Social factors
Relationships and group dynamics: isolation, conformity, in-group bias, harmful ties, and missing mentors.
Barriers within this factor
Each barrier has its own page with the evidence and sources behind it.
- 1Isolation and loneliness
Holt-Lunstad, Smith, and Layton (2010) found that strong social relationships were associated with about a 50% higher likelihood of survival. Putnam (2000) documented declines in U.S. community participation.
Evidence and sources (3 evidence points, 3 actions, 4 experimental methods)
- 2Conformity and groupthink
Asch (1956) showed that many people agree with a group's clearly wrong answer. Janis (1972) described how close-knit groups suppress dissent. Janis's model rests mainly on historical case studies and has limited experimental support (rated C).
Evidence and sources (3 evidence points, 3 actions, 4 experimental methods)
- 3In-group bias
Social identity theory (Tajfel and Turner, 1979) explains why people favor their own group and are suspicious of outsiders.
Evidence and sources (2 evidence points, 2 actions, 5 experimental methods)
- 4Harmful relationships
Harmful relationships, such as abuse, neglect, or control, undermine autonomy and self-worth. Childhood abuse and household dysfunction are covered under early-life adversity in the biological factor.
Evidence and sources (3 evidence points, 5 actions, 6 experimental methods)
- 5Lack of mentors and networks
Without mentors and networks, people are cut off from information and introductions.
Evidence and sources (3 evidence points, 4 actions, 5 experimental methods)
- 6Status anxiety and social comparison
Social media intensifies status anxiety and social comparison. When incomes at the top of the U.S. distribution rose, non-rich households spent more on visible goods and saved less (Bertrand and Morse, 2016).
Evidence and sources (3 evidence points, 2 actions, 3 experimental methods)
Evidence strength
These are the main findings behind this page, grouped by the strength ratings, from strongest to weakest. Each tier lists the findings that received that rating.
| Strength | Findings |
|---|---|
| Strong | The Asch conformity effect in the laboratory. |
| Moderate | Survival benefit of strong social ties (observational). In-group favoritism. Partner violence prevalence (modeled). Trickle-down consumption (debated). |
| Limited | Groupthink. The benefits of mentoring (advocacy organization data). Partner violence and employment. |
| Contested or debated | The effect of neighbors' earnings on happiness. |
Actions that can reduce these barriers
This section lists changes that governments, health systems, organizations, schools, employers, and families can make to reduce these barriers. Each action has an evidence rating on the scale used in the strength ratings (A strong and replicated, B solid but limited, C weak or debated, D contested or failed). The rating applies to the specific claim made. All sources were checked against their abstracts or full texts.
Each barrier page lists the actions that apply to it, with ratings and sources.
Who can act
| Actor | Highest-value social actions |
|---|---|
| Governments | fund proven job training for young adults such as Year Up, career academies in high schools, school dating violence curricula with skill-building, hearing care coverage for older adults |
| Health systems | psychological therapy for loneliness, hearing aids and audiology for older adults with hearing loss, perinatal home visiting rather than IPV screening alone |
| Nonprofits and organizations | advocacy for women leaving shelters, youth mentoring with realistic goals, bystander programs such as Green Dot, college coaching |
| Schools and employers | Safe Dates or Fourth R style curricula, Green Dot bystander training, random mixing of roommates and peer groups, idea generation alone before group discussion, diverse decision groups, pay differences tied to visible performance, career academies |
| Communities | media and radio programs that model tolerant norms, contact between groups under equal status and shared goals |
| Families and individuals | treat hearing loss early, set personal limits on social media time, seek out mentors and coaching |
Lessons across the actions
- Programs that change how people think or what they can perceive did better than programs that simply add contact. For loneliness, cognitive therapy did better than more chances for contact. Hearing care modestly widened social networks.
- Several widely used approaches did not change the behavior they targeted. Many school dating violence programs improved knowledge and attitudes but not perpetration or victimization. Coaching Boys into Men raised intentions to intervene and bystander behavior but not dating violence perpetration. Routine IPV screening did not reduce IPV. So evaluations should measure behavior.
- How a group is set up matters for its judgment. In open discussion, groups lose ideas and hidden information. In experiments, diverse groups or groups that prepared independently decided better.
Limits: Most evidence for "Conformity and groupthink" and "In-group bias" in the social factors comes from laboratory tasks or single field experiments. Many outcomes in "Isolation and loneliness", "Harmful relationships", and "Status anxiety and social comparison" in the social factors are self-reported. The strongest employment evidence for "Lack of mentors and networks" in the social factors comes from evaluation reports of single programs, not replicated trials. The social media evidence is actively disputed. Exact effect sizes for Mullen et al. (1991), Ferguson (2025), and Raposa et al. (2019) could not be confirmed from the original texts.
Proposed and experimental methods
Each barrier also has a list of proposed and experimental methods. The list covers methods that are proposed, under trial, approved in some places but not widely used, or tried and then failed or reversed, so readers can see what is being tested. Each method has a stage label and an evidence rating in parentheses. The stage labels are Theoretical (proposed but not yet tested as an intervention), Early trial (small or first studies), Large trial (large randomized or field trials), Approved but not scaled (legally approved or running in some places but not widely adopted), In wide use (widely adopted but newly tested or questioned), Sold commercially without trials (used for polygenic embryo screening), and Failed or reversed (tested and shown not to work, or adopted and then withdrawn). The word contested is added where the evidence is disputed. Failed, reversed, and unhelpful methods are listed last and begin with "Failed," "Reversed," or "Not shown to help." A stage label shows how far a method has progressed, not whether it works. The rating shows the strength of the evidence.
Ideal conditions that counter this factor
Exposure, mentorship, and door-openers
What the evidence shows
Childhood exposure to innovation has significant causal effects. The effects were gender-specific. Girls were more likely to invent in fields where more women invented locally (Bell et al., 2019). Pioneers often reached their field through one chance contact. Hardy read a clerk's letter, Davy answered a bookbinder, and Faraday's path began at a public lecture. Bell et al. (2019) estimate that the gender gap in innovation would fall by half if girls were exposed to female inventors as often as boys are to male inventors. However, their analysis does not identify which programs work best. Franklin built a library, an academy, and a learned society for others, and he declined patents. Patents also reward invention, though, so the site does not judge which approach produces more progress overall.
Ideal:
- Regular meetings with working scientists, engineers, and inventors, especially people who share the child's background, with exposure programs aimed at children from underrepresented groups who excel early in math and science
- Mentorship that reaches beyond elite schools and families
- Open channels for outsiders, such as review of unsolicited work
- Public lectures and outreach
- Pathways that pioneers build for others
Evidence strength: Mixed. Evidence is moderate to strong for exposure effects (rated B). The mentorship pattern is consistent but anecdotal. The value of institutions built by pioneers rests on historical cases only.
Social conditions and collaboration
What the evidence shows
Wuchty, Jones, and Uzzi (2007) analyzed 19.9 million papers and 2.1 million patents. They found that teams increasingly dominate nearly all fields. Teams now produce the exceptionally high-impact work that solo authors once did. Franklin's Junto and Einstein's Olympia Academy were small communities of this kind.
Ideal:
- Communities for free cross-field discussion
- Easy ways to find complementary collaborators
- Spaces that allow chance encounters
- Fair credit-sharing norms
Evidence strength: Mixed. Strong for the rise of teams (descriptive, rated A, from a near-complete census of papers and patents). Historical cases only for discussion communities such as the Junto.
In the pioneer cases
Statements from the pioneer records that this site classifies under the social factor. The classification is this site's.
| Pioneer | Effect | Statement |
|---|---|---|
| Albert Einstein | Helped | Max Talmey. He lent Einstein Aaron Bernstein's popular science books and a geometry textbook. |
| Albert Einstein | Helped | Marcel Grossmann. He shared lecture notes. His father recommended Einstein for the patent office job. In 1912 he pointed Einstein to Riemannian geometry for general relativity. Einstein later downplayed Grossmann's role. But historians generally see it as significant. |
| Albert Einstein | Helped | The Olympia Academy. Einstein, Maurice Solovine, and Conrad Habicht met to talk about philosophy. They spent weeks on Hume's critique of substance and causality. |
| Albert Einstein | Helped | Michele Besso. He was the only person thanked in the 1905 relativity paper. |
| Albert Einstein | Note | A close call. He nearly left physics to teach high school. One recommendation from Grossmann's father changed his path. |
| Albert Einstein | Note | Mileva Marić. A 1901 letter mentions "our work on relative motion." But most historians reject the claim that she was an unacknowledged coauthor. She was an intellectual companion during his formative years. |
| Albert Einstein | Helped | Max Planck. He was co-editor of Annalen der Physik. He accepted Einstein's light quanta paper even though he disliked the idea. He was also the first scientist to report favorably on relativity. |
| Michael Faraday | Barrier | Class. Davy toured Europe from 1813 to 1815. Days before they left, Davy's valet withdrew. Faraday agreed to do the valet's tasks until a replacement was found. No replacement was ever hired, and Lady Davy treated him as a servant. In 1815 he wrote from Rome to his friend Benjamin Abbott. He said "'tis the name more than the thing which hurts" (Bence Jones, 1870). |
| Michael Faraday | Barrier | Questions of credit and rank. In 1821 he discovered electromagnetic rotation. Afterward, rumors spread that he had used work by Davy and William Hyde Wollaston without giving credit. He had to satisfy both men that he had acted properly. He was nominated to the Royal Society in 1823. Davy, its President, told him to take down his nomination certificate. He refused. He was elected in early 1824 with one vote against him. |
| Michael Faraday | Helped | Self-education among peers. From 1810 he went to lectures at the City Philosophical Society. It met at the home of the silversmith John Tatum. There he made lifelong friends. They included Benjamin Abbott and the chemist Richard Phillips, who later nominated him to the Royal Society. |
| Michael Faraday | Helped | A lucky connection. In the spring of 1812 a customer, William Dance, gave him tickets to four Humphry Davy lectures at the Royal Institution. |
| Michael Faraday | Helped | Initiative and timing. He wrote up his notes from the lectures, bound them and sent them to Davy. In February 1813 the Royal Institution's laboratory assistant was fired after a fight. Davy hired Faraday to replace him. |
| Michael Faraday | Helped | Travel in place of university. He still had the servant's duties. But the 18-month tour took him to laboratories in France, Switzerland, Italy, and southern Germany. There he met scientists including André-Marie Ampère and Alessandro Volta. A biographer, Martin, wrote that these months "had taken the place, in Faraday's life, of the years spent at university by other men" (MacTutor). |
| Marie Curie | Barrier | Hostility in 1911. On January 23, 1911, she lost an election to the French Academy of Sciences. She lost by one vote in the first round and two in the second, out of 58 votes cast. The vote followed a press campaign. NobelPrize.org describes it as drawing on antisemitism, prejudice against women, and xenophobia (right-wing papers falsely called her Jewish, according to the American Institute of Physics). In November 1911, newspapers published letters about her relationship with the physicist Paul Langevin. A crowd gathered outside her home. Svante Arrhenius of the Swedish Academy of Sciences asked her not to come to Stockholm to receive her second Nobel Prize (NobelPrize.org). |
