Discrimination and exclusion
Discrimination and exclusion is a barrier to human progress within the societal factors. The evidence for it, and the methods proposed to address it, follow.
Barriers based on race, gender, class, disability, or other traits keep people from using their abilities. Field experiments send identical applications that differ only in a signal such as a name. These experiments give direct evidence on hiring. Exclusion also works through legal rules, funding decisions, who teaches, and across generations.
Evidence
- U.S. hiring. A meta-analysis of 28 field experiments (55,842 applications) found that since 1989 white applicants received on average 36% more callbacks than African Americans and 24% more than Latinos. It found no change for African Americans over 25 years (Quillian et al., 2017).
- Large employers. Researchers sent more than 83,000 fictitious applications to 108 large U.S. employers. They found that distinctively Black names reduced the chance of contact by 2.1 percentage points. Discrimination was concentrated in a minority of firms (Kline, Rose, and Walters, 2022).
- Wasted talent. In 1960, 94% of U.S. doctors and lawyers were white men. In 2010 the share was 62%. A model-based study estimated that better allocation of talent explains 20% to 40% of U.S. growth in output per person over that period (Hsieh et al., 2019).
- Limits of callback studies. Callbacks capture only the first step. A methodological critique (Heckman and Siegelman, 1993) suggests gaps can be misstated in either direction. Reanalyses using a correction by Neumark (2012) found most estimates robust. However, a Swedish reanalysis found the critique mattered for some studies.
- Law, funding, and schools. Women have about two-thirds (67%) of the legal rights of men worldwide (World Bank, 2026). Black applicants' chance of winning a major NIH grant was about 10 percentage points lower than white applicants' (Ginther et al., 2011). But an unexplained gap is not by itself proof of reviewer bias. Black students randomly assigned a Black teacher in early grades were 13% more likely to graduate from high school (Gershenson et al., 2022).
- Gaps across generations. In U.S. tax and census records, Black boys have lower adult incomes than white boys from families with similar incomes in 99% of Census tracts (Chetty et al., 2020). Studies of redlining and mortgage lending also find lasting gaps. But these studies do not each identify present-day discrimination as the sole cause. Later research disputes whether the 1930s lending maps themselves caused the gaps (Fishback et al., 2021).
What can be done
Actions rated on the strength-rating scale (A strong and replicated, B solid but limited, C weak or debated, D contested or failed), applied to the specific claim made.
- Extending anti-discrimination law to more employers (B for direction, C for size). The Equal Employment Opportunity Act of 1972 extended federal civil rights coverage to employers with 15 to 24 employees. A study compared industries and states by how much of their workforce was newly covered. The industries most affected showed large shifts in employment and pay practices toward African-American workers (Chay, 1998). The effect sizes could not be confirmed from the abstract.
- Removing barriers to voting, the Voting Rights Act of 1965 (B). A study compared counties in states that had to drop literacy tests with counties in other states over 20 years. Counties with larger Black populations saw greater increases in both voter turnout and state funding transfers (Cascio and Washington, 2014).
- Affirmative action requirements for federal contractors (B). A study used the timing of regulation across workplaces. The Black share of employees rose by an average of 0.8 percentage points in the 5 years after a workplace first became regulated. The share kept growing at a similar pace after deregulation. The author links this to employers improving how they screen applicants (Miller, 2017).
- Contested: race-conscious university admissions (C). California's ban on affirmative action in public universities came in 1998. After the ban, underrepresented minority applicants moved to less selective colleges, and their degree attainment and later wages fell (Bleemer, 2022). An earlier study of the same ban found that graduation rates rose, partly through better matching of students to campuses (Arcidiacono et al., 2014).
- Not effective: "Ban the box" rules that hide criminal records on job applications (B). A study used about 15,000 fictitious applications in New Jersey and New York City. At companies that removed the question after the policy began, the white-Black gap in callbacks grew from 7% to 43% (Agan and Starr, 2018). A national study found the policies reduced employment of young low-skilled Black and Hispanic men (Doleac and Hansen, 2020). But a 2025 reanalysis corrected miscoded policy dates. The reanalysis found the result held in the Current Population Survey but not in the larger American Community Survey (Burton and Wasser, 2025) (C for the employment effect).
Proposed and experimental methods
Methods that are proposed, under trial, approved in some places, or tried and then failed. Each shows a stage label and an evidence rating. A stage label shows how far a method has progressed, not whether it works. The stage labels are explained on the societal factor page.
- Search help for families with housing vouchers, Creating Moves to Opportunity (Large trial, B). Helping voucher families move to high-opportunity neighborhoods addresses exclusion by place. See "Inequality and limited mobility" in the economic factors for the trial results.
- Firm-level discrimination audits for enforcement (Theoretical, B). Correspondence audits send matched fake applications that differ only in names. One study sent 83,000 applications to 108 large U.S. employers. It found that applications with distinctively Black names got about 2.1 percentage points less contact. The study also found that gaps varied widely by company and persisted over time. In the study, 23 companies could be identified as discriminating against Black applicants (Kline et al., 2022). The authors suggest such firm-level audits as a tool for targeting enforcement, which has not yet been tested.
- Legal reform of women's economic rights (Approved but not scaled, B). In Ethiopia, a family law reform gave wives more access to marital property and removed limits on working outside the home. The reform was rolled out first in some regions. Women there became significantly more likely to work outside the home and in paid full-time jobs (Hallward-Driemeier and Gajigo, 2015). Worldwide, the 2026 edition of Women, Business and the Law found that women have about two-thirds of the legal rights of men. The report gave average scores of 67 out of 100 for laws, 53 for enforcement, and 47 for the systems needed to implement them, across 190 economies (World Bank, 2026). The 2024 edition, which used a different method, had put legal protections at 64% of men's (World Bank, 2024).
