Custodes Futurifor the advancement of humanity

Norman Borlaug 1914-2009

Contribution. He developed high-yield wheat that resisted disease. It helped prevent famine in Mexico, India, and Pakistan. Mexico became self-sufficient in wheat in 1956. He won the Nobel Peace Prize in 1970.

At a glance

ItemDetail
Dates1914-2009
FieldAgriculture and food
Case typePioneer
Discrimination or exclusionNo

Factor coverage

Favorable entries (helped or barrier absent) and adverse entries (barrier or not overcome) by factor. Factor tags are this site's classification.

Barriers faced

FactorsStatement
Economic Educational EnvironmentalA poor farm childhood. He grew up on an Iowa farm during hard economic times. He began school in a one-room rural school. There was no school bus to the high school 12 miles away. He left for college with $50 of his own and $11 from his grandfather (University of Minnesota).
EducationalA failed entrance exam. In 1933 he failed the University of Minnesota entrance examination and nearly went home. Instead he was admitted to the university's new General College, a junior college for underprepared students. After two quarters he moved to the forestry program (University of Minnesota). In a 2008 interview he said he had to take the exam because his ninth-grade credits did not count.
EconomicThe Depression. During the Depression he was "usually broke and often hungry," according to the University of Minnesota. He worked at a coffee shop for meals. He took federal work-study jobs funded by the National Youth Administration. In 1936 he missed a quarter to work for the U.S. Forest Service, where he supervised Civilian Conservation Corps workers (University of Minnesota). In 1937 the Forest Service withdrew a promised permanent job for budget reasons.
Societal Technological SocialRuins and resistance in Mexico. He arrived in Mexico in 1944. The Chapingo research station near Mexico City was in ruins. Because of wartime shortages, no new farm machinery could be bought. Consultant H. K. Hayes objected to breeding at two sites a year. He said it was unorthodox because seed needed a year of "rest." Program director George Harrar refused it as too expensive. Harrar gave permission in 1947, after Borlaug threatened to resign and Stakman mediated (University of Minnesota).
Societal SocialResistance in Pakistan. In Pakistan in 1964, local plant breeders and agronomists resisted the Mexican wheats. Trial plots were not properly sown, fertilized, or watered. Borlaug later said the main obstacle was "the government policy maker," who controlled prices and the supply of fertilizer (Academy of Achievement). In 1965 war broke out between India and Pakistan while the first large seed shipments were arriving.

What helped

FactorsStatement
Social EducationalA mentor who took a chance. The Forest Service offer fell through. Then plant pathologist Elvin C. Stakman gave him a job counting rust spores on microscope slides. Stakman then admitted him to graduate study. He earned a PhD in plant pathology in 1942 (National Academy of Sciences). Stakman and Harrar recruited him in 1943. At his wife Margaret's urging, he left a microbiology job at DuPont for Mexico in 1944.
Societal EconomicInstitutional backing. He organized and directed the Cooperative Wheat Research and Production Program. This was a joint project of the Mexican government and the Rockefeller Foundation. He later led the wheat program of the International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT).
Social EducationalInterdisciplinary teamwork and local help. The program combined genetics, plant breeding, plant pathology, entomology, agronomy, soil science, and cereal technology. Mexican scientist Ignacio Narváez became his partner. He trained local farm boys, and they became skilled technicians. Yaqui Valley farmers lent equipment.
TechnologicalShuttle breeding. He grew one generation in summer in the highlands near Mexico City (Toluca, at 2,090 meters). He grew the next in winter at Ciudad Obregón in Sonora (38 meters). This gave two generations a year instead of one, which at least doubled progress. It also produced wheats that were insensitive to day length and grew well in many countries.
TechnologicalOthers' work. From 1954 he crossed his rust-resistant wheats with Norin 10. This was a Japanese dwarf wheat that Orville Vogel of Washington State University had received from Cecil Salmon. Its short, stiff straw let plants carry heavy, fertilized grain heads without falling over.
Societal SocialDemonstrations and political allies. He gave seed to farmers and relied on demonstrations in their fields. In Pakistan, President Ayub Khan released funds for seed, fertilizer, training, and price supports. In India, M. S. Swaminathan and Agriculture Minister C. Subramaniam backed the program. In 1965 Pakistan imported 350 tons and India 250 tons of Mexican seed (Nobel lecture).
SocietalResults. By 1963, 95% of Mexico's wheat used his varieties. The harvest was six times 1944's. From 1965 to 1970, wheat yields nearly doubled in Pakistan and India.