| Marie Curie | Helped | A family pact. She worked as a governess to pay for Bronisława's medical studies in Paris. Bronisława then helped her. Their father was by then director of a reform school. He sent Bronisława a monthly sum and set part of it aside to repay Maria. In Paris she won a scholarship for an outstanding Polish student. She placed first in her physics degree in 1893 and second in mathematics in 1894. |
| Marie Curie | Helped | A father who taught mathematics and physics. After laboratory teaching was banned, he kept physics apparatus at home and showed it to his children. During her governess years he taught her advanced mathematics by mail. |
| Marie Curie | Helped | A partner, a workplace, and industry. A paid study of the magnetism of steels led to her meeting Pierre Curie in 1894. He let her work at the Paris Municipal School of Industrial Physics and Chemistry. He and his brother Jacques had built the Curie electrometer, which made precise measurements possible. In 1898 he set aside his own research to join hers. The Austrian government, on the proposal of the Vienna Academy of Sciences, let them have several tons of pitchblende residue from the St. Joachimsthal mine at a low price. By her own account she got definite results only after treating one ton (Curie, 1923) (the American Institute of Physics describes one donated ton). A chemical company, with their colleague André Debierne, scaled up the processing in exchange for a share of the radium. |
| Marie Curie | Helped | An advocate. The 1903 nomination named only Pierre Curie and Becquerel. Gösta Mittag-Leffler alerted Pierre. On August 6, 1903, Pierre replied that he wished to be considered together with Marie. A 1902 nomination of her was then accepted for 1903. |
| Marie Curie | Helped | Allies after 1906. After Pierre's death on April 19, 1906, the Sorbonne invited her on May 13 to take his post. This made her the first woman to teach there (she was made a full professor in 1908). The University of Paris and the private Pasteur Foundation paid for a Radium Institute, completed in August 1914. In 1911 the mathematician Émile Borel sheltered her family, even when the education minister threatened to fire him. In 1921 a U.S. campaign brought her a gram of radium, plus equipment and cash for the institute. The magazine editor Mrs. William Brown Meloney organized it, and President Harding presented the radium (AIP). |
| Srinivasa Ramanujan | Barrier | Isolation. Before he wrote to Hardy, he sent his results to the Cambridge mathematicians H. F. Baker and E. W. Hobson. According to C. P. Snow, two eminent English mathematicians had returned his papers without comment. Later writers have identified them as Baker and Hobson (Berndt, 1985). |
| Srinivasa Ramanujan | Helped | Local supporters. V. Ramaswami Aiyar, founder of the Indian Mathematical Society, and his former teacher P. V. Seshu Aiyar sent him to R. Ramachandra Rao, Collector of Nellore. From December 1910, Rao paid his expenses for a time. On March 1, 1912 (MacTutor), or in 1911 according to Hardy's 1921 obituary, he became a clerk in the accounts department of the Madras Port Trust. There the chairman, Sir Francis Spring, encouraged his work. So did the manager, S. Narayana Aiyar, who was a mathematician. |
| Srinivasa Ramanujan | Helped | A sponsor. According to later accounts, Hardy and Littlewood studied the letter the evening it arrived. Hardy concluded that its results "could only be written down by a mathematician of the highest class" (Young, 1994). Spring showed the work to the meteorologist Gilbert Walker. Walker recommended him to the University of Madras. From May 1913 the University gave him a research scholarship of 75 rupees a month. |
| Srinivasa Ramanujan | Helped | Teaching and recognition. Hardy found that he "had never heard of a doubly periodic function or of Cauchy's theorem." Hardy taught him modern analysis. By his own account, Hardy learned much more in return. Ramanujan received a Cambridge BA by research in 1916. After his 1918 elections, the University of Madras granted him £250 a year for five years from April 1919. |
| Jonas Salk | Barrier | Skepticism of peers. Most virologists, including Albert Sabin, believed that only a live, weakened virus could give lasting immunity. In 1950 the polio typing committee rejected the method changes he proposed. Before the 1954 trial, Sabin argued to the American Medical Association and to Congress that a killed-virus vaccine was neither effective nor safe. |
| Jonas Salk | Helped | A mentor. Thomas Francis Jr. trained him at NYU on inactivated influenza vaccines. When other positions turned him down, Salk went back to Francis. In 1942 he joined him at the University of Michigan on a National Research Council fellowship. There, with U.S. Army support, they developed a killed-virus flu vaccine. |
| Jonas Salk | Helped | A team. His Pittsburgh staff included Julius Youngner, Byron Bennett, and L. James Lewis. Three others joined later. Youngner developed ways to grow the virus in monkey kidney cells. He also made a color test to measure antibodies (Boston Globe). |
| Jonas Salk | Helped | Mass participation and an independent evaluation. Volunteers ran the 1954 trial. Francis directed it, not Salk. The 1955 report counted 1,829,916 children in the study areas. This included observed controls who got no injection (University of Michigan School of Public Health). Other accounts give from 1 million to almost 2 million because they count different groups. Jacobs's biography, as summarized by Valiunas (2018), puts those who got the vaccine at over 600,000. In April 1955 the vaccine was reported safe and 80 to 90% effective against paralytic polio. |
| Jonas Salk | Not overcome | He was very famous with the public. Even so, he was never elected to the National Academy of Sciences, which admitted Sabin, Francis, Enders, and David Bodian (KQED, The New Atlantis). He never received a Nobel Prize. In the 1960s Sabin's oral live-virus vaccine replaced his in the United States. |
| Jonas Salk | Note | Credit and patents. Some colleagues criticized Salk for not crediting the researchers his work built on. Members of his own team said he failed to single them out in his April 12, 1955, announcement speech. A United Press report at the time quoted him crediting six staff members. The printed text was headed "From the Staff of the Virus Research Laboratory." But Youngner confronted Salk about the speech in 1993. Salk did not patent the vaccine. Edward R. Murrow asked him who owned the patent on his television program See It Now. This was on April 12, 1955, the day the trial results were announced (The New Atlantis, Smithsonian Magazine, Slate). He answered, "Well, the people, I would say. There is no patent. Could you patent the sun?" (History of Vaccines). The historian Jane S. Smith found documents in the National Foundation's archives, as reported by Slate. According to them, the Foundation's lawyers had looked at whether the vaccine could be patented. They concluded that it did not meet the novelty requirement (Slate). A History.com account says instead that the lawyers did not pursue a patent in part because of Salk's reluctance (History.com). Smith's book was not opened for this document. |
| Norman Borlaug | Barrier | Ruins and resistance in Mexico. He arrived in Mexico in 1944. The Chapingo research station near Mexico City was in ruins. Because of wartime shortages, no new farm machinery could be bought. Consultant H. K. Hayes objected to breeding at two sites a year. He said it was unorthodox because seed needed a year of "rest." Program director George Harrar refused it as too expensive. Harrar gave permission in 1947, after Borlaug threatened to resign and Stakman mediated (University of Minnesota). |
| Norman Borlaug | Barrier | Resistance in Pakistan. In Pakistan in 1964, local plant breeders and agronomists resisted the Mexican wheats. Trial plots were not properly sown, fertilized, or watered. Borlaug later said the main obstacle was "the government policy maker," who controlled prices and the supply of fertilizer (Academy of Achievement). In 1965 war broke out between India and Pakistan while the first large seed shipments were arriving. |
| Norman Borlaug | Helped | A mentor who took a chance. The Forest Service offer fell through. Then plant pathologist Elvin C. Stakman gave him a job counting rust spores on microscope slides. Stakman then admitted him to graduate study. He earned a PhD in plant pathology in 1942 (National Academy of Sciences). Stakman and Harrar recruited him in 1943. At his wife Margaret's urging, he left a microbiology job at DuPont for Mexico in 1944. |
| Norman Borlaug | Helped | Interdisciplinary teamwork and local help. The program combined genetics, plant breeding, plant pathology, entomology, agronomy, soil science, and cereal technology. Mexican scientist Ignacio Narváez became his partner. He trained local farm boys, and they became skilled technicians. Yaqui Valley farmers lent equipment. |
| Norman Borlaug | Helped | Demonstrations and political allies. He gave seed to farmers and relied on demonstrations in their fields. In Pakistan, President Ayub Khan released funds for seed, fertilizer, training, and price supports. In India, M. S. Swaminathan and Agriculture Minister C. Subramaniam backed the program. In 1965 Pakistan imported 350 tons and India 250 tons of Mexican seed (Nobel lecture). |
| Katalin Karikó | Barrier | A hostile supervisor. According to her memoir, as summarized in a 2024 review in Emerging Infectious Diseases, her supervisor at Temple University screamed and threw objects at her. The same account says that when she tried to leave, the supervisor threatened to have her deported. |
| Katalin Karikó | Barrier | Little interest in the 2005 finding. She and Weissman expected their 2005 finding to draw wide interest. But, in her words, "Nobody cared." A 2023 perspective in Frontiers in Immunology, citing the New York Times, reports that Nature and Science rejected the manuscript before Immunity published it. |
| Katalin Karikó | Helped | Early influences. Two things fed her interest in biology: a biology teacher, Albert Tóth, and her father's work as a butcher. At 16 she read a Hungarian translation of a book by the endocrinologist Hans Selye. He advised focusing on what one can change, and she later cited that advice. |
| Katalin Karikó | Helped | A chance meeting. In the late 1990s she met the immunologist Drew Weissman at a photocopier. On her advice, he switched his vaccine work from DNA to mRNA. |
| Katalin Karikó | Note | Possible bias. Some commentators, including UC Berkeley biologist Michael Eisen, have suggested that she was penalized for being a woman and an immigrant from Eastern Europe (Times Higher Education). This is a suggestion, not a documented finding. Penn did not respond to questions. Penn says the Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna vaccines use its licensed technology and that Penn, Karikó, and Weissman have received financial benefits from it. Her memoir, Breaking Through: My Life in Science, was published by Crown in 2023. |
| Tu Youyou | Barrier | Family sacrifice. To focus on the work, she left her younger daughter with her parents. By her own account, the child did not recognize her three years later. |
| Tu Youyou | Helped | Collaboration. Other institutes helped work out artemisinin's chemical structure using X-ray crystallography. |
| Tu Youyou | Helped | Outside advocates. In 2011, U.S. National Institutes of Health researchers Louis Miller and Xinzhuan Su reviewed documents that had been confidential. They concluded that the major credit belonged to Tu. She received the Lasker Award that year. |
| Tu Youyou | Not overcome | Credit remains disputed. Project 523 involved many scientists. Some Chinese scientists and historians object to crediting one person. Tu herself described the discovery as the effort of an entire team. |
| Percy Julian | Barrier | No path to graduate study. He graduated in 1920 as valedictorian and a member of Phi Beta Kappa. Even so, his teachers told him "there were no opportunities for those of his color, and they could not help." He taught chemistry at Fisk University from 1920 to 1922 instead. |
| Percy Julian | Barrier | Violence at home. In 1950 the family moved to Oak Park, Illinois, a white suburb. On Thanksgiving Day 1950, arsonists set their house on fire. On June 12, 1951, the house was hit by a dynamite bomb. The family stayed. |
| Percy Julian | Helped | A family with steady income. His father, James Sumner Julian, was a railway mail clerk. His biographer notes that as a federal employee's family they had higher standing than most Black families of the time. |
| Percy Julian | Helped | A welcome and a mentor at DePauw. He later recalled that on his first day a white student shook his hand and welcomed him. He said that "in the shake of a hand my whole life was changed." William M. Blanchard, a DePauw chemistry professor and dean, invited him back in 1933 to teach senior organic chemistry. With Blanchard's advice, he started an undergraduate research program. |
| Percy Julian | Helped | A collaborator. Josef Pikl, a fellow student from Vienna, joined him at Howard and then at DePauw. Together they finished the physostigmine synthesis. They also showed that a rival synthesis by the English chemist Robert Robinson had produced a different compound. |
