Custodes Futurifor the advancement of humanity

Mary Engle Pennington 1872-1952

Contribution. As a chemist and bacteriologist, she showed that fresh food keeps far longer at steady low temperatures. She turned that finding into standards for milk, poultry, eggs, and refrigerated railroad cars. Her work helped build the modern cold chain in the United States.

At a glance

ItemDetail
Dates1872-1952
FieldAgriculture and food
Case typePioneer
Discrimination or exclusionYes

Factor coverage

Favorable entries (helped or barrier absent) and adverse entries (barrier or not overcome) by factor. Factor tags are this site's classification.

Barriers faced

FactorsStatement
Educational CulturalLimited science education. At about 12 she became interested in chemistry after reading a medical chemistry textbook. But the headmistress of her girls' school refused to offer chemistry (National Inventors Hall of Fame, Women in World History).
Societal EducationalA certificate instead of a degree. She finished the coursework at the University of Pennsylvania's Towne Scientific School, where she was the only woman in her class. But in 1892 she received a certificate of proficiency instead of a bachelor's degree, because the university did not grant degrees to women. Penn let women into the Towne School only as "special students" who could earn certificates but not undergraduate degrees. It gave no bachelor's degree to a woman until 1914 (University of Pennsylvania Archives).
Societal Economic CulturalLimited careers for women. Before 1900, women chemists were mostly limited to assistant jobs under men, teaching, or nutrition work. She was one of 12 women to earn a doctorate in chemistry in the United States before 1900 (Science History Institute).
Economic SocietalFew openings. Few jobs were open to women chemists. So she held research fellowships in botany at Penn (1895 to 1897) and in physiological chemistry at Yale (1897 to 1898, per Women in World History and the Yale University Library, with 1896 given by the Penn Archives). In 1898 she cofounded her own laboratory in Philadelphia.
Societal CulturalA hidden identity. Her federal civil service papers were sent in under the name "M. E. Pennington," which hid that she was a woman. She scored highest of those examined. According to the Science History Institute, Civil Service officials tried to take back the offer when they found out her sex, and Wiley stepped in. The FDA's history office says Wiley argued that the civil service law did not allow her to be refused because of her sex (FDA).

What helped

FactorsStatement
Educational SocialSupportive faculty. Penn professors used a rarely invoked university statute for "extraordinary cases" to admit her to graduate study. She earned a doctorate in chemistry in 1895, at 22. Her dissertation was on derivatives of columbium and tantalum. The Science History Institute says her professors, particularly the chemist Edgar Fahs Smith, accepted her into the PhD program. Smith later wrote that she had done this work "in this laboratory in 1895" (Smith, 1905).
Economic SocietalHer own laboratory and local results. Her Philadelphia Clinical Laboratory did bacteriological analyses for physicians. Its report on Philadelphia's milk supply led to a job running the city health department's bacteriological laboratory (1901 to 1907, per Women in World History). Health boards across the country adopted the milk standards she developed.
Social SocietalHarvey Wiley. The chief of the Bureau of Chemistry hired her. According to the Science History Institute, he also stepped in to keep her in the post. She began working with him on cold storage in 1905. In 1907 she became the first chief of the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Food Research Laboratory. It was created to support enforcement of the 1906 Pure Food and Drugs Act. At her insistence the laboratory was in Philadelphia rather than Washington. Its staff ranged from 4 to 50.
Social EconomicPersuading industry rather than punishing it. Instead of closing unsanitary egg-breaking plants, she persuaded them to refrigerate and use sanitary methods. She also helped create the first scientific egg-grading charts (Women in World History). Her laboratory found that poultry kept good quality for a year at zero degrees Fahrenheit (Penn Gazette, 2022).
Societal TechnologicalWartime demand. During World War I she took part in about 500 test journeys of refrigerated railcars over two years. She slept in cabooses on railroad sidings, while her team recorded temperatures with electric thermometers (Science History Institute). In 1917 she found that only about 3,000 of some 40,000 refrigerator cars were insulated well enough for meat (Women in World History). Herbert Hoover presented her with the Notable Service Medal for her wartime work (1918 per Women in World History, 1919 per Penn Gazette).
EconomicA second career in industry. She left government in 1919. She then directed research at the American Balsa Company, which doubled her government salary, and later opened her own consulting office. From 1923 to 1931 she directed the Household Refrigeration Bureau of the National Association of Ice Industries. The bureau taught the public how to refrigerate food at home (Women in World History).
Social SocietalProfessional recognition. In 1920 she became the first woman member of the American Society of Refrigerating Engineers. The society elected her a fellow in 1947 (1948 per ASHRAE) (Women in World History, Science History Institute).

