Custodes Futurifor the advancement of humanity

Distrust of expertise

Distrust of expertise is a barrier to human progress within the cultural factors. The evidence for it, and the methods proposed to address it, follow.

Distrust of experts slows adoption of useful knowledge. Most people trust scientists. But where trust is lower, people are less likely to follow expert advice.

Evidence

  • 68 countries. A survey of 71,922 people found that in most countries most people trust scientists. They also want scientists to take a bigger part in society and policymaking. Trust varied within and between countries, partly by political views (Cologna et al., 2025).
  • Public health in 2020. Panel surveys in 12 countries found that trust in scientists was the key driver of support for non-drug public health measures. It was also the key driver of favorable attitudes toward vaccination (Algan et al., 2021).
  • Vaccination intentions. Across 25 national samples (25,334 people), trust in medical and scientific experts was among the strongest correlates of willingness to get a COVID-19 vaccine (odds ratio 1.28). These are stated intentions (Kerr et al., 2021).

Note: The authors of the 68-country study caution that distrust among even a small minority can still affect how policy uses evidence.

What can be done

Actions rated on the strength-rating scale (A strong and replicated, B solid but limited, C weak or debated, D contested or failed), applied to the specific claim made.

  • Context: A major review of vaccination research found that few randomized trials have changed what people think and feel about vaccines. The review found that those that did had minimal effects on uptake. It found that interventions that act on behavior directly (reminders, defaults, incentives, and requirements) were the most plentiful and effective (Brewer et al., 2017b). The proven actions below work around distrust rather than remove it.
  • Vaccination requirements, including ending nonmedical exemptions (B). California tightened personal belief exemptions for school entry and then, in 2016, eliminated them. After that, the share of kindergartners not up to date on vaccinations fell from 9.84% in 2013 to 4.87% in 2017 (Pingali et al., 2019). This was an observational study of three bundled interventions. A synthetic control study of six countries found that mandatory COVID-19 certificates increased vaccinations. The effect was largest where prior uptake was below average and among people under 30. There was no effect in Germany, where uptake was already average (Mills and Rüttenauer, 2022).
  • Modest guaranteed cash payments for vaccination (B). A preregistered trial included 8,286 people in Sweden, linked to population vaccination records. A payment of 200 Swedish kronor ($24) raised COVID-19 vaccination by 4.2 percentage points from a baseline of 71.6%. Behavioral nudges raised stated intentions but not vaccination (Campos-Mercade et al., 2021). It is a single trial in a high-trust country.
  • Train clinicians to recommend vaccines as a routine announcement (B). A randomized trial took place in 30 North Carolina clinics. It covered 17,173 adolescents aged 11 or 12 at the 29 clinics still open six months later. A one-hour training in brief "announcements" that assume parents are ready raised HPV vaccine initiation by 5.4 percentage points over six months. Training in open-ended "conversations" had no effect (Brewer et al., 2017a). Neither training changed other vaccinations or those of older adolescents. Trusted doctors and nurses as messengers are in the proposed methods below.
  • Contested: vaccine lotteries (D). A study compared U.S. states with and without lottery incentives. It found no association between the lotteries and COVID-19 vaccination rates (Law et al., 2022). The study is a short research letter using observational data. Other studies of the same programs disagree. A synthetic control study of 18 lottery states found positive effects on first doses in all but three states. But it found negative or null effects on full vaccination in over half (Fuller et al., 2022). Another synthetic control study estimated that Ohio's lottery raised the vaccinated share of the state population by 0.7 percentage points (Barber and West, 2022). A preregistered synthetic control study of Ohio found a statistically insignificant 1.3% decrease in the full vaccination rate (Lang et al., 2023).

Proposed and experimental methods

Methods that are proposed, under trial, approved in some places, or tried and then failed. Each shows a stage label and an evidence rating. A stage label shows how far a method has progressed, not whether it works. The stage labels are explained on the cultural factor page.

  • Trusted health professionals as messengers (Large trial, B). A trial randomized 820 U.S. counties. In that trial, short Facebook videos recorded by doctors and nurses reached 11,954,109 users at Thanksgiving and 23,302,290 at Christmas 2020. The trial found that travel distance fell by 0.993 percentage points in high-intensity counties and COVID-19 infections fell 3.5% in targeted zip codes. The share of people leaving home on the holiday did not change (Breza et al., 2021). In Oakland, Black men randomly assigned to Black male doctors were much more likely to choose every preventive service after meeting the doctor. The authors estimate this could reduce the Black-white male gap in cardiovascular mortality by 19% (Alsan et al., 2019).
  • Being open about uncertainty (Large trial, B). Five experiments with 5,780 people tested communicating uncertainty about facts and numbers. These experiments found that this produced only a small decrease in trust in the numbers and the source. In these experiments, the decrease came mostly when uncertainty was given in words rather than numbers (van der Bles et al., 2020). A study of 10,519 people found that giving a numeric range around COVID-19 statistics slightly lowered trust in the number but not in the source. In the same study, vague statements that uncertainty exists lowered trust in both (Kerr et al., 2023).
  • Faith leaders as messengers (Early trial, C). A survey experiment in April 2021 included 709 unvaccinated registered voters in South Dakota. The experiment found that an identical pro-vaccine message raised interest in vaccination when attributed to a religious leader. The message did not raise interest when attributed to a political or medical leader (Viskupič and Wiltse, 2022). The experiment measured stated interest, not vaccination, in one state.
  • Open science and transparency to raise trust (Early trial, C). In a German survey of 504 adults, 74.0% said seeing shared materials, data, and code raised their trust in a study. But in an experiment with 588 adults, mentioning open science practices had no significant effect on trust. In that experiment, the mention had only a small effect among those who noticed it (Rosman et al., 2022). In a preregistered experiment with 390 people, an animated video about reforms after the replication crisis raised trust in researchers compared with a video about the crisis alone (d = 0.26). This came after earlier studies using short texts had found that news of reforms did not restore trust (Methner et al., 2023).
  • Not shown to help: political endorsements by scientific journals (Failed or reversed, B). In a preregistered experiment, people were told that the journal Nature had endorsed Joe Biden. The experiment found that this caused large falls in Trump supporters' trust in Nature and in scientists in general. It also found that this reduced their requests for Nature articles on vaccine efficacy. The experiment found small and mostly insignificant gains among Biden supporters, and little change in views of the candidates (Zhang, 2023).