| Percy Julian | Helped | Recognition. He received the NAACP's Spingarn Medal in 1947. In 1973 he was elected to the National Academy of Sciences, the first African American chemist in the Academy. In 1990 he was inducted into the National Inventors Hall of Fame. |
| Ignaz Semmelweis | Barrier | No support from the top. His chief, Johann Klein, rejected his explanation. His appointment was not extended. The Science History Institute says Klein dismissed him on March 20, 1849, partly because Semmelweis supported the 1848 Hungarian revolution (Science History Institute). Kadar (2019) adds that his work was drawn into a dispute over academic freedom at the Vienna medical school. This turned Klein against him (Kadar, 2019). The private attending post he then held would not have let him continue his research (Kadar et al., 2018). |
| Ignaz Semmelweis | Barrier | Delayed publication. Ferdinand von Hebra reported the discovery in December 1847 and April 1848. But Semmelweis's own first papers appeared only in 1858, and his book in 1861. Kadar (2020) argues that Škoda's and Brücke's responses to the animal experiments led him to wait. He waited until he had enough clinical evidence (Kadar, 2020). |
| Ignaz Semmelweis | Barrier | A disputed role for his own conduct. After 1861 he wrote open letters to leading obstetricians abroad, with little effect (Britannica). In them he called continued opposition a "massacre." Historians still debate exactly why his evidence was dismissed. Kadar (2019, 2021) argues that the primary documents do not support accounts that blame the rejection on his character, education, or writing (Kadar, 2021). |
| Ignaz Semmelweis | Helped | Supportive colleagues. Josef Škoda and Ferdinand von Hebra supported him, and so did the deputy director Karl Haller. When Semmelweis turned down an 1849 invitation to address the Vienna Medical Society, Škoda spoke for him (Ravel et al., 2025). Škoda also asked the Academy of Sciences to fund more experiments. Semmelweis himself lectured to the Vienna Medical Society on May 15, 1850. The discussion continued on June 18 and ended on July 15, 1850 (Semmelweis, 1861, p. 397, Neue Deutsche Biographie). |
| Ignaz Semmelweis | Helped | Pathology and a colleague's death. He worked with the pathologist Carl von Rokitansky (Science History Institute). Each day before his ward rounds, he autopsied the mothers who had died. In March 1847 he returned from Venice. He learned that his friend Jakob Kolletschka, a forensic pathologist, had died after a student cut his finger during an autopsy. The autopsy findings matched those of mothers who died of childbed fever. From this he inferred a common cause. |
| Ignaz Semmelweis | Helped | An editor's encouragement. Lajos Markusovszky founded the Hungarian medical journal Orvosi Hetilap (1857). He encouraged Semmelweis to publish there. The preface to Semmelweis's book is dated Pest, August 30, 1860. In it he wrote that he was acting against his own inclinations in appearing before the public again, because silence had served so badly (Semmelweis, 1861). In the same preface he wrote that, besides his dislike of all polemics, he had "an innate aversion to everything called writing" ("eine mir angeborne Abneigung gegen alles, was Schreiben heißt"). His biographer Schürer von Waldheim reprinted this (Schürer von Waldheim, 1905, p. 155). |
| Ignaz Semmelweis | Note | Later recognition. Virchow acknowledged his merit in 1864. Scanzoni credited him in 1867. Joseph Lister also praised him. |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Barrier | An unstable family. Her family's fortunes were unstable. Her father mismanaged his share of his own father's inheritance. The family moved again and again (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). They went to a farm near Beverley in Yorkshire, then Hoxton near London, then Wales. Godwin was her husband and first biographer. He writes that when her father threatened her mother she would "throw herself between the despot and his victim," and sometimes lay all night on the landing near her parents' door (Godwin, 1798, chapters 1 and 2). |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Barrier | Unequal inheritance. Her eldest brother, Edward, inherited directly from their grandfather. He was the only child to get a formal education, and he became a lawyer (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). Godwin says her schooling was the day schools at Beverley. The family lived there until she was fifteen. |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Barrier | Few paid jobs. Few kinds of paid work were open to her. In 1778 she became a lady's companion to a Mrs Dawson in Bath. She returned home in late 1781 to nurse her mother, who died in the spring of 1782 (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Barrier | A failed school. Her school failed. With her sisters and her friend Fanny Blood, she opened a day school at Islington. It soon moved to Newington Green. Early in 1785 Fanny Blood, ill with consumption, sailed to Lisbon to marry. Wollstonecraft left the school to nurse her. Blood died after childbirth on November 29, 1785. When Wollstonecraft came back, she found the school in a worse state and decided to close it (Godwin, 1798, chapters 3 and 4). |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Helped | Early teachers outside school. At Hoxton a neighboring clergyman, Mr Clare, encouraged her reading. Fanny Blood, who was ahead of her in learning, became her teacher (Godwin, 1798, chapters 1 and 2). |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Helped | A network. Richard Price led a Dissenting community at Newington Green. Through it she met the schoolmaster John Hewlett, who urged her to write for money (Godwin, 1798, chapter 4). When she sailed to Lisbon, a Mrs Burgh of the same circle lent her the money for the trip. |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Helped | A publisher. Through Hewlett, Joseph Johnson paid ten guineas for the copyright of her first book, Thoughts on the Education of Daughters (1787). She used the money to help Fanny Blood's parents move to Ireland. She arrived in London in August 1787 and stayed in Johnson's house for two or three weeks. He found her a house in George Street. He gave her steady writing work, mainly translation. From about the middle of 1788 he also gave her reviewing for his Analytical Review. |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Helped | A public debate. Edmund Burke's attack on Richard Price drew her reply, A Vindication of the Rights of Men. It was published anonymously in November 1790 and under her name in December. She began A Vindication of the Rights of Woman in September 1791 (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). She wrote it in six weeks and gave the manuscript to the printer on January 3, 1792. According to the Orlando Project, her fame began in February 1792, when Talleyrand visited her. She dedicated the book to him (Orlando Project). |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Not overcome | She died on September 10, 1797, eleven days after giving birth, of septicemia or puerperal fever (Orlando Project). Godwin records that the placenta was not delivered. He also records that a physician removed it in pieces, but part of it remained (Godwin, 1798, chapter 10). This is the disease that Semmelweis showed, fifty years later, was spread on unwashed hands (see his entry). Her husband's frank memoir (1798) then hurt her reputation for most of the next century. Claudia L. Johnson writes that serious attention to her works, rather than her life, began only in the late 1960s and 1970s (Johnson, 2002). |
| Mary Wollstonecraft | Note | Reception and private life. Early reviews of Rights of Woman were fairly respectful. Johnson (2002) says critics more and more read it as a political text once Britain and France went to war. Horace Walpole wrote to Hannah More in a letter begun on January 24, 1795. In it he called her "a hyena in petticoats" (the first printing, in 1798, leaves her name blank) (Walpole, 1798). The clergyman Richard Polwhele attacked her as the leading example of "unsexed" women. The Anti-Jacobin Review of 1798 indexed her under "P" for "Prostitute," which Johnson links to her criticism of standards of female modesty. In France from December 1792, she met the American Gilbert Imlay. They had a daughter, Fanny, in May 1794. After he left her, she attempted suicide twice in 1795. Her daughter with William Godwin, born August 30, 1797, became the novelist Mary Shelley (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). |
| Baruch Spinoza | Barrier | Excommunication. On July 27, 1656, the ma'amad issued him a herem (ban), with the rabbis' consent. The ma'amad was the lay governing board of Amsterdam's Sephardic congregation. The ban condemned his "evil opinions and acts," "abominable heresies," and "monstrous deeds," and it barred members from communicating with him, "not even in writing," from reading anything he wrote, and from coming within four cubits of him. Steven Nadler calls it the harshest writ the community ever issued. The historian Yosef Kaplan counts forty bans there between 1622 and 1683. Others could end in reinstatement after an apology and a fine. Spinoza's was never lifted, and no surviving document states its exact reasons (Nadler, 2013). |
| Baruch Spinoza | Helped | A Latin tutor. With his Latin teacher, Franciscus van den Enden, guiding him, he turned from Jewish tradition toward classical literature, republican political theory, and the philosophy of Descartes. |
| Baruch Spinoza | Helped | Friends with means. He also received grants and pensions from wealthy admirers. The early biographer Johannes Colerus writes about the annuity from the de Vries estate described below. He says it was offered at 500 florins a year and that Spinoza accepted only 300 (Colerus, 1706). Simon de Vries was an Amsterdam Mennonite merchant and one of his closest friends. He died in 1667, and Spinoza inherited an annual sum from his estate. It let him focus on philosophy (Cambridge Spinoza Lexicon). |
| Baruch Spinoza | Helped | A network of correspondents. He exchanged letters with leading thinkers, including Christiaan Huygens and Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz. |
| Baruch Spinoza | Helped | Friends who published his work. After his death, friends published his unpublished writings as the Opera posthuma (1677). These included the Ethics and the unfinished Political Treatise. Jarig Jelles edited the volume, and Jan Rieuwertsz printed it in Amsterdam (Morgan Library). |
| Baruch Spinoza | Note | Reasons for the ban. The reasons for the herem are not documented. Nadler infers them from Spinoza's later philosophy, including his denial of the soul's immortality and of the divine origin of the Law. He also draws on reports by Spanish travelers to the Inquisition, which he calls hearsay. Nadler does not think the orphan petition was the real cause. He suggests the community may also have wanted to reassure Dutch authorities that it did not tolerate such views. Spinoza reportedly responded to the ban with "All the better." A story says that a man attacked him with a knife. It rests on two early accounts that differ, Pierre Bayle's (1697) and Colerus's (1705). Nadler treats it as unconfirmed. He dates it, if it happened, before the ban. He suggests the motive was revenge by men in a business dispute, rather than religious hostility (Nadler, 2018). |
| Phillis Wheatley | Barrier | Enslavement. She was born in West Africa, probably in the Senegambia region. She arrived in Boston on July 11, 1761 aboard the slave ship Phillis. The Wheatley family bought her and named her after the ship. John Wheatley wrote that she was "between seven and eight Years of Age." Her real name is unknown. |
| Phillis Wheatley | Barrier | Poverty after freedom. Susanna Wheatley, who had arranged her London publication, died in early 1774 (February, according to the Society of Early Americanists chronology). Phillis reported her death in a letter to Obour Tanner of March 21, 1774 (Massachusetts Historical Society). On April 1, 1778, she married John Peters, a free Black man. His business failed in the depression after the Revolution. He was imprisoned for debt. She worked as a charwoman or boardinghouse maid and kept writing. Brooks notes that the white women who had once hosted her performances withdrew their support. Brooks asks whether her manumission, adulthood, and marriage placed her "beyond the realm of permissible associates." |
| Phillis Wheatley | Helped | Education at home. The Wheatleys, including their son Nathaniel and daughter Mary, taught her to read and write. Her master wrote that she had learned English within sixteen months of her arrival. He added that she had made some progress in Latin. |
| Phillis Wheatley | Helped | Early newspaper publication. Single poems in newspapers from 1767 built her reputation before any book existed. Her 1770 elegy on the preacher George Whitefield was advertised across New England. |
| Phillis Wheatley | Helped | A patron. Whitefield had been chaplain to Selina Hastings, Countess of Huntingdon. Wheatley wrote to her about the elegy. The book was dedicated to the Countess, who gave money toward Wheatley's journey to London. |
| Phillis Wheatley | Helped | Prominent sponsors. The attestation carried the names of the colony's governor, lieutenant governor, and leading merchants and clergy. |
