Custodes Futurifor the advancement of humanity

Fritz Haber 1868-1934

Contribution. He showed how to make ammonia directly from nitrogen and hydrogen. The BASF engineer Carl Bosch scaled the method up into the Haber-Bosch process for synthetic nitrogen fertilizer. Erisman et al. (2008) estimate that nitrogen from the Haber-Bosch process supported about 48% of the world's population in 2008. He received the 1918 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, awarded in 1919. In his Nobel lecture he said that the nitrate deposits of Chile could not meet demand that would rise "to millions of tons" (Haber, 1920).

At a glance

ItemDetail
Dates1868-1934
FieldAgriculture and food
Case typePioneer
Discrimination or exclusionYes

Factor coverage

Favorable entries (helped or barrier absent) and adverse entries (barrier or not overcome) by factor. Factor tags are this site's classification.

Barriers faced

FactorsStatement
Social EconomicFamily expectations. His father, a merchant in dyes and pharmaceuticals in Breslau, expected him to train for the family business. Haber went to university only after his uncle Hermann helped persuade his father (Friedrich, 2016). After his 1891 doctorate he tried his father's business for about six months, and it did not suit him (Dictionary of Scientific Biography).
Educational SocialGaps in training. Short jobs in industry showed him "pressing deficiencies" in his education, particularly in chemical technology. He applied several times to work with the physical chemist Wilhelm Ostwald but never got the post. He later said he had never attended a lecture on physical chemistry other than his own (Friedrich, 2016).
TechnologicalA reaction that seemed impractical. His first measurements near 1,000 degrees Celsius gave ammonia contents of only 1/200% to 1/80%. In 1905 he judged it "useless to pursue the problem further," and he shared "the widely-held opinion" that such a gas reaction under high pressure could not be run industrially (Haber, 1920). In 1920 the industrial process ran at about 200 atmospheres and 500 to 600 degrees Celsius.
SocialPublic criticism. Walther Nernst said in talks and in print that Haber's equilibrium value was "far from the truth" (Friedrich, 2016). The Dictionary of Scientific Biography says the error lay in a constant Nernst used in his calculations. Their exchange took place at the Bunsen Society meeting in Hamburg in 1907 (Max Planck Institute for the History of Science). Nernst published an article on the ammonia equilibrium in August 1907 (Nernst, 1907).

What helped

FactorsStatement
Social EducationalFamily support for science. His uncle Hermann, who owned a liberal newspaper, gave him space in his apartment for chemical experiments when he was a schoolboy (Friedrich, 2016).
Educational EconomicAn academic base. He held posts at the Karlsruhe Polytechnic from 1894 to 1911. He started as assistant to Hans Bunte. He became a lecturer (Privatdozent) in 1896, associate professor in 1898, and professor in 1906.
Economic TechnologicalAn industrial question. He first measured the ammonia equilibrium in 1903, in answer to a question from an Austrian chemical company.
Social TechnologicalA challenge and a collaborator. Nernst's criticism led Haber to repeat his measurements. With Robert Le Rossignol, from William Ramsay's London laboratory, he turned to high pressures. At about 200 atmospheres and with an osmium catalyst, they got a yield of about 18% (Friedrich, 2016).
Economic SocialIndustry partnership. BASF partnered with him in 1908. In 1909 he showed a working ammonia apparatus to BASF representatives (BASF). On Bosch's advice BASF bought the rights. During World War I Haber received royalties of about fifteen marks per ton of fixed nitrogen (Dictionary of Scientific Biography).
Technological SocialCarl Bosch and Alwin Mittasch. Bosch led the industrial scale-up, and Mittasch led the catalyst work. They replaced osmium with iron. They used a Swedish ore whose impurities made the catalyst more active (Friedrich, 2016). The first ammonia synthesis plant opened at Oppau on September 9, 1913 (BASF).
Economic SocialA patron and a new institute. The banker Leopold Koppel funded a Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry in Berlin-Dahlem, which opened in 1912. On the recommendation of Svante Arrhenius, Haber became its first director.

Not overcome

FactorsStatement
Societal CulturalHe was born to a Jewish family and had converted to Protestantism in 1892. But in 1933 Nazi race laws forced most of his Jewish staff out. He resigned rather than agree to the dismissals. In his letter of April 30, 1933 he wrote that he had chosen his collaborators by their intelligence and character. His words have been rendered freely in English as "not on the basis of their grandmothers" (Dictionary of Scientific Biography). He delayed his departure a few months to help Jewish staff find posts abroad. He worked briefly at Cambridge at the invitation of William Pope. He died of heart disease in Basel on January 29, 1934 (Friedrich, 2016).