Sources cited on this page

  1. Algan, Y., Cohen, D., Davoine, E., Foucault, M., & Stantcheva, S. (2021). Trust in scientists in times of pandemic: panel evidence from 12 countries. PNAS, 118(40), e2108576118. DOI B Moderate
  2. Kerr, J. R., Schneider, C. R., Recchia, G., Dryhurst, S., Sahlin, U., Dufouil, C., Arwidson, P., Freeman, A. L. J., & van der Linden, S. (2021). Correlates of intended COVID-19 vaccine acceptance across time and countries: results from a series of cross-sectional surveys. BMJ Open, 11(8), e048025. DOI B Moderate
  3. Cologna, V., Mede, N. G., Berger, S., et al. (2025). Trust in scientists and their role in society across 68 countries. Nature Human Behaviour, 9(4), 713-730. DOI B Moderate
  4. Alsan, M., Garrick, O., & Graziani, G. (2019). Does diversity matter for health? Experimental evidence from Oakland. American Economic Review, 109(12), 4071-4111. link B Moderate
  5. Breza, E., Stanford, F. C., Alsan, M., Alsan, B., Banerjee, A., Chandrasekhar, A. G., et al. (2021). Effects of a large-scale social media advertising campaign on holiday travel and COVID-19 infections: A cluster randomized controlled trial. Nature Medicine, 27(9), 1622-1628. link B Moderate
  6. Kerr, J., van der Bles, A. M., Dryhurst, S., Schneider, C. R., Chopurian, V., Freeman, A. L. J., et al. (2023). The effects of communicating uncertainty around statistics, on public trust. Royal Society Open Science, 10(11), 230604. link B Moderate
  7. Methner, N., Dahme, B., & Menzel, C. (2023). The "replication crisis" and trust in psychological science: How reforms shape public trust in psychology. Social Psychological Bulletin, 18, e9665. link C Limited
  8. Rosman, T., Bosnjak, M., Silber, H., Koßmann, J., & Heycke, T. (2022). Open science and public trust in science: Results from two studies. Public Understanding of Science, 31(8), 1046-1062. link C Limited
  9. van der Bles, A. M., van der Linden, S., Freeman, A. L. J., & Spiegelhalter, D. J. (2020). The effects of communicating uncertainty on public trust in facts and numbers. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 117(14), 7672-7683. link B Moderate
  10. Viskupič, F., & Wiltse, D. L. (2022). The messenger matters: Religious leaders and overcoming COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy. PS: Political Science & Politics, 55(3), 504-509. link C Limited
  11. Zhang, F. J. (2023). Political endorsement by Nature and trust in scientific expertise during COVID-19. Nature Human Behaviour, 7(5), 696-706. link B Moderate
  12. Barber, A., & West, J. (2022). Conditional cash lotteries increase COVID-19 vaccination rates. Journal of Health Economics, 81, 102578. link D Contested
  13. Brewer, N. T., Chapman, G. B., Rothman, A. J., Leask, J., & Kempe, A. (2017b). Increasing vaccination: Putting psychological science into action. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 18(3), 149-207. link B Moderate
  14. Campos-Mercade, P., Meier, A. N., Schneider, F. H., Meier, S., Pope, D., & Wengström, E. (2021). Monetary incentives increase COVID-19 vaccinations. Science, 374(6569), 879-882. link B Moderate
  15. Fuller, S., Kazemian, S., Algara, C., & Simmons, D. J. (2022). Assessing the effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccine lotteries: A cross-state synthetic control methods approach. PLoS ONE, 17(9), e0274374. link C Limited
  16. Lang, D., Esbenshade, L., & Willer, R. (2023). Did Ohio's vaccine lottery increase vaccination rates? A pre-registered, synthetic control study. Journal of Experimental Political Science, 10(2), 242-260. link C Limited
  17. Law, A. C., Peterson, D., Walkey, A. J., & Bosch, N. A. (2022). Lottery-based incentives and COVID-19 vaccination rates in the US. JAMA Internal Medicine, 182(2), 235-237. link D Contested: (changed from C on October 9, 2026, because independent analyses of the same lottery programs reached conflicting conclusions)
  18. Mills, M. C., & Rüttenauer, T. (2022). The effect of mandatory COVID-19 certificates on vaccine uptake: Synthetic-control modelling of six countries. The Lancet Public Health, 7(1), e15-e22. link B Moderate
  19. Pingali, S. C., Delamater, P. L., Buttenheim, A. M., Salmon, D. A., Klein, N. P., & Omer, S. B. (2019). Associations of statewide legislative and administrative interventions with vaccination status among kindergartners in California. JAMA, 322(1), 49-56. link B Moderate

Every source for this factor is listed on the cultural factor page.