| Phillis Wheatley | Helped | The London journey. Susanna Wheatley arranged for Archibald Bell to produce the volume. Phillis sailed for London in May 1773 with Nathaniel Wheatley. There she met statesmen including Benjamin Franklin. She also received five guineas from the Earl of Dartmouth. |
| Phillis Wheatley | Helped | A network of correspondents. On February 11, 1774, she wrote a letter to Samson Occom, a Mohegan Presbyterian minister. It argued that "in every breast, God has implanted a principle, which we call love of freedom" and was printed in newspapers. In February 1776 George Washington replied to a poem she had sent him. He praised her "great poetical Talents." He invited her to visit if she came to Cambridge or near his headquarters (Founders Online). No source checked records that they met. |
| Ludwig van Beethoven | Barrier | A struggling father. His father, Johann, was a tenor in the Bonn court chapel. He drank heavily, and Thayer judged that this helped bring the family into poverty. His mother died of tuberculosis on July 17, 1787. At 18 Beethoven petitioned the Elector. A decree of November 20, 1789 retired his father. It paid half of the father's salary to Beethoven to support his two younger brothers (Thayer, 1921, Vol. I). |
| Ludwig van Beethoven | Barrier | Isolation and despair. The Heiligenstadt Testament is an unsent letter to his brothers of October 6, 1802. In it he wrote that he had been in a hopeless condition for six years. He wrote that he had to live "like an exile." He also wrote that he was humiliated when someone beside him heard a distant flute or a shepherd singing and he heard nothing. Only his art, he wrote, held him back from ending his life (Heiligenstadt Testament, Wikisource). |
| Ludwig van Beethoven | Helped | A patron in Bonn. Count Ferdinand von Waldstein befriended him. On October 29, 1792, as Beethoven was leaving, Waldstein wrote in his album. He wrote that with hard work Beethoven would "receive Mozart's spirit from Haydn's hands." |
| Ludwig van Beethoven | Helped | Study in Vienna. He reached Vienna by November 10, 1792. He studied with Joseph Haydn and then with Johann Georg Albrechtsberger. |
| Ludwig van Beethoven | Helped | A first annuity. In about 1800, Prince Karl Lichnowsky granted him 600 florins a year. It was to be paid until he found a suitable post. |
| Ludwig van Beethoven | Helped | The 1809 annuity. Jérôme Bonaparte, Napoleon's brother and King of Westphalia, offered him a post as music director in Kassel for 600 gold ducats a year. After that, on March 1, 1809, Archduke Rudolph and Princes Kinsky and Lobkowitz agreed to pay him 4,000 florins a year. The only condition was that he turn down the Kassel offer and stay in Vienna. Ignaz von Gleichenstein led the talks. The contract split the sum as 1,500 florins from Rudolph, 1,800 from Kinsky, and 700 from Lobkowitz. It promised payment for life if accident or old age stopped his work (Thayer, 1921, Vol. II). |
| Ludwig van Beethoven | Helped | Written conversation. From 1818 visitors wrote their questions in notebooks. He usually answered aloud. |
| Ludwig van Beethoven | Helped | Allies in the annuity disputes. Archduke Rudolph and friends pressed his claims. Settlements in 1815 restored payments from the Kinsky estate at 1,200 florins instead of 1,800. They also restored payments from the Lobkowitz estate at the full 700 florins in the new paper currency. |
| Benjamin Franklin | Barrier | A harsh apprenticeship. At 12 he signed indentures that bound him to his brother James, a printer, until age 21. In his words, James "was passionate, and had often beaten me." His "indiscreet disputations about religion" also made him "pointed at with horror by good people as an infidel or atheist." He ran away to Philadelphia. |
| Benjamin Franklin | Barrier | A broken promise abroad. Pennsylvania's governor, William Keith, urged him to go to London to buy printing equipment. Keith promised letters of recommendation and a letter of credit. None arrived. The merchant Thomas Denham told him that no one who knew Keith relied on him. Franklin worked in London printing houses for about eighteen months before returning. |
| Benjamin Franklin | Barrier | Skepticism of peers. At first the Royal Society judged his letters on electricity not worth printing in its Transactions. A paper on how lightning and electricity are the same was "laughed at by the connoisseurs." In France, the Abbé Nollet was tutor in natural philosophy to the royal family. He doubted that such a work came from America. He published letters denying Franklin's experiments. |
| Benjamin Franklin | Helped | Books through his trade. His father chose printing for him because of his "bookish inclination." As an apprentice he borrowed books overnight from booksellers' apprentices. A tradesman, Matthew Adams, lent him books from his own collection. |
| Benjamin Franklin | Helped | A network of peers. In 1727 he formed the Junto, a club for mutual improvement that met on Friday evenings. Members posed questions on morals, politics, or natural philosophy and read essays every three months. |
| Benjamin Franklin | Helped | A door-opener in London. Peter Collinson, a Fellow of the Royal Society, gave the Library Company a glass tube for electrical experiments. Franklin reported his results to Collinson by letter. The Royal Society passed over them. The physician John Fothergill then advised printing them. Collinson arranged their publication in London in 1751 as Experiments and Observations on Electricity. |
| Benjamin Franklin | Helped | Recognition after confirmation. Thomas-François Dalibard's assistant at Marly and then Delor in Paris carried out his proposed experiment in May 1752 (Founders Online). A contemporary letter described Delor as a "master of experimental philosophy." The editors of Franklin's papers have not fully identified him (Founders Online). After that, the Royal Society printed a summary of his letters. It awarded him the Copley Medal for 1753, its oldest and most prestigious award (Royal Society). Harvard gave him a Master of Arts degree on July 25, 1753. Harvard's archives call it "generally considered to be the first true honorary degree awarded by Harvard" (Harvard University Archives). Yale gave him the same degree in September 1753 (Papers of Benjamin Franklin, volume 5). Jean-Baptiste Le Roy of the French Academy of Sciences answered Nollet. |
| Benjamin Franklin | Helped | The Library Company. Junto members first pooled their own books. Then, in 1731, he proposed the Library Company of Philadelphia. He later called it "the mother of all the North American subscription libraries." Its first fifty subscribers, "mostly young tradesmen," paid forty shillings each. |
| Benjamin Franklin | Helped | The Union Fire Company. In 1736 he organized the Union Fire Company, Philadelphia's first fire protection society. |
| Benjamin Franklin | Helped | The American Philosophical Society. He founded the American Philosophical Society in 1743 (American Philosophical Society). The Autobiography gives the date as 1744. |
| Gregor Mendel | Barrier | Poverty. He was born on July 20, 1822 in Hynčice (Heinzendorf), Silesia, into a German-speaking farming family. His parents were struggling farmers who could not pay for his studies. So at the grammar school in Opava he supported himself by tutoring other pupils (Mendel Museum). His sister Theresia gave up part of her dowry to help pay for his education (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory). |
| Gregor Mendel | Barrier | A vocation decided by circumstance. He entered the Augustinian monastery of St. Thomas in Brno in 1843. He later said that his circumstances decided his choice of vocation. His father had been crippled by an accident about three years before 1841. His father could no longer manage the farm. After Mendel chose the priesthood, his father sold the farmstead to Alois Sturm, the husband of Mendel's sister Veronika. The condition was that the buyer pay Mendel 100 florins and the costs of his first mass (Fairbanks, 2022). |
| Gregor Mendel | Barrier | Little notice. He presented his results in two lectures to the Natural Science Society in Brno on February 8 and March 8, 1865 (Mendel, 1866). His 1866 paper appeared in the society's proceedings. He sent the paper to 133 associations of natural scientists and to libraries (Villanova University). But it was largely overlooked for 34 years. Fairbanks (2022) writes that "No one, including Mendel, recognized the importance of his theory in his day." |
| Gregor Mendel | Helped | A teacher's recommendation. Friedrich Franz, his physics professor in Olomouc, recommended him for admission to the St. Thomas monastery. He was admitted to the order on October 9, 1843 (Fairbanks, 2022). |
| Gregor Mendel | Helped | An educated community. Several of the friars at St. Thomas were highly educated. They worked as teachers and professors. Among them was the philosopher Matouš Klácel (Fairbanks, 2022). |
| Gregor Mendel | Helped | Land, time, and a local society. The monastery gave him garden space for his experiments. The Natural Science Society of Brno heard his lectures and printed his paper. |
| Gregor Mendel | Helped | Correspondence with a leading botanist. He sent an offprint to the botanist Carl Nägeli on December 31, 1866. He kept writing to him for years after. Nägeli kept the letters. They are the main record of Mendel's later hybridization experiments (Fairbanks, 2022). |
| Gregor Mendel | Helped | Later scientists who reached the same results. In 1900 Hugo de Vries and Carl Correns each reached similar findings on their own and drew attention to his paper. Erich von Tschermak is often named as a third rediscoverer. But historians question whether he understood Mendel's ratios. |
| Gregor Mendel | Not overcome | He died on January 6, 1884 without recognition for his work on heredity. He was elected abbot in 1868. Within about five years, his duties running the monastery largely ended his research. From 1874 he refused to accept a new law that raised taxes on monasteries. He called it "unjust." The government placed part of the monastery's property under administration (Masaryk University, 2022). The dispute was still unresolved when he died. He died of kidney disease that had worsened in 1883. |
| Gregor Mendel | Note | Nägeli, Fisher, and lost papers. Mendel wrote to the leading botanist Carl Nägeli. He repeated his work with hawkweed, which Nägeli also studied, but the results did not match. Historians disagree about whether Nägeli suggested the plant (Bicknell et al., 2016). Hawkweed mostly forms seeds without fertilization, which explains the difference. In 1936 R. A. Fisher argued that Mendel's data fit expectations too closely. No later study finds evidence of deliberate falsification (Franklin et al., 2008). Fairbanks (2019) describes the controversy as essentially resolved. But statisticians still disagree about whether the fit is unusually close. Pires and Branco (2010) accept that it is. They explain it by unconscious selection of repeated trials. Ellis et al. (2019) found that Mendel's ratios do not depart remarkably from expectation. Fairbanks (2022) also rejects the story that Darwin owned an uncut copy of Mendel's paper. He found no evidence that Darwin knew of Mendel. Accounts conflict on whether Mendel's papers were burned. A prior of the monastery recalled that Mendel burned his own papers in bitterness. Another account says they were burned after his death. Others recalled thousands of sheets surviving. So their fate remains uncertain (Fairbanks, 2022). |
| George Washington Carver | Barrier | Born enslaved and orphaned. He was born on the farm of Moses and Susan Carver near Diamond Grove, Missouri. In 1865 slave raiders kidnapped him and his mother, Mary. He was found in Arkansas, but his mother never was (National Park Service). The Iowa State University archivist's account says Moses Carver offered a bushwhacker, John Bentley, 40 acres and a racehorse to bring back Mary and her child. It says Bentley came back with only the infant and kept the horse as payment (Fishbein, 1976). Mackintosh notes that the story of a horse given for his recovery comes from later accounts. He also notes that a 1932 American Magazine article was titled "A Boy Who Was Traded for a Horse" (Mackintosh, 1977). The same account says he was a frail child. It says he had whooping cough when he was returned and was too weak for field work (Fishbein, 1976). |
| George Washington Carver | Helped | His former enslavers. Moses and Susan Carver had owned his mother. They raised him after the kidnapping and Emancipation. He learned to read and write in their home (Fishbein, 1976). |
| George Washington Carver | Helped | People who took him in. In Neosho he lived with Mariah and Andrew Watkins. In Winterset, Iowa, a white couple encouraged him to apply to Simpson College (Science History Institute, Encyclopedia of Alabama). |
| George Washington Carver | Helped | A teacher who redirected him. Simpson College admitted him in September 1890 as an art major. He was its only African American student. His art teacher, Etta Budd, worried that he would struggle to find work as an artist. She saw plants he had hybridized. Then she suggested he transfer to Iowa State, where her father, J. L. Budd, taught horticulture (Encyclopedia of Alabama, Fishbein, 1976). |