- Mandatory bias audits of hiring algorithms, NYC Local Law 144 (Approved but not scaled, contested, C). New York City's law was the first to require bias audits of automated hiring tools and public posting of results. Student investigators checked 391 employers. They found only 18 audit reports and 13 transparency notices. This was partly because employers decide for themselves whether a tool falls under the law (Wright et al., 2024).
- Failed: Anonymous résumés (Failed or reversed, B). Removing names and other identifying details from applications is meant to stop bias. In an experiment run with the French public employment service, firms that volunteered were randomly given anonymous or named résumés. Firms that got anonymous résumés were less likely to interview and hire minority candidates (in the working paper version, the minority interview rate fell from 9.3% to 4.7%, and the widening of the hiring gap was significant only at the 10% level). This was possibly because anonymization stopped firms from discounting negative signals for minority applicants (Behaghel et al., 2015).
Sources cited on this page
- Quillian, L., Pager, D., Hexel, O., & Midtbøen, A. H. (2017). Meta-analysis of field experiments shows no change in racial discrimination in hiring over time. PNAS, 114(41), 10870-10875. DOI A Strong: for the callback gap
- Quillian, L., Heath, A., Pager, D., Midtbøen, A. H., Fleischmann, F., & Hexel, O. (2019). Do some countries discriminate more than others? Evidence from 97 field experiments of racial discrimination in hiring. Sociological Science, 6, 467-496. Stanford Center on Poverty and Inequality A Strong: for the existence of discrimination, B for country rankings
- Kline, P., Rose, E. K., & Walters, C. R. (2022). Systemic discrimination among large U.S. employers. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 137(4), 1963-2036. DOI B Moderate
- Hsieh, C.-T., Hurst, E., Jones, C. I., & Klenow, P. J. (2019). The allocation of talent and U.S. economic growth. Econometrica, 87(5), 1439-1474. DOI A Strong: for occupational shares, C for the 20% to 40% growth share
- World Bank (2026). Women, Business and the Law 2026 B Moderate: for legal rights, C for enforcement perceptions
- Ginther, D. K., Schaffer, W. T., Schnell, J., Masimore, B., Liu, F., Haak, L. L., & Kington, R. (2011). Race, ethnicity, and NIH research awards. Science, 333(6045), 1015-1019. DOI A Strong: for the gap
- Neumark, D. (2012). Detecting discrimination in audit and correspondence studies. Journal of Human Resources, 47(4), 1128-1157. JHR B Moderate
- Chetty, R., Hendren, N., Jones, M. R., & Porter, S. R. (2020). Race and economic opportunity in the United States: an intergenerational perspective. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 135(2), 711-783. Opportunity Insights A Strong: for the gaps, B for explanations
- Fishback, P., Rose, J., Snowden, K. A., & Storrs, T. (2022). New evidence on redlining by federal housing programs in the 1930s. Journal of Urban Economics, 103462. DOI (working paper version: NBER Working Paper 29244) B Moderate
- Gershenson, S., Hart, C. M. D., Hyman, J., Lindsay, C. A., & Papageorge, N. W. (2022). The long-run impacts of same-race teachers. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 14(4), 300-342. DOI A Strong: for the effect, C for the mechanism
- Walter, B. F., Howard, L. M., & Fortna, V. P. (2021). The extraordinary relationship between peacekeeping and peace. British Journal of Political Science, 51(4), 1705-1722. link B Moderate
- Behaghel, L., Crépon, B., & Le Barbanchon, T. (2015). Unintended effects of anonymous résumés. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 7(3), 1-27. link B Moderate
- Hallward-Driemeier, M., & Gajigo, O. (2015). Strengthening economic rights and women's occupational choice: The impact of reforming Ethiopia's family law. World Development, 70, 260-273. link B Moderate: (changed from C on October 9, 2026)
- Wright, L., Muenster, R. M., Vecchione, B., Qu, T., Cai, P., Smith, A., et al. (2024). Null compliance: NYC Local Law 144 and the challenges of algorithm accountability. In Proceedings of the 2024 ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency (pp. 1701-1713). link C Limited
- Agan, A., & Starr, S. (2018). Ban the box, criminal records, and racial discrimination: A field experiment. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 133(1), 191-235. link B Moderate
- Arcidiacono, P., Aucejo, E., Coate, P., & Hotz, V. J. (2014). Affirmative action and university fit: Evidence from Proposition 209. IZA Journal of Labor Economics, 3, 7. link C Limited
- Bleemer, Z. (2022). Affirmative action, mismatch, and economic mobility after California's Proposition 209. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 137(1), 115-160. link C Limited
- Cascio, E. U., & Washington, E. (2014). Valuing the vote: The redistribution of voting rights and state funds following the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 129(1), 379-433. link B Moderate
- Chay, K. Y. (1998). The impact of federal civil rights policy on Black economic progress: Evidence from the Equal Employment Opportunity Act of 1972. ILR Review, 51(4), 608-632. link C Limited
- Doleac, J. L., & Hansen, B. (2020). The unintended consequences of "ban the box": Statistical discrimination and employment outcomes when criminal histories are hidden. Journal of Labor Economics, 38(2), 321-374. link C Limited
- Miller, C. (2017). The persistent effect of temporary affirmative action. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 9(3), 152-190. link B Moderate
- Burton, A. M., & Wasser, D. N. (2025). Revisiting the unintended consequences of ban the box (Center for Economic Studies Working Paper CES-25-58). U.S. Census Bureau. link B Moderate
Every source for this factor is listed on the societal factor page.