et al. (2025). The effect and mechanism of self-compassion on reducing materialism: A randomized controlled trial of an online self-compassion intervention. International Journal of Psychology, 60(4), e70076. link C Limited
- Kasser, T., Rosenblum, K. L., Sameroff, A. J., Deci, E. L., Niemiec, C. P., Ryan, R. M., et al. (2014). Changes in materialism, changes in psychological well-being: Evidence from three longitudinal studies and an intervention experiment. Motivation and Emotion, 38(1), 1-22. link C Limited: for the document's use (B for the longitudinal findings)
- New Zealand Treasury. (2019). The Wellbeing Budget 2019. link B Moderate
- New Zealand Treasury. (n.d.). Wellbeing report. link B Moderate
- Opree, S. J., Buijzen, M., & Valkenburg, P. M. (2012). Lower life satisfaction related to materialism in children frequently exposed to advertising. Pediatrics, 130(3), e486-e491. link C Limited
- Perez-Truglia, R. (2020). The effects of income transparency on well-being: Evidence from a natural experiment. American Economic Review, 110(4), 1019-1054. link B Moderate
- Berkowitz, D., Pistor, K., & Richard, J.-F. (2003). Economic development, legality, and the transplant effect. European Economic Review, 47(1), 165-195. link C Limited
- Hall, G. C. N., Ibaraki, A. Y., Huang, E. R., Marti, C. N., & Stice, E. (2016). A meta-analysis of cultural adaptations of psychological interventions. Behavior Therapy, 47(6), 993-1014. link B Moderate
- Lowe, M. (2021). Types of contact: A field experiment on collaborative and adversarial caste integration. American Economic Review, 111(6), 1807-1844. link B Moderate
- Mousa, S. (2020). Building social cohesion between Christians and Muslims through soccer in post-ISIS Iraq. Science, 369(6505), 866-870. link B Moderate
- Paluck, E. L., Green, S. A., & Green, D. P. (2019). The contact hypothesis re-evaluated. Behavioural Public Policy, 3(2), 129-158. link B Moderate
- Baird, S., McIntosh, C., & Özler, B. (2011). Cash or condition? Evidence from a cash transfer experiment. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 126(4), 1709-1753. link B Moderate
- Collin, M., & Talbot, T. (2023). Are age-of-marriage laws enforced? Evidence from developing countries. Journal of Development Economics, 160, 102950. link B Moderate
- Ekberg, J., Eriksson, R., & Friebel, G. (2013). Parental leave: A policy evaluation of the Swedish "Daddy-Month" reform. Journal of Public Economics, 97, 131-143. link B Moderate
- Foxcroft, D. R., Moreira, M. T., Almeida Santimano, N. M. L., & Smith, L. A. (2015). Social norms information for alcohol misuse in university and college students. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2015(12), CD006748. link B Moderate
- Giacobino, H., Huillery, E., Michel, B., & Sage, M. (2024). Schoolgirls, not brides: Education as a shield against child marriage. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 16(4), 109-143. link B Moderate
- Hahn, Y., Islam, A., Nuzhat, K., Smyth, R., & Yang, H.-S. (2018). Education, marriage, and fertility: Long-term evidence from a female stipend program in Bangladesh. Economic Development and Cultural Change, 66(2), 383-415. link B Moderate
- Malhotra, A., & Elnakib, S. (2021). 20 years of the evidence base on what works to prevent child marriage: A systematic review. Journal of Adolescent Health, 68(5), 847-862. link B Moderate
- Patnaik, A. (2019). Reserving time for daddy: The consequences of fathers' quotas. Journal of Labor Economics, 37(4), 1009-1059. link B Moderate
- Porter, C., & Serra, D. (2020). Gender differences in the choice of major: The importance of female role models. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 12(3), 226-254. link C Limited: (changed from B on October 9, 2026)
- Reimão, M. E. (2025). Cash and change: A replication and further analysis of a cash transfer experiment in Malawi. Journal of Applied Econometrics, 40(7), 862-872. link B Moderate
- Wilson, N. (2022). Child marriage bans and female schooling and labor market outcomes: Evidence from natural experiments in 17 low- and middle-income countries. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 14(3), 449-477. link B Moderate
- Avitabile, C., & de Hoyos, R. (2018). The heterogeneous effect of information on student performance: Evidence from a randomized control trial in Mexico. Journal of Development Economics, 135, 318-348. link B Moderate
- Jensen, R. (2010). The (perceived) returns to education and the demand for schooling. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 125(2), 515-548. link B Moderate
- Bail, C. A., Argyle, L. P., Brown, T. W., Bumpus, J. P., Chen, H., Hunzaker, M. B. F., et al. (2018). Exposure to opposing views on social media can increase political polarization. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 115(37), 9216-9221. link B Moderate
- Bullock, J. G., Gerber, A. S., Hill, S. J., & Huber, G. A. (2015). Partisan bias in factual beliefs about politics. Quarterly Journal of Political Science, 10(4), 519-578. link C Limited
- Nyhan, B., Settle, J., Thorson, E., Wojcieszak, M., Barberá, P., Chen, A. Y., et al. (2023). Like-minded sources on Facebook are prevalent but not polarizing. Nature, 620(7972), 137-144. link B Moderate