| George Washington Carver | Helped | Booker T. Washington. Washington invited him to lead agriculture and a new experiment station at Tuskegee. He began there on October 8, 1896. The Science History Institute says Washington sought him out as the only African American with an advanced degree in scientific agriculture. The relationship later became strained. In 1910 the agriculture department graduated only two students. After that, Washington removed him from charge of it and made him head of a new Department of Research. In 1912 Washington warned him of criticism of his teaching (Mackintosh, 1977). |
| George Washington Carver | Helped | Recognition after 1915. He became a fellow of Britain's Royal Society of Arts in 1916. He received the NAACP's Spingarn Medal in 1923 (Fishbein, 1976). |
| Yuan Longping | Barrier | Destroyed seedlings. In 1968 his trial seedlings were destroyed the day after planting. A sign at the memorial park on his former school's campus marks the site (Hunan Daily, 2023). An essay by He Lushe and He Wenkui dates this to the night of May 18, 1968. It says more than 700 seedlings of male-sterile material were pulled up and the culprit was never identified. It also says that four days later he found five surviving seedlings in an abandoned well and went on with the work using them (He and He, 2025). |
| Yuan Longping | Helped | Protection from the state. In his oral autobiography, Yuan says that Xiong Yanheng of the State Science and Technology Commission found his paper. Xiong passed it to bureau director Zhao Shiying. The Commission's leader Nie Rongzhen approved. In May 1966 Zhao then wrote to order local officials to support the research. In 1967 the Hunan Science Commission made his work a provincial project and gave it 400 yuan. It also assigned him two former students, Li Bihu and Yin Huaqi, as assistants. |
| Yuan Longping | Helped | Assistants who spoke for him. According to the biographies summarized by Schmalzer, Li and Yin telegraphed the State Science Commission when he was sent to the coal mine. The same biographies say their poor peasant backgrounds made them politically secure and that he soon returned to research. |
| Yuan Longping | Helped | A national team. In November 1970 his assistant Li Bihu and Feng Keshan, a technician at a farm on Hainan Island, found a wild male-sterile rice plant there. It became the key breeding material. From 1971 the material was shared with more than 20 research units in 13 provinces. In 1972 hybrid rice became a national priority project. In October 1973 he announced that the three-line system (a male-sterile line, a line that maintains its sterility, and a line that restores fertility in the hybrid) was complete. |
| Yuan Longping | Not overcome | He was nominated three times for the Chinese Academy of Sciences but was never elected. Even so, he was elected to the Chinese Academy of Engineering in 1995. In 2006 he was elected a foreign associate of the U.S. National Academy of Sciences. Schmalzer links his failure to enter the Chinese Academy of Sciences to that academy's shift from applied to basic science after 1978. Under that shift, a technology for hybridizing rice counted for less. |
| Yuan Longping | Note | A team achievement. Hybrid rice was a team achievement. Li Bihu and the farm technician Feng Keshan found the wild plant while Yuan was in Beijing. In 1973 Zhang Xiancheng's team found the restorer lines that completed the breeding system. The historian Sigrid Schmalzer notes that hybrid rice was developed through a network of peasants, technicians, and scientists. She also notes that Mao-era accounts presented it as "mass science." His name did not appear in print on the work from 1966 until after Mao's death. His biographies and his own later accounts say the accepted view was that rice, which pollinates itself, would not show hybrid vigor. They say this view came from a U.S. genetics textbook by Sinnott and Dunn. Schmalzer calls this "greatly overblown." She says the claim was not a Western consensus. She adds that hybrid sorghum, another self-pollinating crop, was already spreading in China by the mid-1960s. |
| Mary Engle Pennington | Helped | Supportive faculty. Penn professors used a rarely invoked university statute for "extraordinary cases" to admit her to graduate study. She earned a doctorate in chemistry in 1895, at 22. Her dissertation was on derivatives of columbium and tantalum. The Science History Institute says her professors, particularly the chemist Edgar Fahs Smith, accepted her into the PhD program. Smith later wrote that she had done this work "in this laboratory in 1895" (Smith, 1905). |
| Mary Engle Pennington | Helped | Harvey Wiley. The chief of the Bureau of Chemistry hired her. According to the Science History Institute, he also stepped in to keep her in the post. She began working with him on cold storage in 1905. In 1907 she became the first chief of the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Food Research Laboratory. It was created to support enforcement of the 1906 Pure Food and Drugs Act. At her insistence the laboratory was in Philadelphia rather than Washington. Its staff ranged from 4 to 50. |
| Mary Engle Pennington | Helped | Persuading industry rather than punishing it. Instead of closing unsanitary egg-breaking plants, she persuaded them to refrigerate and use sanitary methods. She also helped create the first scientific egg-grading charts (Women in World History). Her laboratory found that poultry kept good quality for a year at zero degrees Fahrenheit (Penn Gazette, 2022). |
| Mary Engle Pennington | Helped | Professional recognition. In 1920 she became the first woman member of the American Society of Refrigerating Engineers. The society elected her a fellow in 1947 (1948 per ASHRAE) (Women in World History, Science History Institute). |
| Fritz Haber | Barrier | Family expectations. His father, a merchant in dyes and pharmaceuticals in Breslau, expected him to train for the family business. Haber went to university only after his uncle Hermann helped persuade his father (Friedrich, 2016). After his 1891 doctorate he tried his father's business for about six months, and it did not suit him (Dictionary of Scientific Biography). |
| Fritz Haber | Barrier | Gaps in training. Short jobs in industry showed him "pressing deficiencies" in his education, particularly in chemical technology. He applied several times to work with the physical chemist Wilhelm Ostwald but never got the post. He later said he had never attended a lecture on physical chemistry other than his own (Friedrich, 2016). |
| Fritz Haber | Barrier | Public criticism. Walther Nernst said in talks and in print that Haber's equilibrium value was "far from the truth" (Friedrich, 2016). The Dictionary of Scientific Biography says the error lay in a constant Nernst used in his calculations. Their exchange took place at the Bunsen Society meeting in Hamburg in 1907 (Max Planck Institute for the History of Science). Nernst published an article on the ammonia equilibrium in August 1907 (Nernst, 1907). |
| Fritz Haber | Helped | Family support for science. His uncle Hermann, who owned a liberal newspaper, gave him space in his apartment for chemical experiments when he was a schoolboy (Friedrich, 2016). |
| Fritz Haber | Helped | A challenge and a collaborator. Nernst's criticism led Haber to repeat his measurements. With Robert Le Rossignol, from William Ramsay's London laboratory, he turned to high pressures. At about 200 atmospheres and with an osmium catalyst, they got a yield of about 18% (Friedrich, 2016). |
| Fritz Haber | Helped | Industry partnership. BASF partnered with him in 1908. In 1909 he showed a working ammonia apparatus to BASF representatives (BASF). On Bosch's advice BASF bought the rights. During World War I Haber received royalties of about fifteen marks per ton of fixed nitrogen (Dictionary of Scientific Biography). |
| Fritz Haber | Helped | Carl Bosch and Alwin Mittasch. Bosch led the industrial scale-up, and Mittasch led the catalyst work. They replaced osmium with iron. They used a Swedish ore whose impurities made the catalyst more active (Friedrich, 2016). The first ammonia synthesis plant opened at Oppau on September 9, 1913 (BASF). |
| Fritz Haber | Helped | A patron and a new institute. The banker Leopold Koppel funded a Kaiser Wilhelm Institute for Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry in Berlin-Dahlem, which opened in 1912. On the recommendation of Svante Arrhenius, Haber became its first director. |
| Nikolai Vavilov | Barrier | His colleagues purged. After his arrest, Lysenko took over his Institute of Genetics. At his Institute of Plant Industry, at least 10 leading researchers were arrested and shot or died in prison. Also, 12 spent years in prison or exile, and more than 26 were dismissed. |
| Nikolai Vavilov | Helped | Family means and education. He was born in Moscow on November 25, 1887 (Embryo Project) to a prosperous merchant family. He was one of seven children. He graduated from the Moscow Agricultural Institute in 1911 (Janick, 2015). |
| Nikolai Vavilov | Helped | Training abroad. In 1913 and 1914 he studied with the geneticist William Bateson at the John Innes Horticultural Institution and with Rowland Biffen at Cambridge. He later credited Bateson as a great influence (Embryo Project). |
| Nikolai Vavilov | Helped | Loyal colleagues. During the Siege of Leningrad, staff of his institute protected the seed collection without eating it. They tied seed boxes into bundles against rats. They sealed the rooms and checked the seals daily. They kept three to five people on duty around the clock. Even so, thieves took small amounts of seed in the spring of 1942. The institute's historian counts more than 20 specialists and scientists who lost their lives saving the collection. The historian also reports that the institute lost more than 30 researchers in the first autumn of the siege alone, to bombing, starvation, or fighting at the front (Loskutov, 2021). Other sources cited in this document give counts from 9 upward, depending on whom they include. |
| Nikolai Vavilov | Helped | International standing. He wrote to geneticists abroad, including Theodosius Dobzhansky, and invited Bateson to Russia (Borinskaya et al., 2019). The Royal Society elected him a foreign member in 1942, while he was in prison. |
Key figures
| Measure | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| People who report feeling lonely | About 1 in 6 worldwide (15.8%) | WHO Commission on Social Connection (2025) |
| Deaths linked to loneliness | An estimated 871,000 per year, about 100 every hour | WHO Commission on Social Connection (2025) |
| Loneliness by group | 21% among adolescents, 24.3% in low-income countries, and 11% in high-income countries | WHO Commission on Social Connection (2025) |
| Survival advantage of strong social relationships | About 50% higher likelihood | Holt-Lunstad et al. (2010) |
| Asch conformity experiments | When people judged line lengths alone, they erred under 1% of the time (0.7%). With a unanimous group giving wrong answers, 36.8% of responses conformed. 94 of 123 participants (about 76%) conformed at least once, and 29 of 123 (about 24%) never conformed | Asch (1956) |
| Effect of one dissenting voice in the Asch experiments | When one other person gave the correct answer, conformity dropped to about 5% of trials | Asch (1956) |
| Young people who never had an adult mentor | About 1 in 3 (an estimated 16 million), including about 9 million considered at risk | MENTOR, The Mentoring Effect (2014), nationally representative U.S. survey |
| Postsecondary enrollment among at-risk young people | 45% of those with a mentor vs. 29% of those without. This is a correlation from a survey, not proof that mentoring caused the difference | MENTOR, The Mentoring Effect (2014) |
| In-group favoritism | A meta-analysis of 212 studies found that people cooperate more with members of their own group than with outsiders (d = 0.32). It found that this reflects favoritism toward the in-group more than hostility toward the out-group | Balliet, Wu, and De Dreu (2014) |
| Partner violence against women | An estimated 27% of ever-partnered women aged 15 to 49 have experienced physical or sexual violence from a partner, and 13% in the past year. This estimate is based on 366 studies covering 2 million women in 161 countries. Rates are higher in low-income countries. Childhood abuse and household dysfunction are covered under early-life adversity in the biological key figures | Sardinha et al. (2022) |
| Neighbors' earnings and happiness | U.S. panel data on 8,944 adults showed that people whose neighbors earned more reported lower happiness, holding their own income constant. The author found this was not explained by who chose to live where. German data found the opposite for neighbors. Once comparisons with coworkers and people of the same sex were accounted for, higher neighborhood income was linked to more happiness. Comparisons with those peers predicted lower wellbeing (Mayraz, Wagner, and Schupp, 2009). Who people compare themselves with appears to matter more than neighbors as such | Luttmer (2005) |
