Cultural value differences
Cultural value differences is a barrier to human progress within the cultural factors. The evidence for it, and the methods proposed to address it, follow.
Hofstede (2001) describes how cultures differ in individualism and in tolerance for uncertainty. No single profile is better overall. Critics argue that treating each nation as one uniform culture oversimplifies (rated C).
Evidence
- Tight and loose cultures. A 33-nation study found that tighter nations tended to have histories of threats. These included dense populations, scarce resources, conflict, and disease. Tightness can help people coordinate, but it leaves less room for nonconformity (Gelfand et al., 2011).
- Disputed measure. A six-country replication found different country rankings (Treviño et al., 2021). Another study argued that the scoring method can distort results (Venaik et al., 2021). The country examples are uncertain.
- Individualism and innovation. A cross-country study used gene frequencies and historic disease prevalence as instruments for culture. It found that individualism raised innovation, productivity, and income per worker. The instruments rest on strong assumptions, so this is rated C (Gorodnichenko and Roland, 2017).
What can be done
Actions rated on the strength-rating scale (A strong and replicated, B solid but limited, C weak or debated, D contested or failed), applied to the specific claim made.
- Sustained, equal-status contact through shared housing and study groups (B). At a large South African university, some white students were randomly assigned a roommate of a different race. These students held fewer negative stereotypes of Black students on implicit association tests and formed more interracial friendships. Black students in mixed rooms earned higher grades, passed more exams, and dropped out less (Corno et al., 2022). At the U.S. Air Force Academy, some white men were randomly assigned to peer groups with higher-achieving Black peers. This made them more likely to choose a Black roommate the next year (Carrell et al., 2019). At a U.S. state university, white students randomly given African American roommates were more likely to support affirmative action and to interact comfortably with minorities. But the samples were too small for definitive evidence (Boisjoly et al., 2006). Contact in sports teams, classrooms, and schools, and its limits, is covered in the proposed methods below and in "In-group bias" in the social factors.
- Carry proven programs across cultures, adapting how the problem is explained rather than rebuilding them (B). Four parenting programs from the United States or Australia were tested in 10 other countries, in 17 trials with 1,558 children. In the 14 randomized trials, effects on child behavior were substantial (SMD -.71). They were at least as large in culturally distant regions, and extensive adaptation did not appear necessary (Gardner et al., 2016). In psychotherapy for ethnic and racial minority clients, culturally adapted therapy did better than unadapted therapy by d = 0.32. Adapting the explanation of the illness was the only feature linked to better results (d = 0.21) (Benish et al., 2011). A broader meta-analysis of cultural adaptation is in the proposed methods below.
- Not effective: brief prejudice reduction and implicit bias exercises (A for little effect on behavior). A network meta-analysis of 492 studies with 87,418 participants found that procedures changed implicit measures only weakly (|d| < .30). It found that they generally produced trivial changes in behavior (Forscher et al., 2019). Nine interventions that reduced implicit racial preferences lost their effect within hours to days (Lai et al., 2016). A review of 418 experiments found that 76% tested light-touch interventions of unclear long-term effect. That review found signs of publication bias (Paluck et al., 2021). One-off diversity training is in "In-group bias" in the social factors.
Proposed and experimental methods
Methods that are proposed, under trial, approved in some places, or tried and then failed. Each shows a stage label and an evidence rating. A stage label shows how far a method has progressed, not whether it works. The stage labels are explained on the cultural factor page.
- Cooperative contact across groups (Large trial, B). A review of 27 randomized studies with outcomes measured at least one day later found that contact typically reduces prejudice (pooled effect 0.39 standard deviations, 24 of 27 estimates positive). The review found that effects were substantially weaker for ethnic or racial prejudice. The review also found that no study tested adults' racial or ethnic prejudice (Paluck et al., 2019). In India, men randomly placed on mixed-caste cricket teams formed more cross-caste friendships and showed less own-caste favoritism. But being randomly assigned opponents from other castes reduced cross-caste interaction (Lowe, 2021). In Iraq, Christians randomly placed on soccer teams with Muslims behaved better toward Muslim peers. They did not behave better in other settings, and attitudes did not change consistently (Mousa, 2020). The overall effect of short depolarization treatments is in "Cognitive dissonance and motivated reasoning" in the psychological factors.
