Lack of mentors and networks
Lack of mentors and networks is a barrier to human progress within the social factors. The evidence for it, and the methods proposed to address it, follow.
Without mentors and networks, people are cut off from information and introductions.
Evidence
- Mentoring gap. About 1 in 3 young people, an estimated 16 million, never had an adult mentor. This includes about 9 million considered at risk (MENTOR, 2014, nationally representative U.S. survey).
- Enrollment. Among at-risk young people, 45% of those with a mentor enrolled in postsecondary education, against 29% of those without. This is a correlation from a survey, not proof that mentoring caused the difference.
- Source. The data come from an organization that promotes mentoring, so they are rated C.
What can be done
Actions rated on the strength-rating scale (A strong and replicated, B solid but limited, C weak or debated, D contested or failed), applied to the specific claim made.
- Year Up job training for young adults (B). A randomized evaluation of Year Up included 2,544 young adults. In that evaluation, Year Up raised average quarterly earnings by $1,895 (28%) in quarters 23 and 24 after random assignment. The evaluation found that gains "persisted undiminished" to the end of seven years. According to the evaluation, the program returned $2.46 per dollar spent (Fein and Dastrup, 2022). This is a government-funded evaluation report of one program.
- Career academies with employer partnerships in high schools (B). A randomized study followed more than 1,400 young people in nine U.S. high schools. In that study, students admitted to career academies earned 11% ($2,088) more per year over eight years. The gains were concentrated among young men (17%, $3,731 per year). But the academies did not raise high school graduation or postsecondary completion compared with other options (Kemple, 2008).
- Individual coaching for college students (B). In a randomized experiment, the coaching service InsideTrack contacted students regularly to set goals and build skills such as time management and self-advocacy. The experiment found that coached students were more likely to persist during coaching. They were also more likely to still be enrolled one year after coaching ended (Bettinger and Baker, 2014). Most participants were nontraditional students.
- One-on-one youth mentoring programs, with modest expectations (B). A meta-analysis of 70 outcome studies with 25,286 youth found a statistically significant effect across all youth outcomes. The effect was in the medium or moderate range for youth prevention programs. The authors stress "the modest impact of these programs as currently implemented." Effects were larger in evaluations that relied on youth self-report (Raposa et al., 2019). See the proposed methods below for school-based mentoring and the Cambridge-Somerville study.
Proposed and experimental methods
Methods that are proposed, under trial, approved in some places, or tried and then failed. Each shows a stage label and an evidence rating. A stage label shows how far a method has progressed, not whether it works. The stage labels are explained on the social factor page.
- Algorithmic weak-tie introductions (Large trial, B). LinkedIn ran experiments that randomly varied the connections suggested by its "People You May Know" algorithm. They covered over 20 million people over 5 years. During that time, 2 billion new ties and 600,000 new jobs were created. The study found that moderately weak ties (measured by mutual connections) and the weakest ties (measured by interaction intensity) produced the most job mobility. Beyond a point, more weakness gave smaller added returns. The study also found that strong ties helped more in less digital industries (Rajkumar et al., 2022). Two of the five authors worked at LinkedIn.
- Local peer mentors for small business owners (Early trial, B). A randomized trial in Kenya studied inexperienced women running microenterprises. In the trial, mentoring by an experienced entrepreneur from the same community raised profits by about 20% on average. But the gains faded as the mentoring relationships ended. A formal business class did not raise profits (Brooks et al., 2018).
- Building cross-class friendships (Theoretical, C). A study used 21 billion Facebook friendships. It found that the share of high-income friends among low-income people (economic connectedness) was among the strongest predictors of upward income mobility found to date. The authors estimate that children from low-income families would earn 20% more on average if they grew up in counties with the connectedness of the average high-income child (Chetty et al., 2022a). A second paper found that about half of the class gap in friendships reflects less exposure in schools and groups. That paper found that the other half reflects "friending bias" even with exposure. It also found that more high-income classmates led to more cross-class friendships in schools with low friending bias (Chetty et al., 2022b). The 20% figure comes from associations, not from a tested intervention.
- Not shown to help: school-based mentoring for lasting gains (In wide use, B). A randomized study looked at Big Brothers Big Sisters school-based mentoring with 1,139 students aged 9 to 16 in 10 cities. The study found that after one school year, mentored youth did better in school and more often reported a "special adult." But they showed no improvement in classroom effort, self-worth, relationships, or problem behavior. The academic gains did not last into the second year (Herrera et al., 2011).
- Failed: Cambridge-Somerville Youth Study (Failed or reversed, B). In this early randomized trial, 650 at-risk boys aged 5 to 13 were matched in pairs. One boy in each pair received counseling, activities, and home visits for an average of 5.5 years between 1939 and 1945 (Welsh et al., 2019). Follow-ups in middle age found harmful (iatrogenic) effects in the treated group. The follow-ups found support for contact with deviant peers as a cause (Welsh, 2025). By old age, no significant difference in time to death remained (hazard ratio 1.18, 95% CI 0.98 to 1.41) (Welsh et al., 2019).
Sources cited on this page
- MENTOR: The Mentoring Effect, executive summary (2014) C Limited: advocacy organization data
- Brooks, W., Donovan, K., & Johnson, T. R. (2018). Mentors or teachers? Microenterprise training in Kenya. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 10(4), 196-221. link B Moderate
- Chetty, R., Jackson, M. O., Kuchler, T., Stroebel, J., Hendren, N., Fluegge, R. B., et al. (2022a). Social capital I: Measurement and associations with economic mobility. Nature, 608(7921), 108-121. link C Limited: (B for the association)
- Herrera, C., Grossman, J. B., Kauh, T. J., & McMaken, J. (2011). Mentoring in schools: An impact study of Big Brothers Big Sisters school-based mentoring. Child Development, 82(1), 346-361. link B Moderate
- Rajkumar, K., Saint-Jacques, G., Bojinov, I., Brynjolfsson, E., & Aral, S. (2022). A causal test of the strength of weak ties. Science, 377(6612), 1304-1310. link B Moderate
- Welsh, B. C. (2025). The longitudinal-experimental design and the development and prevention of criminal offending over the life-course: Advances in science and policy from the Cambridge-Somerville Youth Study. Criminal Behaviour and Mental Health, 35(2), 89-94. link B Moderate
- Welsh, B. C., Zane, S. N., Zimmerman, G. M., & Yohros, A. (2019). Association of a crime prevention program for boys with mortality 72 years after the intervention: Follow-up of a randomized clinical trial. JAMA Network Open, 2(3), e190782. link B Moderate
- Bettinger, E. P., & Baker, R. B. (2014). The effects of student coaching: An evaluation of a randomized experiment in student advising. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 36(1), 3-19. link B Moderate
- Fein, D., & Dastrup, S. (2022). Benefits that last: Long-term impact and cost-benefit findings for Year Up (OPRE Report 2022-77). Office of Planning, Research, and Evaluation, US Department of Health and Human Services. link B Moderate
- Kemple, J. J. (2008). Career academies: Long-term impacts on work, education, and transitions to adulthood. MDRC. link B Moderate
- Raposa, E. B., Rhodes, J., Stams, G. J. J. M., Card, N., Burton, S., Schwartz, S., et al. (2019). The effects of youth mentoring programs: A meta-analysis of outcome studies. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 48(3), 423-443. link B Moderate
Every source for this factor is listed on the social factor page.