| Partner violence and women's work | Among 1,311 Illinois welfare recipients, recent partner violence was linked to unstable employment over three years, largely through health problems (National Institute of Justice). In Tanzania, women who had been abused earned less than women who had not (World Bank). A Colombian study found the opposite. In that study, partner violence increased women's employment, possibly as a way to escape (EAFIT seminar abstract). A peer-reviewed study using Colombian survey data also reported this positive link (Fajardo-Gonzalez, 2021). All are observational, so the effect of adult partner violence on achievement is rated C | NIJ, World Bank, EAFIT, Fajardo-Gonzalez (2021) |
| Trickle-down consumption | This study used variation across U.S. states and years. Non-rich households exposed to higher top incomes spent a larger share of income, especially on visible goods. They reported more financial strain and lived in states with more personal bankruptcies. Middle-income households might have saved an additional 2.6% to 3.2% of their income by the mid-2000s had top incomes grown at the same rate as median income. The authors judge status-driven spending the most consistent explanation. Other work is mixed. A related study supports such "expenditure cascades" (Frank, Levine, and Dijk, 2014). But a working paper found no effect when comparison groups were defined by census division (Wang, working paper) | Bertrand and Morse (2016) |
| Social isolation, loneliness, and mortality | A meta-analysis of 90 prospective cohort studies (2,205,199 adults) found that social isolation was associated with a 32% higher risk of death from any cause (pooled effect 1.32). It found that loneliness was associated with a 14% higher risk (1.14). Isolation was also associated with higher cardiovascular (1.34) and cancer (1.24) mortality. The studies are observational, so the link may partly reflect poorer health causing isolation. An independent reproduction found the main results robust, but most publication bias adjustments gave somewhat smaller effects | Wang et al. (2023), Molo et al. (2024) |
| Social relationships, heart disease, and stroke | A meta-analysis of longitudinal studies in high-income countries (16 datasets, 4,628 coronary heart disease and 3,002 stroke events over 3 to 21 years) looked at social ties. It found that poor social relationships were associated with a 29% higher risk of coronary heart disease and a 32% higher risk of stroke. In 479,054 UK Biobank participants, isolation and loneliness were associated with about 36% to 49% higher risk of first heart attack and stroke after adjusting only for demographics. But conventional risk factors and existing chronic conditions explained most of this risk | Valtorta et al. (2016), Hakulinen et al. (2018) |
| Loneliness and dementia | A meta-analysis of 21 longitudinal samples (608,561 people) found that loneliness was associated with a 31% higher risk of dementia (hazard ratio 1.31). In 16 samples (103,387 people), loneliness was associated with a 15% higher risk of cognitive impairment. The associations held after accounting for depression and social isolation. The studies are observational, and they measured loneliness in different ways. Early, undiagnosed dementia may itself cause loneliness | Luchetti et al. (2024) |
| Conformity across 133 Asch-type studies | A meta-analysis of 133 Asch-type line judgment studies from 17 countries found that conformity in U.S. studies had declined since the 1950s. It also found that countries scoring as more collectivist generally showed higher conformity. The culture comparison is at the country level. A later Asch replication with 140 Japanese students found Japanese participants conformed no more than Americans | Bond and Smith (1996), Takano and Sogon (2008) |
| Social influence in an online music market | In an online "music market," 14,341 participants were randomly assigned to see or not see other people's download counts. Stronger social influence made song success both more unequal and less predictable. Quality only partly determined success. The best songs rarely did poorly and the worst rarely did well, but any other result was possible. The setting was one website with unknown songs, so the size of the effect in real markets is uncertain | Salganik et al. (2006) |
| Herding in online ratings | On a social news website, researchers randomly gave 101,281 comments an extra up-vote, a down-vote, or no change over five months. A single positive vote made the next rating 32% more likely to be positive. It raised final ratings by 25% on average. Other users tended to correct negative votes. The effect varied by topic, and the study covers one site | Muchnik et al. (2013) |
| Judges' in-group bias in Israeli courts | In Israeli small claims courts from 2000 to 2004, cases were effectively randomly assigned to Arab or Jewish judges. Claims were about 17 to 20 percentage points more likely to be accepted when the judge shared the plaintiff's ethnicity. The bias was larger after more terrorist violence near the court. The main sample was 1,748 cases. A study of juvenile courts in one U.S. state with random judge assignment found the opposite pattern, with judges harsher on defendants of their own race | Shayo and Zussman (2011), Depew et al. (2017) |
| Jury pool racial composition and convictions | In felony trials in two Florida counties from 2000 to 2010, juries drawn from all-white jury pools convicted Black defendants 16 percentage points more often than white defendants. The gap disappeared when the pool included at least one Black member. The study used day-to-day random variation in who was called for jury duty. It covered about 700 trials, and about 40% of pools had no Black members | Anwar et al. (2012) |
| Partisan favoritism in scholarship choices | In a U.S. experiment, online panel members chose between two scholarship applicants (610 in the party version). About 80% of Democrats and Republicans picked the applicant from their own party. The authors found that "partisanship simply trumped academic excellence." Racial in-group preference was weaker, with European Americans slightly favoring the African American applicant. A follow-up in Belgium, Great Britain, Spain (the Basque Country), and the United States found that partisans discriminated against opposing partisans more than against religious, linguistic, ethnic, or regional out-groups. Both are hypothetical choices in surveys. Another study found that even strongly polarized partisans were no more likely to intentionally harm opponents | Iyengar and Westwood (2015), Westwood et al. (2018), Lelkes and Westwood (2017) |
| Women and girls killed by partners or family, 2024 | An estimated 83,000 women and girls were intentionally killed worldwide in 2024. Of these, about 50,000 (60%) were killed by intimate partners or family members, compared with 11% of male homicides. The UN notes that country data are incomplete. The UN also notes that the drop from the 2023 estimate mostly reflects differences in data availability, not a real decline. An earlier systematic review of 66 countries found that intimate partners alone committed a median of 38.6% of female homicides, against 6.3% of male homicides | Stöckl et al. (2013), UNODC and UN Women (2025) |
| Partner violence and later depression | A meta-analysis of 16 longitudinal studies with 36,163 participants looked at partner violence. Women who experienced partner violence had about twice the odds of later developing depressive symptoms (pooled odds ratio 1.97 from six studies). Partner violence was also associated with later suicide attempts. The link ran both ways, since depressive symptoms also predicted later partner violence. Few studies controlled for confounders beyond demographics | Devries et al. (2013) |
| Disruptive classmates and adult earnings | Economists used school records from one Florida county linked to later earnings. They compared school cohorts that by chance had more classmates from families linked to domestic violence. Earlier work had shown this group disrupts classrooms. Having one such disruptive peer in a class of 25 throughout elementary school was associated with about 3% lower earnings at ages 24 to 28 for classmates. It was also associated with a nearly one percentage point lower chance of a college degree. Unequal exposure to these peers explained about 5% of the gap in earnings between rich and poor children in the data | Carrell, Hoekstra, and Kuka (2018) |
| Mentoring for low-track students in Germany | A randomized trial tested a German program that paired students in low-track secondary schools with university student mentors. The relationships were meant to last about two years. After one year, mentoring raised an index of math grades, patience and social skills, and job market orientation by over half a standard deviation for students from low socioeconomic backgrounds. It had no effect for better-off students. After three years, gains in grades and job market orientation persisted, and early school-to-work transitions improved. Gains in patience and social skills faded. The estimation sample was 308 students (153 assigned to mentoring, 155 controls) in 19 schools in 10 cities | Resnjanskij et al. (2024) |
| Mentoring workshop for junior women economists | The American Economic Association randomly assigned 365 junior women economists who applied to a mentoring workshop between 2004 and 2014 to attend or not. Attendees later published about 1.6 more papers before tenure. They were 6.9 and 9.3 percentage points more likely to hold tenure at a top 30 or top 50 ranked institution. The program did not significantly change the overall chance of getting tenure anywhere | Ginther et al. (2020) |
| First jobs at a parent's workplace, Sweden | Researchers used Swedish population records on graduates from 1988 to 1995. They found that about 10% of young people found their first job at a workplace where a parent worked. This rose to 14% of those leaving after compulsory school and fell to 3.2% of university graduates. According to the discussion-paper version, these graduates found work about half a year sooner and were more likely to stay, though they started on lower wages. Parental ties mattered most for less-educated graduates and in years of high unemployment. Weaker ties, such as classmates' parents, showed no such pattern | Kramarz and Skans (2014) |
| Negative social comparison in depression and anxiety | A systematic review of 54 studies, 14 of them pooled in a meta-analysis, looked at people with clinical depression or anxiety. Among them, more negative views of oneself relative to others were associated with more severe symptoms (weighted correlations of minus 0.53 for depression and minus 0.39 for anxiety). Experimental studies suggested that depression and anxiety are related to how people react to comparisons with those better off. The studies are mostly correlational and few used clinical samples, so the direction of cause is unclear | McCarthy and Morina (2020) |
| Income inequality and depression | A review of 26 studies found that nearly two-thirds reported higher depression risk where income inequality was higher. Five of six longitudinal studies reported this too. The pooled risk ratio was 1.19 across 12 studies. The review proposed social comparison as one of several pathways. These are mostly cross-sectional comparisons between places. A preregistered study of about 550,000 Norwegian adolescents from 2010 to 2019 found that changes in inequality within municipalities did not meaningfully predict depressive symptoms | Nilsen et al. (2026), Patel et al. (2018) |
| Income rank and mental distress | A British cohort of 30,000 people completed health questionnaires yearly for up to 17 years. Both income and income rank within a region or comparison group predicted current and future mental distress. But when both were included, only rank remained significant. Distress was self-reported, and the design is correlational. A later study by members of the same team found a similar pattern for depressive symptoms in U.S. and English cohorts, with rank explaining a small share of variation | Hounkpatin et al. (2015), Wood et al. (2012) |
References cited on this page
- Bertrand, M., & Morse, A. (2016). Trickle-down consumption. Review of Economics and Statistics, 98(5), 863-879. DOI
- Frank, R. H., Levine, A. S., & Dijk, O. (2014). Expenditure cascades. Review of Behavioral Economics, 1(1-2), 55-73
- Wang, H. (n.d., no year printed, PDF file created November 28, 2019, unpublished). Expenditure cascade hypothesis: no evidence at the level of census divisions. Job market paper, University of Delaware. PDF
- Park, J. (2024). Do expenditure cascades exist? Evidence from Bush administration tax reforms. KDIS Working Paper 24-06, KDI School of Public Policy and Management. KDI School
- Riger, S., & Staggs, S. (2004). Impact of intimate partner violence on women's labor force participation: final report (NCJ 207143). National Institute of Justice
- Vyas, S. (2013). Estimating the association between women's earnings and partner violence: evidence from the 2008-2009 Tanzania National Panel Survey. Women's Voice, Agency, and Participation Research Series No. 2. World Bank
- EAFIT. Intimate partner violence and women's employment: evidence from Colombia (seminar abstract, presenter not named, page no longer online as of October 2026)
- Holt-Lunstad, J., Smith, T. B., & Layton, J. B. (2010). Social relationships and mortality risk: a meta-analytic review. PLoS Medicine, 7(7), e1000316. DOI
- Putnam, R. D. (2000). Bowling Alone. New York: Simon and Schuster.
