Contribution. She was the first African American author to publish a full-length book of poetry, Poems on Various Subjects, Religious and Moral (London, 1773). Jupiter Hammon had published a single poem as a broadside in 1761 (Poets.org). Abolitionists cited her work as evidence of the intellectual abilities of Black people. Her first poem appeared in the Newport Mercury on December 21, 1767, when she was about 13.
At a glance
Item
Detail
Dates
c. 1753-1784
Field
Philosophy and the arts
Case type
Pioneer
Discrimination or exclusion
Yes
Factor coverage
Favorable entries (helped or barrier absent) and adverse entries (barrier or not overcome) by factor. Factor tags are this site's classification.
Enslavement. She was born in West Africa, probably in the Senegambia region. She arrived in Boston on July 11, 1761 aboard the slave ship Phillis. The Wheatley family bought her and named her after the ship. John Wheatley wrote that she was "between seven and eight Years of Age." Her real name is unknown.
No market in Boston. In February 1772, Boston newspapers ran advertisements seeking subscribers for a book of her poems. They drew too little support. The Poetry Foundation says this was because colonists were unwilling to support literature by an African. She and the Wheatleys then turned to London for a publisher.
Doubted authorship. The first attempt to place the manuscript with the London bookseller Archibald Bell failed. The Boston merchant John Andrews reported that Bell "could not sell it by reason of their not crediting ye performance to be by a Negro" (Brooks, 2010). The book was printed with an attestation signed by 18 men, including Governor Thomas Hutchinson, John Hancock, seven ministers, and her master. It stated that the poems "were (as we verily believe) written by Phillis, a young Negro Girl" and that "She has been examined by some of the best Judges" (Wheatley, 1773). Brooks dates the signing to October 28, 1772.
Poverty after freedom. Susanna Wheatley, who had arranged her London publication, died in early 1774 (February, according to the Society of Early Americanists chronology). Phillis reported her death in a letter to Obour Tanner of March 21, 1774 (Massachusetts Historical Society). On April 1, 1778, she married John Peters, a free Black man. His business failed in the depression after the Revolution. He was imprisoned for debt. She worked as a charwoman or boardinghouse maid and kept writing. Brooks notes that the white women who had once hosted her performances withdrew their support. Brooks asks whether her manumission, adulthood, and marriage placed her "beyond the realm of permissible associates."
No market for a second book. From October 30, 1779 she advertised for subscribers for a second volume of about 300 pages. It found too little support and was never published.
Education at home. The Wheatleys, including their son Nathaniel and daughter Mary, taught her to read and write. Her master wrote that she had learned English within sixteen months of her arrival. He added that she had made some progress in Latin.
Early newspaper publication. Single poems in newspapers from 1767 built her reputation before any book existed. Her 1770 elegy on the preacher George Whitefield was advertised across New England.
A patron. Whitefield had been chaplain to Selina Hastings, Countess of Huntingdon. Wheatley wrote to her about the elegy. The book was dedicated to the Countess, who gave money toward Wheatley's journey to London.
The London journey. Susanna Wheatley arranged for Archibald Bell to produce the volume. Phillis sailed for London in May 1773 with Nathaniel Wheatley. There she met statesmen including Benjamin Franklin. She also received five guineas from the Earl of Dartmouth.
Freedom and a share of sales. In a letter of October 18, 1773, she wrote that "Since my return to America my Master, has at the desire of my friends in England given me my freedom." She also wrote that "I am to have half the sale of the Books" (Massachusetts Historical Society).
A network of correspondents. On February 11, 1774, she wrote a letter to Samson Occom, a Mohegan Presbyterian minister. It argued that "in every breast, God has implanted a principle, which we call love of freedom" and was printed in newspapers. In February 1776 George Washington replied to a poem she had sent him. He praised her "great poetical Talents." He invited her to visit if she came to Cambridge or near his headquarters (Founders Online). No source checked records that they met.
She died in poverty in Boston on December 5, 1784, aged about 31. Her husband was in jail at the time. Her second volume was never published. Brooks and the National Women's History Museum write that she had three children, none of whom survived. The Poetry Foundation says the evidence of children is disputed.
The disputed examination. The "examination" of Wheatley is disputed. In The Trials of Phillis Wheatley, Henry Louis Gates Jr. imagined an oral examination before the signers. He wrote, "She is on trial and so is her race." Brooks points out that "Nowhere does the attestation state that the signatories had conducted their own examination of Wheatley." Vincent Carretta suspects the signers belonged to the same wealthy Boston circle as her enslavers. He suspects they had come to believe in her authorship through knowing her over time. Some historians argue that no explicit examination took place (National Constitution Center). Hollis Robbins argues that some form of examination did occur. Thomas Jefferson later wrote that religion had "produced a Phyllis Whately" but "could not produce a poet." Sources differ on the date of her freedom (her own letter shows she was free by October 18, 1773, while the Museum of the American Revolution gives 1774). They also differ on her arrival (the Society of Early Americanists gives July 11, 1761, the Poetry Foundation August 1761).
Discrimination and exclusion
Element
In this case
Form of exclusion
Her authorship was doubted because she was enslaved and Black. A London bookseller reportedly could not sell the book because buyers did not believe a Black author wrote it. The book was printed with an attestation signed by 18 men, including her master, stating that she wrote her poems.
Modern evidence it parallels
Field experiments in which identical applications are judged differently depending on the applicant's race.
What got them past it
Education from the Wheatley family, a patron (the Countess of Huntingdon), and publication in London.
Also relevant: Bell, A., Chetty, R., Jaravel, X., Petkova, N., & Van Reenen, J. (2019). Who becomes an inventor in America? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(2), 647-713. All references