- Peterson, E., & Iyengar, S. (2021). Partisan gaps in political information and information-seeking behavior: Motivated reasoning or cheerleading? American Journal of Political Science, 65(1), 133-147. link B Moderate
- Prior, M., Sood, G., & Khanna, K. (2015). You cannot be serious: The impact of accuracy incentives on partisan bias in reports of economic perceptions. Quarterly Journal of Political Science, 10(4), 489-518. link C Limited
- Barber, A., & West, J. (2022). Conditional cash lotteries increase COVID-19 vaccination rates. Journal of Health Economics, 81, 102578. link D Contested
- Brewer, N. T., Chapman, G. B., Rothman, A. J., Leask, J., & Kempe, A. (2017b). Increasing vaccination: Putting psychological science into action. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 18(3), 149-207. link B Moderate
- Brewer, N. T., Hall, M. E., Malo, T. L., Gilkey, M. B., Quinn, B., & Lathren, C. (2017a). Announcements versus conversations to improve HPV vaccination coverage: A randomized trial. Pediatrics, 139(1), e20161764. link B Moderate
- Campos-Mercade, P., Meier, A. N., Schneider, F. H., Meier, S., Pope, D., & Wengström, E. (2021). Monetary incentives increase COVID-19 vaccinations. Science, 374(6569), 879-882. link B Moderate
- Fuller, S., Kazemian, S., Algara, C., & Simmons, D. J. (2022). Assessing the effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccine lotteries: A cross-state synthetic control methods approach. PLoS ONE, 17(9), e0274374. link C Limited
- Lang, D., Esbenshade, L., & Willer, R. (2023). Did Ohio's vaccine lottery increase vaccination rates? A pre-registered, synthetic control study. Journal of Experimental Political Science, 10(2), 242-260. link C Limited
- Law, A. C., Peterson, D., Walkey, A. J., & Bosch, N. A. (2022). Lottery-based incentives and COVID-19 vaccination rates in the US. JAMA Internal Medicine, 182(2), 235-237. link D Contested: (changed from C on October 9, 2026, because independent analyses of the same lottery programs reached conflicting conclusions)
- Mills, M. C., & Rüttenauer, T. (2022). The effect of mandatory COVID-19 certificates on vaccine uptake: Synthetic-control modelling of six countries. The Lancet Public Health, 7(1), e15-e22. link B Moderate
- Pingali, S. C., Delamater, P. L., Buttenheim, A. M., Salmon, D. A., Klein, N. P., & Omer, S. B. (2019). Associations of statewide legislative and administrative interventions with vaccination status among kindergartners in California. JAMA, 322(1), 49-56. link B Moderate
- Agarwal, S., Mikhed, V., & Scholnick, B. (2020). Peers' income and financial distress: Evidence from lottery winners and neighboring bankruptcies. The Review of Financial Studies, 33(1), 433-472. link B Moderate
- Chaplin, L. N., John, D. R., Rindfleisch, A., & Froh, J. J. (2019). The impact of gratitude on adolescent materialism and generosity. The Journal of Positive Psychology, 14(4), 502-511. link C Limited
- Fernandes, D., Lynch, J. G., & Netemeyer, R. G. (2014). Financial literacy, financial education, and downstream financial behaviors. Management Science, 60(8), 1861-1883. link C Limited
- Kaiser, T., Lusardi, A., Menkhoff, L., & Urban, C. (2022). Financial education affects financial knowledge and downstream behaviors. Journal of Financial Economics, 145(2), 255-272. link B Moderate
- Kuhn, P., Kooreman, P., Soetevent, A., & Kapteyn, A. (2011). The effects of lottery prizes on winners and their neighbors: Evidence from the Dutch Postcode Lottery. American Economic Review, 101(5), 2226-2247. link B Moderate
- Benish, S. G., Quintana, S., & Wampold, B. E. (2011). Culturally adapted psychotherapy and the legitimacy of myth: A direct-comparison meta-analysis. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 58(3), 279-289. link B Moderate
- Boisjoly, J., Duncan, G. J., Kremer, M., Levy, D. M., & Eccles, J. (2006). Empathy or antipathy? The impact of diversity. American Economic Review, 96(5), 1890-1905. link C Limited
- Carrell, S. E., Hoekstra, M., & West, J. E. (2019). The impact of college diversity on behavior toward minorities. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 11(4), 159-182. link B Moderate
- Corno, L., La Ferrara, E., & Burns, J. (2022). Interaction, stereotypes, and performance: Evidence from South Africa. American Economic Review, 112(12), 3848-3875. link B Moderate
- Forscher, P. S., Lai, C. K., Axt, J. R., Ebersole, C. R., Herman, M., Devine, P. G., & Nosek, B. A. (2019). A meta-analysis of procedures to change implicit measures. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 117(3), 522-559. link A Strong
- Gardner, F., Montgomery, P., & Knerr, W. (2016). Transporting evidence-based parenting programs for child problem behavior (age 3-10) between countries: Systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, 45(6), 749-762. link B Moderate
- Paluck, E. L., Porat, R., Clark, C. S., & Green, D. P. (2021). Prejudice reduction: Progress and challenges. Annual Review of Psychology, 72, 533-560. link B Moderate
- Bhutan Broadcasting Service. (2022, October 3). Gross National Happiness Commission officially dissolves. link B Moderate
- New Zealand Parliament. (2026). Public Finance Amendment Act 2026 (2026 No 9). link B Moderate
- New Zealand Treasury. (2025). Departmental disclosure statement: Public Finance Amendment Bill (Government Bill 165). link B Moderate