- Balliet, D., Wu, J., & De Dreu, C. K. W. (2014). Ingroup favoritism in cooperation: a meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 140(6), 1556-1581. Semantic Scholar
- Sardinha, L., Maheu-Giroux, M., Stöckl, H., Meyer, S. R., & García-Moreno, C. (2022). Global, regional, and national prevalence estimates of physical or sexual, or both, intimate partner violence against women in 2018. Lancet, 399(10327), 803-813. DOI02664-7)
- Luttmer, E. F. P. (2005). Neighbors as negatives: relative earnings and well-being. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 120(3), 963-1002. DOI
- Mayraz, G., Wagner, G. G., & Schupp, J. (2009). Life satisfaction and relative income: perceptions and evidence. CEP Discussion Paper 938, Centre for Economic Performance, London School of Economics. LSE Research Online
- Asch, S. E. (1956). Studies of independence and conformity: I. A minority of one against a unanimous majority. Psychological Monographs, 70(9), Whole No. 416, 1-70. DOI
- Janis, I. L. (1972). Victims of Groupthink. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
- Tajfel, H., & Turner, J. C. (1979). An integrative theory of intergroup conflict. In W. G. Austin and S. Worchel (Eds.), The Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations (pp. 33-47). Monterey, CA: Brooks/Cole.
- MENTOR: The Mentoring Effect, executive summary (2014)
- Anwar, S., Bayer, P., & Hjalmarsson, R. (2012). The impact of jury race in criminal trials. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 127(2), 1017-1055. DOI
- Bond, R., & Smith, P. B. (1996). Culture and conformity: A meta-analysis of studies using Asch's (1952b, 1956) line judgment task. Psychological Bulletin, 119(1), 111-137. DOI
- Carrell, S. E., Hoekstra, M., & Kuka, E. (2018). The long-run effects of disruptive peers. American Economic Review, 108(11), 3377-3415. DOI
- Devries, K. M., Mak, J. Y., Bacchus, L. J., Child, J. C., Falder, G., Petzold, M., Astbury, J., & Watts, C. H. (2013). Intimate partner violence and incident depressive symptoms and suicide attempts: A systematic review of longitudinal studies. PLoS Medicine, 10(5), e1001439. DOI
- Ginther, D. K., Currie, J. M., Blau, F. D., & Croson, R. T. A. (2020). Can mentoring help female assistant professors in economics? An evaluation by randomized trial. AEA Papers and Proceedings, 110, 205-209. DOI
- Hakulinen, C., Pulkki-Råback, L., Virtanen, M., Jokela, M., Kivimäki, M., & Elovainio, M. (2018). Social isolation and loneliness as risk factors for myocardial infarction, stroke and mortality: UK Biobank cohort study of 479 054 men and women. Heart, 104(18), 1536-1542. DOI
- Iyengar, S., & Westwood, S. J. (2015). Fear and loathing across party lines: New evidence on group polarization. American Journal of Political Science, 59(3), 690-707. DOI
- Kramarz, F., & Skans, O. N. (2014). When strong ties are strong: Networks and youth labour market entry. Review of Economic Studies, 81(3), 1164-1200. DOI
- Luchetti, M., Aschwanden, D., Sesker, A. A., Zhu, X., O'Súilleabháin, P. S., Stephan, Y., Terracciano, A., & Sutin, A. R. (2024). A meta-analysis of loneliness and risk of dementia using longitudinal data from >600,000 individuals. Nature Mental Health, 2(11), 1350-1361. DOI
- McCarthy, P. A., & Morina, N. (2020). Exploring the association of social comparison with depression and anxiety: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy, 27(5), 640-671. DOI
- Muchnik, L., Aral, S., & Taylor, S. J. (2013). Social influence bias: A randomized experiment. Science, 341(6146), 647-651. DOI
- Patel, V., Burns, J. K., Dhingra, M., Tarver, L., Kohrt, B. A., & Lund, C. (2018). Income inequality and depression: A systematic review and meta-analysis of the association and a scoping review of mechanisms. World Psychiatry, 17(1), 76-89. DOI
- Resnjanskij, S., Ruhose, J., Wiederhold, S., Woessmann, L., & Wedel, K. (2024). Can mentoring alleviate family disadvantage in adolescence? A field experiment to improve labor market prospects. Journal of Political Economy, 132(3), 1013-1062. DOI
- Salganik, M. J., Dodds, P. S., & Watts, D. J. (2006). Experimental study of inequality and unpredictability in an artificial cultural market. Science, 311(5762), 854-856. DOI
- Shayo, M., & Zussman, A. (2011). Judicial ingroup bias in the shadow of terrorism. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 126(3), 1447-1484. DOI
- Stöckl, H., Devries, K., Rotstein, A., Abrahams, N., Campbell, J., Watts, C., & Moreno, C. G. (2013). The global prevalence of intimate partner homicide: A systematic review. Lancet, 382(9895), 859-865. DOI
- Valtorta, N. K., Kanaan, M., Gilbody, S., Ronzi, S., & Hanratty, B. (2016). Loneliness and social isolation as risk factors for coronary heart disease and stroke: Systematic review and meta-analysis of longitudinal observational studies. Heart, 102(13), 1009-1016. DOI
- Wang, F., Gao, Y., Han, Z., Yu, Y., Long, Z., Jiang, X., et al. (2023). A systematic review and meta-analysis of 90 cohort studies of social isolation, loneliness and mortality. Nature Human Behaviour, 7(8), 1307-1319. DOI
- Wood, A. M., Boyce, C. J., Moore, S. C., & Brown, G. D. A. (2012). An evolutionary based social rank explanation of why low income predicts mental distress: A 17 year cohort study of 30,000 people. Journal of Affective Disorders, 136(3), 882-888. DOI
- UNODC and UN Women (2025). Femicides in 2024: Global estimates of intimate partner/family member femicides. United Nations publication
- Fajardo-Gonzalez, J. (2021). Domestic violence, decision-making power, and female employment in Colombia. Review of Economics of the Household, 19(1), 233-254
Sources for the actions
- Associated Press. (2026, January). Google and chatbot maker Character to settle lawsuit alleging chatbot pushed teen to suicide. WTOP. link B Moderate
- Headquarters for Advancement of Measures to Address Loneliness and Isolation, Cabinet Office of Japan. (2025). Priority plan to facilitate the promotion of the policies regarding measures to address loneliness and isolation (June 11, 2024, partially amended May 27, 2025) [Provisional English translation]. link B Moderate
- Cooper, M., Avery, L., Scott, J., Ashley, K., Jordan, C., Errington, L., & Flynn, D. (2022). Effectiveness and active ingredients of social prescribing interventions targeting mental health: A systematic review. BMJ Open, 12(7), e060214. link C Limited
- De Freitas, J., Oğuz-Uğuralp, Z., Uğuralp, A. K., & Puntoni, S. (2025). AI companions reduce loneliness. Journal of Consumer Research, 52(6), 1126-1148. Figures in Part 4 are from the 2024 preprint (arXiv:2407.19096). link C Limited
- Fang, C. M., Liu, A. R., Danry, V., Lee, E., Chan, S. W. T., Pataranutaporn, P., et al. (2025). How AI and human behaviors shape psychosocial effects of extended chatbot use: A longitudinal randomized controlled study (arXiv:2503.17473, version 2). arXiv. link C Limited
- Gilbody, S., Littlewood, E., McMillan, D., Atha, L., Bailey, D., Baird, K., et al. (2024). Behavioural activation to mitigate the psychological impacts of COVID-19 restrictions on older people in England and Wales (BASIL+): A pragmatic randomised controlled trial. The Lancet Healthy Longevity, 5(2), e97-e107. link B Moderate
- Kahlon, M. K., Aksan, N., Aubrey, R., Clark, N., Cowley-Morillo, M., Jacobs, E. A., et al. (2021). Effect of layperson-delivered, empathy-focused program of telephone calls on loneliness, depression, and anxiety among adults during the COVID-19 pandemic: A randomized clinical trial. JAMA Psychiatry, 78(6), 616-622. link B Moderate
- Padilla, S. (2025, October 13). First-in-nation AI chatbot safeguards signed into law [Press release]. California State Senate. link B Moderate
- UK Government. (2018, January 17). PM commits to government-wide drive to tackle loneliness [Press release]. link B Moderate
- Becker, J., Brackbill, D., & Centola, D. (2017). Network dynamics of social influence in the wisdom of crowds. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 114(26), E5070-E5076. link B Moderate
- Berndt, S., & Holzer, H. (2023, December). The State Department Dissent Channel: History and impact. The Foreign Service Journal. American Foreign Service Association. link C Limited
- Columbia Accident Investigation Board. (2003). Columbia Accident Investigation Board report: Volume 1. National Aeronautics and Space Administration. link B Moderate
- Congressional Research Service. (2003, September 2). NASA's Space Shuttle Columbia: Synopsis of the report of the Columbia Accident Investigation Board (RS21606). link B Moderate
- Gill, C. R., & Epstein, S. B. (2017, April 7). The U.S. Department of State's "Dissent Channel" (CRS In Focus IF10631). Congressional Research Service. link B Moderate
- Lorenz, J., Rauhut, H., Schweitzer, F., & Helbing, D. (2011). How social influence can undermine the wisdom of crowd effect. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 108(22), 9020-9025. link C Limited
- Nemeth, C., Brown, K., & Rogers, J. (2001). Devil's advocate versus authentic dissent: Stimulating quantity and quality. European Journal of Social Psychology, 31(6), 707-720. link C Limited
- Chang, E. H., Milkman, K. L., Gromet, D. M., Rebele, R. W., Massey, C., Duckworth, A. L., et al. (2019). The mixed effects of online diversity training. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 116(16), 7778-7783. link B Moderate
- Lai, C. K., Skinner, A. L., Cooley, E., Murrar, S., Brauer, M., Devos, T., et al. (2016). Reducing implicit racial preferences: II. Intervention effectiveness across time. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 145(8), 1001-1016. link B Moderate
- Rao, G. (2019). Familiarity does not breed contempt: Generosity, discrimination, and diversity in Delhi schools. American Economic Review, 109(3), 774-809. link B Moderate
- Scacco, A., & Warren, S. S. (2018). Can social contact reduce prejudice and discrimination? Evidence from a field experiment in Nigeria. American Political Science Review, 112(3), 654-677. link B Moderate
- Abramsky, T., Devries, K., Kiss, L., Nakuti, J., Kyegombe, N., Starmann, E., et al. (2014). Findings from the SASA! Study: A cluster randomized controlled trial to assess the impact of a community mobilization intervention to prevent violence against women and reduce HIV risk in Kampala, Uganda. BMC Medicine, 12, 122. link C Limited
- Arce, R., Arias, E., Novo, M., & Fariña, F. (2020). Are interventions with batterers effective? A meta-analytical review. Psychosocial Intervention, 29(3), 153-164. link C Limited