- Culturally adapting programs (In wide use, B). This changes the content, language, or delivery of an intervention to fit the values of the people it serves. A meta-analysis looked at 78 studies with 13,998 participants. The meta-analysis found that culturally adapted psychological interventions outperformed other conditions (g = 0.67) and unadapted versions of the same intervention (g = 0.52). It also found larger effects for treatment than for prevention (Hall et al., 2016). Many comparisons were with no intervention. Whether adaptation affects culture-specific problems has not been adequately studied.
- Not shown to help: transplanting institutions without adapting them (Failed or reversed, C). Across 49 countries, how law was originally received mattered more for the effectiveness of legal institutions than which legal family it came from. Some countries adapted imported law, or their people were already familiar with its principles. These countries had more effective legal institutions, which in turn was linked to development (Berkowitz et al., 2003). The study is a cross-country comparison and cannot show cause.
Sources cited on this page
- Gorodnichenko, Y., & Roland, G. (2017). Culture, institutions, and the wealth of nations. Review of Economics and Statistics, 99(3), 402-416. DOI C Limited
- Hofstede, G. (2001). Culture's Consequences (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. C Limited
- Gelfand, M. J., et al. (2011). Differences between tight and loose cultures: a 33-nation study. Science, 332(6033), 1100-1104. DOI C Limited: for the concept, D for country rankings
- Treviño, L. J., Egri, C. P., Ralston, D. A., Naoumova, I., et al. (2021). A multi-country, multi-sector replication challenge to the validity of the cultural tightness-looseness measure. Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 38(2), 735-764. DOI B Moderate
- Venaik, S., Midgley, D. F., & Christopoulos, D. (2021). Do within-subject standardized indices of societal culture distort reality? An illustration with the national Tightness culture scale. Journal of World Business, 56(5), 101242. DOI B Moderate
- Berkowitz, D., Pistor, K., & Richard, J.-F. (2003). Economic development, legality, and the transplant effect. European Economic Review, 47(1), 165-195. link C Limited
- Hall, G. C. N., Ibaraki, A. Y., Huang, E. R., Marti, C. N., & Stice, E. (2016). A meta-analysis of cultural adaptations of psychological interventions. Behavior Therapy, 47(6), 993-1014. link B Moderate
- Lowe, M. (2021). Types of contact: A field experiment on collaborative and adversarial caste integration. American Economic Review, 111(6), 1807-1844. link B Moderate
- Mousa, S. (2020). Building social cohesion between Christians and Muslims through soccer in post-ISIS Iraq. Science, 369(6505), 866-870. link B Moderate
- Paluck, E. L., Green, S. A., & Green, D. P. (2019). The contact hypothesis re-evaluated. Behavioural Public Policy, 3(2), 129-158. link B Moderate
- Benish, S. G., Quintana, S., & Wampold, B. E. (2011). Culturally adapted psychotherapy and the legitimacy of myth: A direct-comparison meta-analysis. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 58(3), 279-289. link B Moderate
- Boisjoly, J., Duncan, G. J., Kremer, M., Levy, D. M., & Eccles, J. (2006). Empathy or antipathy? The impact of diversity. American Economic Review, 96(5), 1890-1905. link C Limited
- Carrell, S. E., Hoekstra, M., & West, J. E. (2019). The impact of college diversity on behavior toward minorities. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 11(4), 159-182. link B Moderate
- Corno, L., La Ferrara, E., & Burns, J. (2022). Interaction, stereotypes, and performance: Evidence from South Africa. American Economic Review, 112(12), 3848-3875. link B Moderate
- Forscher, P. S., Lai, C. K., Axt, J. R., Ebersole, C. R., Herman, M., Devine, P. G., & Nosek, B. A. (2019). A meta-analysis of procedures to change implicit measures. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 117(3), 522-559. link A Strong
- Gardner, F., Montgomery, P., & Knerr, W. (2016). Transporting evidence-based parenting programs for child problem behavior (age 3-10) between countries: Systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology, 45(6), 749-762. link B Moderate
- Paluck, E. L., Porat, R., Clark, C. S., & Green, D. P. (2021). Prejudice reduction: Progress and challenges. Annual Review of Psychology, 72, 533-560. link B Moderate
Every source for this factor is listed on the cultural factor page.