Not overcome

FactorsStatement
Societal EnvironmentalHis work in sub-Saharan Africa stayed unfinished. From the 1980s, environmental groups pressed donors to stop funding fertilizer-based farming projects in Africa. Lobbying blocked his first efforts there. He worked with the Sasakawa Africa Association and Sasakawa-Global 2000 from the mid-1980s until his death in 2009. His family reported that his last words were about African farmers. A new stem rust race was found in Uganda in 1998 to 1999 (Ug99). It can overcome resistance genes bred into wheat since the 1960s.

Notes

FactorsStatement
CulturalCritics of the Green Revolution. The broader Green Revolution has critics. They point to fertilizer pollution, water use, and reliance on a few varieties. Borlaug replied that higher yields left more land for forests and natural habitat. He called many Western environmental lobbyists "elitists" who had never felt hunger. He said Stakman or Harrar should have received or shared his Nobel Prize. NobelPrize.org notes that he always called himself only part of a team. In 1986 he founded the World Food Prize, first awarded in 1987.

Pattern summary

ElementIn this case
Door-openerStakman, Harrar, Rockefeller program
Knowledge sourceForestry at Minnesota, then plant pathology under Stakman
Institutional supportRockefeller Foundation
Built on recent workNorin 10, Vogel
Setback overcomeFailed entrance exam, Depression poverty, opposition to shuttle breeding
Barrier not overcomeAfrica work unfinished
Not independently verified. Sources differ on the year of his master's degree. They give 1939 (Nobel biography), 1940 (Phillips, 2013), or 1941, when the University of Minnesota says his thesis was accepted. Sources also differ on when he started at DuPont. They give October 1941 (University of Minnesota) or 1942 (Nobel biography and Phillips, 2013). So his entry gives neither year.

Sources

  1. NobelPrize.org: Borlaug Nobel Lecture
  2. CSA News: 100 Years of Dr. Norman Borlaug
  3. University of Minnesota: Norman Borlaug, the formative years, 1914-1933
  4. NobelPrize.org. (1970). Norman Borlaug, Biographical. From Les Prix Nobel, republished in Nobel Lectures, Peace 1951-1970
  5. Phillips, R. L. (2013). Norman E. Borlaug 1914-2009. Biographical Memoirs, National Academy of Sciences
  6. University of Minnesota, College of Food, Agricultural and Natural Resource Sciences. Norman Borlaug: The Undergraduate
  7. University of Minnesota, CFANS. Norman Borlaug: The Accidental Graduate Student
  8. University of Minnesota, CFANS. Norman Borlaug: The Researcher
  9. University of Minnesota, CFANS. 1933-1953: Three Degrees, Industrial Research, the Mexican Project
  10. University of Minnesota, CFANS. 1961-1969: Mexican 'Miracle Wheat'
  11. University of Minnesota, CFANS. 1970-1990: On the World Stage
  12. University of Minnesota, CFANS. 1990-2009: A Well Lived Life
  13. Academy of Achievement. (2008, May 12). Norman E. Borlaug interview and biography
  14. NobelPrize.org. (2023). Norman Borlaug, Facts

Also relevant: Bell, A., Chetty, R., Jaravel, X., Petkova, N., & Van Reenen, J. (2019). Who becomes an inventor in America? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(2), 647-713. All references