- Babcock, J. C., Green, C. E., & Robie, C. (2004). Does batterers' treatment work? A meta-analytic review of domestic violence treatment. Clinical Psychology Review, 23(8), 1023-1053. link C Limited: (changed from B on October 8, 2026, because a later meta-analysis reached different conclusions on effect size and program type, leaving the size of effects unresolved)
- Bloom, T. L., Perrin, N., Brown, M. L., Campbell, J., Clough, A., Grace, K. T., et al. (2023). Concerned friends of intimate partner violence survivors: Results from the myPlan randomized controlled trial on college campuses. BMC Public Health, 23(1), 1033. link C Limited: for the document's use (B for its own outcomes)
- Buller, A. M., Peterman, A., Ranganathan, M., Bleile, A., Hidrobo, M., & Heise, L. (2018). A mixed-method review of cash transfers and intimate partner violence in low- and middle-income countries. The World Bank Research Observer, 33(2), 218-258. link B Moderate
- Jewkes, R., Nduna, M., Levin, J., Jama, N., Dunkle, K., Puren, A., et al. (2008). Impact of Stepping Stones on incidence of HIV and HSV-2 and sexual behaviour in rural South Africa: Cluster randomised controlled trial. BMJ, 337, a506. link B Moderate
- Pronyk, P. M., Hargreaves, J. R., Kim, J. C., Morison, L. A., Phetla, G., Watts, C., et al. (2006). Effect of a structural intervention for the prevention of intimate-partner violence and HIV in rural South Africa: A cluster randomised trial. The Lancet, 368(9551), 1973-1983. link B Moderate
- Brooks, W., Donovan, K., & Johnson, T. R. (2018). Mentors or teachers? Microenterprise training in Kenya. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 10(4), 196-221. link B Moderate
- Chetty, R., Jackson, M. O., Kuchler, T., Stroebel, J., Hendren, N., Fluegge, R. B., et al. (2022a). Social capital I: Measurement and associations with economic mobility. Nature, 608(7921), 108-121. link C Limited: (B for the association)
- Chetty, R., Jackson, M. O., Kuchler, T., Stroebel, J., Hendren, N., Fluegge, R. B., et al. (2022b). Social capital II: Determinants of economic connectedness. Nature, 608(7921), 122-134. link B Moderate
- Herrera, C., Grossman, J. B., Kauh, T. J., & McMaken, J. (2011). Mentoring in schools: An impact study of Big Brothers Big Sisters school-based mentoring. Child Development, 82(1), 346-361. link B Moderate
- Rajkumar, K., Saint-Jacques, G., Bojinov, I., Brynjolfsson, E., & Aral, S. (2022). A causal test of the strength of weak ties. Science, 377(6612), 1304-1310. link B Moderate
- Welsh, B. C. (2025). The longitudinal-experimental design and the development and prevention of criminal offending over the life-course: Advances in science and policy from the Cambridge-Somerville Youth Study. Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health, 35(2), 89-94. link B Moderate
- Welsh, B. C., Zane, S. N., Zimmerman, G. M., & Yohros, A. (2019). Association of a crime prevention program for boys with mortality 72 years after the intervention: Follow-up of a randomized clinical trial. JAMA Network Open, 2(3), e190782. link B Moderate
- Baker, M., Halberstam, Y., Kroft, K., Mas, A., & Messacar, D. (2023). Pay transparency and the gender gap. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 15(2), 157-183. link B Moderate
- Card, D., Mas, A., Moretti, E., & Saez, E. (2012). Inequality at work: The effect of peer salaries on job satisfaction. American Economic Review, 102(6), 2981-3003. link B Moderate
- Cullen, Z. B., & Pakzad-Hurson, B. (2023). Equilibrium effects of pay transparency. Econometrica, 91(3), 765-802. link B Moderate
- European Union. (2023). Directive (EU) 2023/970 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 10 May 2023 to strengthen the application of the principle of equal pay for equal work or work of equal value between men and women through pay transparency and enforcement mechanisms. Official Journal of the European Union. link B Moderate
- Meta. (2021, May 26). Giving people more control on Instagram and Facebook. link C Limited
- Hickin, N., Käll, A., Shafran, R., Sutcliffe, S., Manzotti, G., & Langan, D. (2021). The effectiveness of psychological interventions for loneliness: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology Review, 88, 102066. link B Moderate
- Masi, C. M., Chen, H.-Y., Hawkley, L. C., & Cacioppo, J. T. (2011). A meta-analysis of interventions to reduce loneliness. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 15(3), 219-266. link B Moderate
- Reed, N. S., Chen, J., Huang, A. R., Pike, J. R., Arnold, M., Burgard, S., et al. (2025). Hearing intervention, social isolation, and loneliness: A secondary analysis of the ACHIEVE randomized clinical trial. JAMA Internal Medicine, 185(7), 797-806. link B Moderate
- World Health Organization. (2025, June 30). Social connection linked to improved health and reduced risk of early death [News release]. link B Moderate: for prevalence, C for the deaths figure
- Levine, S. S., Apfelbaum, E. P., Bernard, M., Bartelt, V. L., Zajac, E. J., & Stark, D. (2014). Ethnic diversity deflates price bubbles. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 111(52), 18524-18529. link B Moderate
- Lu, L., Yuan, Y. C., & McLeod, P. L. (2012). Twenty-five years of hidden profiles in group decision making: A meta-analysis. Personality and Social Psychology Review, 16(1), 54-75. link B Moderate
- Mullen, B., Johnson, C., & Salas, E. (1991). Productivity loss in brainstorming groups: A meta-analytic integration. Basic and Applied Social Psychology, 12(1), 3-23. link B Moderate
- Sommers, S. R. (2006). On racial diversity and group decision making: Identifying multiple effects of racial composition on jury deliberations. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 90(4), 597-612. link B Moderate
- Paluck, E. L. (2009). Reducing intergroup prejudice and conflict using the media: A field experiment in Rwanda. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 96(3), 574-587. link B Moderate
- Pettigrew, T. F., & Tropp, L. R. (2006). A meta-analytic test of intergroup contact theory. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 90(5), 751-783. link B Moderate
- Coker, A. L., Bush, H. M., Cook-Craig, P. G., DeGue, S. A., Clear, E. R., Brancato, C. J., et al. (2017). RCT testing bystander effectiveness to reduce violence. American Journal of Preventive Medicine, 52(5), 566-578. link B Moderate
- De La Rue, L., Polanin, J. R., Espelage, D. L., & Pigott, T. D. (2017). A meta-analysis of school-based interventions aimed to prevent or reduce violence in teen dating relationships. Review of Educational Research, 87(1), 7-34. link B Moderate
- Feltner, C., Peat, C., Asher, G. N., Wright, S., Vaughan, J., Middleton, J. C., & Jonas, D. E. (2025). Screening for intimate partner violence and for caregiver abuse of older or vulnerable adults: An evidence report and systematic review for the US Preventive Services Task Force. JAMA, 334(4), 339-355. link B Moderate
- Flor, L. S., Spencer, C. N., Cagney, J., Gil, G. F., Aalruz, H., Abd ElHafeez, S., et al. (2026). Disease burden attributable to intimate partner violence against females and sexual violence against children in 204 countries and territories, 1990-2023: A systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2023. The Lancet, 407(10523), 31-52. link B Moderate
- Foshee, V. A., Bauman, K. E., Ennett, S. T., Linder, G. F., Benefield, T., & Suchindran, C. (2004). Assessing the long-term effects of the Safe Dates program and a booster in preventing and reducing adolescent dating violence victimization and perpetration. American Journal of Public Health, 94(4), 619-624. link B Moderate
- Miller, E., Tancredi, D. J., McCauley, H. L., Decker, M. R., Virata, M. C. D., Anderson, H. A., et al. (2012). "Coaching boys into men": A cluster-randomized controlled trial of a dating violence prevention program. Journal of Adolescent Health, 51(5), 431-438. link B Moderate
- Rivas, C., Ramsay, J., Sadowski, L., Davidson, L. L., Dunne, D., Eldridge, S., et al. (2015). Advocacy interventions to reduce or eliminate violence and promote the physical and psychosocial well-being of women who experience intimate partner abuse. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2015(12), CD005043. link C Limited
- Wolfe, D. A., Crooks, C., Jaffe, P., Chiodo, D., Hughes, R., Ellis, W., et al. (2009). A school-based program to prevent adolescent dating violence: A cluster randomized trial. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, 163(8), 692-699. link B Moderate
- Bettinger, E. P., & Baker, R. B. (2014). The effects of student coaching: An evaluation of a randomized experiment in student advising. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 36(1), 3-19. link B Moderate
- Fein, D., & Dastrup, S. (2022). Benefits that last: Long-term impact and cost-benefit findings for Year Up (OPRE Report 2022-77). Office of Planning, Research, and Evaluation, US Department of Health and Human Services. link B Moderate
- Kemple, J. J. (2008). Career academies: Long-term impacts on work, education, and transitions to adulthood. MDRC. link B Moderate
- Raposa, E. B., Rhodes, J., Stams, G. J. J. M., Card, N., Burton, S., Schwartz, S., et al. (2019). The effects of youth mentoring programs: A meta-analysis of outcome studies. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 48(3), 423-443. link B Moderate
- Breza, E., Kaur, S., & Shamdasani, Y. (2018). The morale effects of pay inequality. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 133(2), 611-663. link B Moderate
- Ferguson, C. J. (2025). Do social media experiments prove a link with mental health: A methodological and meta-analytic review. Psychology of Popular Media, 14(2), 201-206. link C Limited
- Hunt, M. G., Marx, R., Lipson, C., & Young, J. (2018). No more FOMO: Limiting social media decreases loneliness and depression. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, 37(10), 751-768. link B Moderate
- Lopes, M. V. V., Branje, K., David, A., Gennara, A., Haidt, J., Rausch, Z., et al. (2026). Effect of social media constraints on mental health: A systematic review and meta-analysis of experiments [Preprint]. medRxiv. link C Limited
- U.S. Preventive Services Task Force. (2025, June 24). [Recommendation on screening for intimate partner violence]. link B Moderate
- e-Gov Law Search, Digital Agency of Japan. (n.d.). Act on Advancement of Measures to Address Loneliness and Isolation (Act No. 45 of 2023) [in Japanese, with revision history]. link B Moderate