Notes

FactorsStatement
Societal TechnologicalPoison gas. Haber also directed Germany's development of poison gas in World War I. He supervised the first large chlorine attack, at Ypres on April 22, 1915. He argued that gas could break the deadlock of trench warfare and shorten the war. The chemist Emil Fischer hoped he would fail. Casualty figures for the first attack are uncertain (Friedrich, 2016). His wife was the chemist Clara Immerwahr, the first woman to earn a chemistry doctorate at the University of Breslau (1900). She shot herself with his army pistol on the night of May 1 to 2, 1915, and he left for the Eastern Front the next day. She is widely described as opposing gas warfare. But the historians Bretislav Friedrich and Dieter Hoffmann find little evidence that she was an outspoken pacifist. They attribute her death to several personal and wartime pressures (Friedrich and Hoffmann, 2017). After the war his name was on an Allied list of alleged war criminals. His Nobel Prize drew protest in France and Britain. He also helped create a government-regulated pesticide company that used a cyanide-based product, Zyklon B, which was later used for mass murder at Auschwitz. The Dictionary of Scientific Biography says the product came from a wartime agent developed by his institute (Dictionary of Scientific Biography). Friedrich (2016) says that Zyklon B was "probably" among the agents developed with the help of Haber and his institute. Nitrogen fertilizer has also added to water and air pollution, greenhouse gas emissions, and biodiversity loss (Erisman et al., 2008). Like Franklin's, his case shows that one person can make great benefits possible and also cause great harm.

Discrimination and exclusion

ElementIn this case
Form of exclusionResigned in 1933 rather than dismiss his Jewish staff under Nazi race laws. Then left Germany, despite his service to Germany.
Modern evidence it parallelsAs with Einstein, U.S. patenting rose in the fields of Jewish chemists who fled Nazi Germany (Moser et al., 2014).
What got them past itNot overcome. He left Germany and died within a year.

Pattern summary

ElementIn this case
Door-openerBASF and Carl Bosch, Robert Le Rossignol, Leopold Koppel
Knowledge sourceGerman university training, then self-taught physical chemistry at Karlsruhe
Institutional supportKarlsruhe Polytechnic, BASF
Built on recent workHis own research on the thermodynamics of gas reactions
Setback overcomeOstwald's refusals, public criticism by Nernst
Barrier not overcomeResigned in 1933 rather than dismiss his Jewish staff, then left Germany
Related barriersDiscrimination and exclusion, conflict and violence, Earth's life-support systems

Sources

  1. NobelPrize.org: Fritz Haber, facts
  2. NobelPrize.org: Fritz Haber, biographical
  3. Science History Institute: Fritz Haber
  4. BASF: Carl Bosch (corporate history)
  5. Hebrew University Fritz Haber Research Center: Fritz Haber 1868-1934
  6. Erisman, J. W., Sutton, M. A., Galloway, J., Klimont, Z., & Winiwarter, W. (2008). How a century of ammonia synthesis changed the world. Nature Geoscience, 1(10), 636-639, DOI 10.1038/ngeo325
  7. Complete Dictionary of Scientific Biography (Encyclopedia.com): Fritz Haber
  8. Ašperger, S. (2005). Review of Fritz Haber: Chemist, Nobel Laureate, German, Jew, by D. Stoltzenberg (Chemical Heritage Press, 2004). Croatica Chemica Acta, 78(3), A17-A19
  9. Haber, F. (1920, June 2). The synthesis of ammonia from its elements. Nobel Lecture (NobelPrize.org)
  10. Friedrich, B. (2016, February 20 version). A brief biography of Fritz Haber (1868-1934). Fritz Haber Institute of the Max Planck Society, published in part in Angewandte Chemie International Edition 44, 3957 (2005)
  11. Friedrich, B., & Hoffmann, D. (2017). Clara Immerwahr: A life in the shadow of Fritz Haber. In One Hundred Years of Chemical Warfare: Research, Deployment, Consequences (Springer), 45-67, DOI 10.1007/978-3-319-51664-6\_4
  12. Nernst, W. (1907). Über das Ammoniakgleichgewicht. Zeitschrift für Elektrochemie und angewandte physikalische Chemie, 13(32), 521-524
  13. Max Planck Institute for the History of Science. Feature story No. 83: The social side of a scientific breakthrough (on B. Johnson, Making Ammonia, Springer, 2022)

Also relevant: Bell, A., Chetty, R., Jaravel, X., Petkova, N., & Van Reenen, J. (2019). Who becomes an inventor in America? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(2), 647-713. All references