Not overcome

FactorsStatement
Societal EducationalPenn did not award her the bachelor's degree she had earned, and no source checked records a later award. Her entry into federal service depended on hiding that she was a woman.

Notes

FactorsStatement
Economic TechnologicalLater work. She worked as a consultant from 1919 to 1952. She held five patents (Smithsonian Lemelson Center, Penn Gazette), including a poultry-cooling rack (1912) and a method of treating eggs (1935). She received the American Chemical Society's Garvan Medal in 1940. In 2018 she was inducted into the National Inventors Hall of Fame. The Household Refrigeration Bureau belonged to the National Association of Ice Industries, the ice industry's trade body (Women in World History).

Discrimination and exclusion

ElementIn this case
Form of exclusionGiven a certificate instead of the bachelor's degree she had earned. Hired into federal service only under her initials.
Modern evidence it parallelsWomen have about two-thirds of the legal rights of men, and no economy gives women equal economic opportunities (World Bank, 2026).
What got them past itPenn faculty who used a rarely used statute to admit her to doctoral study, and Harvey Wiley, who backed her appointment.

Pattern summary

ElementIn this case
Door-openerPenn faculty, Harvey Wiley
Knowledge sourceUniversity of Pennsylvania doctorate
Institutional supportUSDA Bureau of Chemistry, Philadelphia health department
Built on recent workThe 1906 Pure Food and Drugs Act, bacteriology
Setback overcomeDenied a bachelor's degree, admitted to doctoral study anyway
Barrier not overcomeNever received her bachelor's degree
Related barriersDiscrimination and exclusion, unequal access to education, infectious disease
Not independently verified. Sources disagree on the year Pennington began leading the Food Research Laboratory (1906 to 1908). Two of her five patents, the 1932 egg-color scale and the egg-freezing method, were not found in patent records. Whether Penn ever later gave her the bachelor's degree was not reconfirmed, and no source checked says it did. This site follows the stronger or majority source.

Sources

  1. FDA: Mary Engle Pennington, cold chain food safety
  2. University of Pennsylvania Archives: Women at Penn, distinguished early graduates
  3. Science History Institute: Mary Engle Pennington
  4. National Inventors Hall of Fame: Mary Engle Pennington
  5. Penn Gazette (April 2022): Ice woman
  6. Schafer, E. D. Women in World History (Encyclopedia.com): Pennington, Mary Engle (1872-1952)
  7. Stephan, K. D. (1996). Mary Engle Pennington, food refrigeration engineer. ASEE Conference Proceedings
  8. Smithsonian Lemelson Center for the Study of Invention and Innovation: Egg-citing inventions
  9. Google Patents: US 1,020,575, Poultry-cooling rack (1912), and US 1,996,171, Method of treating eggs (1935)
  10. Smith, E. F. (1905). Observations on columbium and tantalum. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 44, 151-158 (BioStor scan, Internet Archive)
  11. Yale University Library (2020). Women in Science and Engineering at Yale: Mary Engle Pennington (1872-1952), Ph.D.
  12. Heggie, B. (1941, September 6). Profiles: Ice woman. The New Yorker, 23-26, 29-30

Also relevant: Bell, A., Chetty, R., Jaravel, X., Petkova, N., & Van Reenen, J. (2019). Who becomes an inventor in America? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(2), 647-713. All references