Contribution. He proposed the experiment that showed lightning is electrical. It was first carried out in France in May 1752. However, he was not the first to suggest the idea (Founders Online). He invented the lightning rod, which the IEEE calls "the first practical engineering application of electricity" (IEEE Engineering and Technology History Wiki). He also founded lasting institutions that gave others access to books and education. He helped draft the Declaration of Independence.
At a glance
Item
Detail
Dates
1706-1790
Field
Physics, chemistry, and mathematics
Case type
Pioneer
Discrimination or exclusion
Yes, as a participant, not a target
Factor coverage
Favorable entries (helped or barrier absent) and adverse entries (barrier or not overcome) by factor. Factor tags are this site's classification.
Little schooling. He was one of seventeen children of Josiah Franklin, a Boston candle and soap maker. He started grammar school at 8. After less than a year, his father took him out, citing "the expense of a college education." At a writing and arithmetic school he "failed in the arithmetic." At 10 his father took him out to work in the family shop (Autobiography).
A harsh apprenticeship. At 12 he signed indentures that bound him to his brother James, a printer, until age 21. In his words, James "was passionate, and had often beaten me." His "indiscreet disputations about religion" also made him "pointed at with horror by good people as an infidel or atheist." He ran away to Philadelphia.
A broken promise abroad. Pennsylvania's governor, William Keith, urged him to go to London to buy printing equipment. Keith promised letters of recommendation and a letter of credit. None arrived. The merchant Thomas Denham told him that no one who knew Keith relied on him. Franklin worked in London printing houses for about eighteen months before returning.
Skepticism of peers. At first the Royal Society judged his letters on electricity not worth printing in its Transactions. A paper on how lightning and electricity are the same was "laughed at by the connoisseurs." In France, the Abbé Nollet was tutor in natural philosophy to the royal family. He doubted that such a work came from America. He published letters denying Franklin's experiments.
Books through his trade. His father chose printing for him because of his "bookish inclination." As an apprentice he borrowed books overnight from booksellers' apprentices. A tradesman, Matthew Adams, lent him books from his own collection.
A network of peers. In 1727 he formed the Junto, a club for mutual improvement that met on Friday evenings. Members posed questions on morals, politics, or natural philosophy and read essays every three months.
Time to think. In 1746 he saw a Dr. Spence's electrical demonstrations in Boston. He later bought Spence's apparatus. In 1748 he took David Hall as a partner. Hall ran the printing office and paid Franklin a share of the profits for eighteen years. This "moderate fortune" gave him leisure "for philosophical studies and amusements."
A door-opener in London. Peter Collinson, a Fellow of the Royal Society, gave the Library Company a glass tube for electrical experiments. Franklin reported his results to Collinson by letter. The Royal Society passed over them. The physician John Fothergill then advised printing them. Collinson arranged their publication in London in 1751 as Experiments and Observations on Electricity.
Recognition after confirmation. Thomas-François Dalibard's assistant at Marly and then Delor in Paris carried out his proposed experiment in May 1752 (Founders Online). A contemporary letter described Delor as a "master of experimental philosophy." The editors of Franklin's papers have not fully identified him (Founders Online). After that, the Royal Society printed a summary of his letters. It awarded him the Copley Medal for 1753, its oldest and most prestigious award (Royal Society). Harvard gave him a Master of Arts degree on July 25, 1753. Harvard's archives call it "generally considered to be the first true honorary degree awarded by Harvard" (Harvard University Archives). Yale gave him the same degree in September 1753 (Papers of Benjamin Franklin, volume 5). Jean-Baptiste Le Roy of the French Academy of Sciences answered Nollet.
The Library Company. Junto members first pooled their own books. Then, in 1731, he proposed the Library Company of Philadelphia. He later called it "the mother of all the North American subscription libraries." Its first fifty subscribers, "mostly young tradesmen," paid forty shillings each.
The American Philosophical Society. He founded the American Philosophical Society in 1743 (American Philosophical Society). The Autobiography gives the date as 1744.
An academy for Philadelphia. His 1749 pamphlet Proposals Relating to the Education of Youth in Pensilvania led to an academy. It opened in January 1751, with a charity school for poor children alongside it. The academy became the University of Pennsylvania (Penn University Archives).
Giving away his inventions. A governor offered him a patent on his stove, but he declined. He wrote that "as we enjoy great advantages from the inventions of others, we should be glad of an opportunity to serve others by any invention of ours."
He never gained much mathematics. He taught himself arithmetic from Cocker's textbook after having "twice failed in learning" it at school. But by his own account he learned only "the little geometry" in navigation books. He "never proceeded far in that science." His leisure for science also did not last, because "the publick, now considering me as a man of leisure, laid hold of me for their purposes." He died in Philadelphia on April 17, 1790, aged 84.
Slavery and the kite. Franklin enslaved people for much of his adult life. The Benjamin Franklin House museum dates his first known purchase of an enslaved person to 1735. It says he returned to Philadelphia in 1775 and shortly after gave his enslaved man Bob to his daughter Sally and her husband Richard Bache (Benjamin Franklin House). The National Park Service names Peter, Jemima, King, and Othello among the enslaved people in his household. It says he no longer owned any enslaved people when he died (National Park Service). His newspaper carried advertisements for slave sales. Late in life he became an outspoken opponent of slavery. In 1787 he became president of the Pennsylvania Society for Promoting the Abolition of Slavery. His last public act was a 1790 petition to Congress asking for an end to slavery and the slave trade (National Archives). Whether and when he flew his kite is debated. His account appeared on October 19, 1752. The editors of his papers say the timing "cannot be established with absolute certainty." But they see "no good reason to doubt" Joseph Priestley's date of June 1752. Tom Tucker argued in 2003 that it was a hoax. Michael Schiffer and Walter Isaacson disagree (National Constitution Center, 2016).
Discrimination and exclusion
Element
In this case
Form of exclusion
Not a target. He enslaved people for much of his adult life, from at least 1735, before leading an abolition society.
Modern evidence it parallels
Shows that the people who advance knowledge can also keep up the barriers that exclude others.
What got them past it
Not applicable.
Pattern summary
Element
In this case
Door-opener
Peter Collinson, John Fothergill
Knowledge source
Books through the printing trade, the Junto, the Library Company
Institutional support
Royal Society recognition, after initial dismissal
Built on recent work
Spence's demonstrations, apparatus and accounts sent by Collinson
Setback overcome
Two years of schooling, harsh apprenticeship, broken promise of support, early dismissal by the Royal Society and Nollet
Barrier not overcome
Little mathematics, public duties that took his time for science
Also relevant: Bell, A., Chetty, R., Jaravel, X., Petkova, N., & Van Reenen, J. (2019). Who becomes an inventor in America? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(2), 647-713. All references