Contribution. He laid the mathematical foundation of genetics through crossing experiments with garden peas from 1856 to 1863. By his own account, he carefully examined more than 10,000 plants (Mendel, 1866). He published the work in 1866 as Experiments on Plant Hybrids. Modern plant and animal breeding builds on this work. He also studied hybridization in at least twenty other plant genera. But he published the results of only a few of these experiments (Fairbanks, 2022).
At a glance
Item
Detail
Dates
1822-1884
Field
Agriculture and food
Case type
Pioneer
Discrimination or exclusion
No
Factor coverage
Favorable entries (helped or barrier absent) and adverse entries (barrier or not overcome) by factor. Factor tags are this site's classification.
Poverty. He was born on July 20, 1822 in Hynčice (Heinzendorf), Silesia, into a German-speaking farming family. His parents were struggling farmers who could not pay for his studies. So at the grammar school in Opava he supported himself by tutoring other pupils (Mendel Museum). His sister Theresia gave up part of her dowry to help pay for his education (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory).
Illness. Once at school in Opava, and again at the Philosophical Institute in Olomouc, he had episodes of nervous illness. They were bad enough that he went home for months to recover (Fairbanks, 2022).
A vocation decided by circumstance. He entered the Augustinian monastery of St. Thomas in Brno in 1843. He later said that his circumstances decided his choice of vocation. His father had been crippled by an accident about three years before 1841. His father could no longer manage the farm. After Mendel chose the priesthood, his father sold the farmstead to Alois Sturm, the husband of Mendel's sister Veronika. The condition was that the buyer pay Mendel 100 florins and the costs of his first mass (Fairbanks, 2022).
Failed certification. He failed the teacher certification exam in 1850. At the University of Vienna, the physics examiners judged him "unqualified to teach physics." The natural history examiner Rudolf Kner wrote that he was "not yet competent to become a teacher" (Fairbanks, 2022). He tried again in May 1856. He fell ill during the written part and went home without finishing. He never became a certified teacher.
Little notice. He presented his results in two lectures to the Natural Science Society in Brno on February 8 and March 8, 1865 (Mendel, 1866). His 1866 paper appeared in the society's proceedings. He sent the paper to 133 associations of natural scientists and to libraries (Villanova University). But it was largely overlooked for 34 years. Fairbanks (2022) writes that "No one, including Mendel, recognized the importance of his theory in his day."
A teacher's recommendation. Friedrich Franz, his physics professor in Olomouc, recommended him for admission to the St. Thomas monastery. He was admitted to the order on October 9, 1843 (Fairbanks, 2022).
A monastery that invested in him. Abbot Cyril Napp sent him to the University of Vienna from 1851 to 1853. According to Fairbanks (2022), Napp was committed to applying scientific advances to farming. Mendel was due to stay one year and stayed almost two. He studied physics under Christian Doppler and botany under Franz Unger. Unger's courses introduced him to evolutionary ideas from before Darwin.
An educated community. Several of the friars at St. Thomas were highly educated. They worked as teachers and professors. Among them was the philosopher Matouš Klácel (Fairbanks, 2022).
Land, time, and a local society. The monastery gave him garden space for his experiments. The Natural Science Society of Brno heard his lectures and printed his paper.
Correspondence with a leading botanist. He sent an offprint to the botanist Carl Nägeli on December 31, 1866. He kept writing to him for years after. Nägeli kept the letters. They are the main record of Mendel's later hybridization experiments (Fairbanks, 2022).
Later scientists who reached the same results. In 1900 Hugo de Vries and Carl Correns each reached similar findings on their own and drew attention to his paper. Erich von Tschermak is often named as a third rediscoverer. But historians question whether he understood Mendel's ratios.
He died on January 6, 1884 without recognition for his work on heredity. He was elected abbot in 1868. Within about five years, his duties running the monastery largely ended his research. From 1874 he refused to accept a new law that raised taxes on monasteries. He called it "unjust." The government placed part of the monastery's property under administration (Masaryk University, 2022). The dispute was still unresolved when he died. He died of kidney disease that had worsened in 1883.
Nägeli, Fisher, and lost papers. Mendel wrote to the leading botanist Carl Nägeli. He repeated his work with hawkweed, which Nägeli also studied, but the results did not match. Historians disagree about whether Nägeli suggested the plant (Bicknell et al., 2016). Hawkweed mostly forms seeds without fertilization, which explains the difference. In 1936 R. A. Fisher argued that Mendel's data fit expectations too closely. No later study finds evidence of deliberate falsification (Franklin et al., 2008). Fairbanks (2019) describes the controversy as essentially resolved. But statisticians still disagree about whether the fit is unusually close. Pires and Branco (2010) accept that it is. They explain it by unconscious selection of repeated trials. Ellis et al. (2019) found that Mendel's ratios do not depart remarkably from expectation. Fairbanks (2022) also rejects the story that Darwin owned an uncut copy of Mendel's paper. He found no evidence that Darwin knew of Mendel. Accounts conflict on whether Mendel's papers were burned. A prior of the monastery recalled that Mendel burned his own papers in bitterness. Another account says they were burned after his death. Others recalled thousands of sheets surviving. So their fate remains uncertain (Fairbanks, 2022).
Pattern summary
Element
In this case
Door-opener
Friedrich Franz, Abbot Napp
Knowledge source
University of Vienna
Institutional support
Monastery, Natural Science Society of Brno
Built on recent work
Earlier plant hybridization research
Setback overcome
Failed his first teacher exam in 1850, then sent to Vienna
Barrier not overcome
No recognition in his lifetime, abbacy and tax dispute
Related barriers
Poverty, unequal access to education, rigid gatekeeping
Not independently verified. Sources disagree on the year of Mendel's first teacher exam (1849 or 1850). They also disagree on the dates of his pea experiments (some give 1854 to 1864). This site follows the stronger or majority source.
Also relevant: Bell, A., Chetty, R., Jaravel, X., Petkova, N., & Van Reenen, J. (2019). Who becomes an inventor in America? Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(2), 647-713. All references